PDA

View Full Version : Copyright law is interferring with my comic book reading pleasure


Kalel21
01/10/2006, 13:47
A month or so ago, Marvel publishes an Essential Marvel Two-in-One, the comic from the 1970s where Ben Grimm teamed up with other Marvel heroes.

It covers the first 25 issues, except that issue 21 is missing without explanation. This even makes for a continuity gap, since #22 picks up with Ben still dealing with the consequences of the previous issue.

I own a copy of #21. Ben's team up that issue was with Doc Savage, the pulp magazine hero from the 1930s. Marvel, during the 1970s, had the rights to do Doc Savage stories and even published a short-lived comic and black-and-white magazine of his adventures.

But Marvel no longer has the rights to use the character, which apparently means they can't even reprint the old stuff. Thus a gap appears in the flow of the storytelling in the Essential reprints.

When I saw that, I remembered that Doc also appeared in a Giant-sized Spider Man from the same time period. I checked and, sure enough, that issue is missing from the Spider Man Essentials.

Then, this past week, Dark Horse puts out the 9th volume of the TPBs in which they are reprinting the old Marvel Conan series. Dark Horse currently owns the comic book rights to Conan and (I assume) must have worked something out with Marvel to reprint these older stories.

EXCEPT---three consecutive issues are missing from this volume. Why? Because those issues guest-starred an appearance by Red Sonya, a character who yet another company recently required the comic book rights to.

So, despite the fact that Dark Horse reprinted the earlier Red Sonya appearances in the old Conan series, suddenly they can't anymore. What makes this personally annoying for me is that I had never read those particular issues and was looking forward to doing so.

Copyright laws can occasionally be annoying. :angry:

HollywoodGhost
01/10/2006, 18:30
I'll fight the copy write laws for you

Stainawarjar
07/29/2009, 08:28
I'll fight the copy write laws for you

And that was the last post he made...

readyeddy?
07/29/2009, 14:44
So you're saying, he really is a hollywood ghost?

BudPalmer
07/29/2009, 14:52
Have you tried reading more current comic books? It could save you some of that frustration (and replace it with a whole 'nother kind that more people could relate to). ;)

Kalel21
07/29/2009, 15:42
Why is everyone necro-posting on a 2 1/2 year old thread? I mean, I know I'm the most fascinating member of HCRealms and you all live for the ecstacy of being able to read one of my posts, but THIS is the sort of thing that might inadvertantly call up zombies or something.


I already have TV Land ninja assassins after me. I don't need zombies as well.

readyeddy?
07/29/2009, 15:48
The issue as I see it, is did Hollywood Ghost meet foul play while attempting to combat the copyright laws? It seems to me that you have a tantalizing mystery on your hands Kal.

Kalel21
07/29/2009, 15:54
I suspect the TV Land ninja assassins got him.


Or, perhaps, a TV Land zombie ninja assassin got him.

readyeddy?
07/29/2009, 16:49
I suspect the TV Land ninja assassins got him.


Or, perhaps, a TV Land zombie ninja assassin got him.
Now you're leaping to conclusions. Would Holmes or Poirot do that?

What you COULD do, is your best Mike Hammer impression and beat the info out of somebody.