PDA

View Full Version : What should [insert hero here] do?


Kalel21
11/03/2006, 09:55
I'm not sure if anyone will find this to be a fun game, but here goes:]

The idea is to take a story from any source (TV, movies, comics, etc) in which the story climaxes with the hero in a seemingly hopeless situation. Then, without giving away what the hero did to handle the situation, ask "What should he/she do?"

Others will post their opinions/plans on what the hero should do. The first person to come reasonably close to what the hero actually did wins. (The original poster decides who was "reasonably" close.) The winner can then post his own "What should the hero do?" problem.

Here's the first:

In an episode of the radio version of "Gunsmoke," Marshal Dillon arrests an outlaw for stage robbery and murder. The man had an unidentified accomplice, but no one can prove who that was. The outlaw threatens to rat out his partner in unless he arranges a jail break.

Dillon knows a jail break attempt is probably coming, so he hires two men to sit with shotguns in front of the jail and a third man to cover the back. Then he hides the key to the jail, not even telling his deputy Chester where it is.

But the outlaw's partner hires a skilled gunman to help. While Dillon is away from the jail, they knock out the backdoor guard and get the drop on Chester. The two men in front have no idea this is happening inside.

When Dillon returns, he's captured and disarmed. He refuses to tell where the key to the door is,so the gunman gets a rope and ties a noose around Chester's neck. He threatens to hang the deputy unless Dillon tells them where the key is.

So two bad guys have their six-shooters trained on Dillon. Chester has a noose around his neck while the outlaw still locked behind bars holds the other end of the rope and gets ready to heave away.

What should Dillon do?

CornsilkSW
11/03/2006, 11:30
let them go, then shoot them in the back as they ride off.

it's how the west was really won.

BoyGenius 1991
11/04/2006, 09:20
he should tell chester to jump off the stool or whatever he's on, the acceleration would pull on the rope with more force than the guy actually weighed, so the bad guy would drop the rope, and then Chester could leap forwards and kick the 2 guys with their guns trained on Dillon in the back of the head before they know what's going on, then they'd drop their guns and Dillon could pick them up and pop the bad guys in the feet a couple of times, so they can't get up or run away. The guy behind bars would remain so and Dillon would remain so.

I've only listened to 2 episodes of gunsmoke, the one where they amputated that guy's leg and the one with the cabin and Belle, so I don't know if this is in character for Dillon, but I know that he doesn't want to kill people himself, he'd rather watch someone else hang them to death, so that's why I typed what I typed.

By the way, Kale21, thanks a lot for the old time radio disc, I am enjoying it very much. But it only works on my computer, why won't it work on my portable CD player?

Kalel21
11/04/2006, 18:20
By the way, Kale21, thanks a lot for the old time radio disc, I am enjoying it very much. But it only works on my computer, why won't it work on my portable CD player?

It's not a regular CD, but MP3 format. That means you can put a lot of stuff on it, but it won't play in most regular CD players. I'm glad you're enjoying it, though.

BoyGenius 1991
11/20/2006, 20:07
okay, so, was I right?

batfink
11/21/2006, 10:54
Hmm, I've never heard this one. Whats the title?

Dillon dives for the rope punching the guy in the cell. Both gunman miss, but the rukus they cause alerts the two deputies outside.

Kalel21
11/21/2006, 10:58
Hmm, I've never heard this one. Whats the title?



"Chester's Hanging."

Boygenius was probably closest. Dillon waits for the moment when the bad guys start to haul away on the rope, knowing that Chester will not be immediately killed. (He'll strangle slowly rather than having his neck snapped.)

Dillon uses the distraction of that moment to jump the gunman and knock him down. Then he runs to the front room, yelling for the guy with the shotgun standing guard there. The guard runs in and blasts the gunman as he is chasing Dillon into the front room. Dillon then borrows the guards six-gun and faces down the other two men, who don't have the skill or the guts to stand up to him. They surrender.