You must set the ad_network_ads_405.txt file to be writable (check file name as well).
Which of these comic book plots is fake? [Archive] - HCRealms

PDA

View Full Version : Which of these comic book plots is fake?


Kalel21
03/03/2005, 16:38
Of these three dinosaur-related comic book plots, two of them are real and one is just made up. Which is the fake?

1. Turok and Andar are still searching for a way out of the lost valley when they are attacked by a T-Rex in a heavily wooded area. Because of the trees, they have trouble getting a clear shot with their poison-tipped arrows. Turok is nearly chomped before Andar finally sinks an arrow into the carnosaur’s neck. The next day, Turok insists he and Andar practice their archery skills and they spend many hours perfected their aim and making trick shots.

Later, they find a white chalk line running across the open ground. When Turok bends down to touch it, boomerang wielding natives leap from their hiding places and capture him. To punish him for violating the “magic” that brings game to their land, the natives tie him up as a sacrifice to the next big carnosaur that comes along.

Andar escapes and his archery skills come into play. He kills a carnosaur about to eat Turok with a long shot. He splits the ropes binding Turok, then shoots an arrow between the legs of an approaching native to trip him and give Turok time to escape. Turok returns the favor by knocking a razor sharp boomerang out of the air just before it brains Andar.

The two friends escape and Turok awakes the next morning to find Andar faithfully practicing with his bow and arrow.


2. During World War II, a plane load of American paratroopers fly into an area where an earlier plane had vanished mysteriously. The plane is attacked by a pteradatcyl and torn out of the air. Only a small number of paratroopers manage to bail out and they end up floating on a wing of the plane, armed with small arms and a bag of bazooka rockets.

They spot another trooper in the water, holding bazooka over his head. Badly wounded, he manages to hand off the bazooka to the others before going under. With this weapon, the soldiers manage to fight off several dinosaurs and even save a damage, low-flying fighter plane from an attacking sea serpent. But their bazooka ammo runs out.

They don’t know if the plane saw them and so don’t know if help is coming. The next day, they find a small (VERY small—a few yards across) island and go ashore. Soon, they are attacked by a large sea serpent that begins eating chunks out of the island. In the nick of time, the plane they rescued yesterday drops a bomb on the monster. Soon after, a submarine arrives to rescue the surviving soldiers.

3. A half-dozen large interstellar merchants from an alien planet are damaged in a magnetic storm. Superman arrives and, linking them together with an enormous chain, begins to tow them home. But an engineer aboard one of the ships makes an ill-advices attempt at emergency repairs. An out-of-control hyperdrive tosses Superman through a black hole. He ends up on the surface of a planet with a red sun.

Powerless, Superman discovers the primitive world is still in its dinosaur age. For several weeks, he manages to fend off meat-eaters and gather enough fruit and other eatables to survive. Eventually, he encounters a tribe of intelligent, magic-using velociraptor-like creatures.

At first, they attack Superman and he has to run for it. But then he rescues a young raptor from a T-Rex and earns the tribe’s friendship. After learning enough of the language to communicate, Superman tells them his troubles. The tribe’s witch doctor uses a magic spell to teleport Superman into deep space, where he regains his powers. Finishing his rescue of the stranded space ships, he then heads for home.

Ignatz_Mouse
03/03/2005, 16:45
I'm going to guess #3 is fake. Although it sound similar to a real Superman story, Captive of the Red Son in which he ends up in Earth's far future, when the Sun has cooled to Red.

batfink
03/03/2005, 16:54
I *think* I read about 2 in your book. It was a radio serial,right?

Kalel21
03/03/2005, 16:57
Originally posted by batfink
I *think* I read about 2 in your book. It was a radio serial,right?

Nope, it's a comic book.

Gee whiz, I'll have to start giving pop quizes to people who have read my book.

;)

JacinB
03/03/2005, 17:04
I think they're all actual stories.

Kalel21
03/03/2005, 17:05
Originally posted by JacinB
I think they're all actual stories.

No, I'm not that evil. One of them is really a fake.

Kalel21
03/03/2005, 17:49
I'll bump this thread in the morning to give anyone else interested a chance to play, then post the correct answer a little later on in the day.

Originally posted by batfink
I *think* I read about 2 in your book. It was a radio serial,right?

It JUST came to me. You're most likely thinking of an episode of the radio series "X Minus One" titled "A Gun for Dinosaur." I mention in in the appendix has being a particularly good example of how effective radio drama was.

If this is the case, at least I know you read my book all the way to the end, so you get a gold star for the day.

:grin:

Ultimate2099
03/03/2005, 17:53
Originally posted by Kalel21
I'll bump this thread in the morning to give anyone else interested a chance to play, then post the correct answer a little later on in the day.



It JUST came to me. You're most likely thinking of an episode of the radio series "X Minus One" titled "A Gun for Dinosaur." I mention in in the appendix has being a particularly good example of how effective radio drama was.

If this is the case, at least I know you read my book all the way to the end, so you get a gold star for the day.

:grin:
X-Minus One was one of my favorite Old Time Radio shows.

Oh, and I'm guessing Story 3 is the fake.

Kalel21
03/04/2005, 11:03
Anyone else want to give this a try before I post the correct answer?

Croaker
03/04/2005, 11:11
I'm saying #1 is fake. The other two just sound Sooooo plausible.

skyounkin
03/04/2005, 11:19
I say the first one is fake.....

SpakSpang
03/04/2005, 11:22
I am guessing number 1 is fake. Yeah, Turok the dinosaur hunter seems to have plots like that, but the other two stories are so farfetched they have to be real.

After all, that is usually the point of these threads...and besides there were some really strange stories back in the day with super hero comics.

Kalel21
03/04/2005, 13:10
Well, I fooled some of you. #1 is real, from Gold Key's Turok, Son of Stone #80. #2 is real, from Star Spangled War Stories #93, when the wonderfully silly War That Time Forgot series was the regular feature of that book.

#3 was the fake. As Ignatz Mouse guessed, I borrowed one of the plot points from the Captive of the Red Sun story.

How about these three? Two are real and one is fake--all DC this time:

1. After Lana follows Clark around hoping to catch him switching into Superboy, she begins to write an article exposing her suspicions. When Lana's father catches her he laughs at her ideas that meek and mild Clark is the Boy of Steel, then he gets angry with her for even wanting to expose Superboy's identity. He says that even if she didn't print the article in might accidentally fall into the wrong hands and damage Superboy's career and endanger his parents. Ready to spank his "stupid" daughter with a brush, Professor Lang changes his mind thinking her too old for it, and instead punishes her by cutting off all her privileges. First he grounds her from going on dates for a solid month, then he takes away all her record albums for an entire month, as well. Then, he takes away all her teen magazines and forbids her to have any in-between-meal snacks! Brooding in her room, Lana vows to discover Superboy's identity, if only for her own satisfaction. She creates a Superboy Identity Detection Kit and, several days later, follows Clark to a cave. Waiting in the bushes outside, she sees Clark go into the cave, then sees Superboy fly out! When Superboy returns, Lana enters the cave and accuses Clark of being Superboy. But to Lana's amazement, Superboy steps out from behind some machinery and stands next to Clark. In an attempt to expose Clark, Lana starts doing tests on him. After successfully burning Clark's supposedly friction-proof tie and cutting a lock of his supposedly invulnerably hair, Lana accuses the "Superboy" of being a robot. Standing them behind a fluoroscope screen Lana sees that Clark is human and that Superboy's body cannot be penetrated by the rays. Lana runs out of the cave humiliated and vowing never again to suspect Clark of being Superboy. After she departs, Clark and Superboy burst out laughing as it is soon revealed that "Clark" was really Superboy's Legion pal, Chameleon Boy in disguise. He had come back in time to write an anecdote for the Super Heroes Club newspaper and he got one!

2. Superboy, using his time viewer, learns that one day Oliver Queen will become the Green Arrow. Coincedentally, a young Ollie Queen visits Smallville. Clark tries to encourage him to practice archery, but Ollie is hopelessly bad at it. At a costume party, Ollie comes dressed as Robin Hood. A criminal robs a bank nearby and Ollie pursues him. Clark talks him into putting a boxing glove at the end of one of his arrows so he won't accidentally injure someone else if he misses. Ollie, though, knocks out the crook and thus is encouraged to continue to practice archery. The germ of the idea of using trick arrows is also planted in his mind.

3. A young Bruce Wayne, training for his life of crime-fighting, becomes more and more arrogant about his abilities. Slowly, he comes to think of himself as superior to the average person. He also comes to think of the person who killed his parents as his real "parent," leading him on a path that made him the superior person he is. Returning to Gotham City, he adopts the identity of Batman in order to take over the underworld and become the reigning master criminal of the city. Working out of the Batcave, he builds an organization that terrorizes Gotham. His butler, Alfred, continues to serve him out of family loyalty, but eventually his conscience leads him to start sending clues to Batman's true identity to the police in the form of riddles. Meanwhile, Batman has met Joe Chill when Chill joins his gang. Recognizing Chill as his true "father," Batman makes him his second in command. But his entire gang is more and more fearful of Batman because of his increasingly impossible standards of perfection that he places on everyone. He's ordering the deaths of his minions for the smallest perceived mistakes. The story ends when Joe Chill leads an assassination attempt against Batman just as the police, lead to Wayne Manor by Alfred's riddles, launch a raid. In the ensuing battle, Chill and Alfred are killed. Batman is captured and sent to Arkham, his mind completely broken by the fact that his "father" as betrayed him.

JacinB
03/04/2005, 13:16
This one is number 2. He used his time-viewer to determine that Bruce Wayne would one day become Batman.

:)

nofx242
03/04/2005, 13:40
I will say # 2 I think I read a discription for story # 3 somewhere. Number 1 sounds like your typical old comic tale.

Clix776
03/04/2005, 13:47
#1 is true, as is #3, an Elseworlds tale. #2 is fake this time.

Glad to see you're bringing this game back, Kalel21. I enjoy it every time it comes up.

Have a Great Day,
Gary E. Poisson

Kalel21
03/04/2005, 13:59
Originally posted by Clix776
#1Glad to see you're bringing this game back, Kalel21. I enjoy it every time it comes up.

Have a Great Day,
Gary E. Poisson

Thanks for the kind words. I enjoy doing these.

Ignatz_Mouse
03/04/2005, 14:10
#3 is fake. I think I've read the other two!

AbeSapien
03/04/2005, 14:30
I remember the time viewer and I remember him using it to show themselves as batman and superman in the future. So I think you've done another altered story to confuse us. I vote #2 as the false one.

Croaker
03/04/2005, 14:49
I'm going with #2, though I really want to go with 3 b/c Igantz picked it, and he's usually right!

Kalel21
03/04/2005, 15:27
Gotcha!!! Fooled everyone except for the apparently omnicient Ignatz. (This could cause a crisis of faith on my part--will I eventually be obligated to convert from Christianity to Ignatzianity?)

#1 & #2 are from different 1950s issues of Adventure Comics (CREDIT: I copied the plot summary for #1 off a web site that I now can't relocate in order to properly credit.) Yes, Superboy did use his time viewer to see heroes in the future other than Batman.

#3 is the fake. Though I have to say that I'm insufferably proud of myself in coming up with what I think would be a really cool Elseworlds plot.

If anyone else would like to give this a try as the creator of a false plot, I wouldn't mind playing this from the other end.

Ignatz_Mouse
03/07/2005, 16:39
Ignatz is short for Ignatius, a name usually taken by Jusuits after the founder of the order, Ignatius Loyola. Christianty is a fine religion, besides, having a cartoon mouse of ill repute as a deity doesn't sound like a good idea!