HCRealms Mafia, Volume 2

[Scott Neelan]

Y'know what, if this is a "villain played against villain" moment, I don't wanna be a part of it. If I'm going out, then fine, I'm going out.

Change Vote: No Lynch

[DocDoom187]

and now, you're gonna try and make us all look like badies, and walk away safe. it will probably work too...

[Scott Neelan]

Nope, I've just decided that I'm going out on my terms. I'm not trying to take anyone with me. I'm not assuming that JoH is the "bad" guy for suspecting me. I'm just resigned to my fate.

[DocDoom187]

Peers, can you just make a mod decision. LOL. I'm getting antsy!!!

[Scott Neelan]

The day phase doesn't force/mod end until sometime tomorrow. There are a few people who haven't chimed in yet anyway (Thawmus and Jacin being the most notable and most previously vocal, Doombot as well)

[Peers]

... what sort of mod decision? Did I miss something?

[DocDoom187]

... what sort of mod decision? Did I miss something?
IDK. use your mod power to end the day phase. I'm going nuts waiting

[Jackofhearts2005]

No kidding. We're this close to winning. We don't need Peers to kill anybody for us.

Besides, the day phase has only lasted all of half an hour. :cheeky:

[Peers]

IDK. use your mod power to end the day phase. I'm going nuts waiting

... I can kill you, if you want.

[DocDoom187]

No kidding. We're this close to winning. We don't need Peers to kill anybody for us.

Besides, the day phase has only lasted all of half an hour. :cheeky:
THEN GET SOME ONE TO VOTE!


I know doombots a villain. WHERE IS HE!?!

[DocDoom187]

... I can kill you, if you want.
yes.. KILL KILL!!



MUAHAHAHAHAHA

[Scott Neelan]

... I can kill you, if you want.

Only if he's the last threat against the villains, so we can win before they lynch me.:cheeky:

[DocDoom187]

Only if he's the last threat against the villains, so we can win before they lynch me.:cheeky:
either way you die.....

[Scott Neelan]

I get the feeling that I'll get lynched, someone will die at night, JoH wil lget lynched...and everyone will be amazed as the game goes on, as neither JoH or I were the last remaining threat. We'll end up having been played against each other rather successfully, and whoever's in it for themselves will win.

[Jackofhearts2005]

As long as Scott, Jacin, or I (the only unconfirmed villians) die today and DocDoom really is the cop, we can't lose.

I'd rather die than let DocDoom die at this point, so don't suicide yourself. :p

[DocDoom187]

There's no way in hell that would happen. If it does I would be, and probably Jack would too, blown away. I would have no clue what to do. But atleast only 4 would be left. We'd win pretty quickly.

[DocDoom187]

As long as Scott, Jacin, or I (the only unconfirmed villians) die today and DocDoom really is the cop, we can't lose.

I'd rather die than let DocDoom die at this point, so don't suicide yourself. :p
Thats a team player


*virtua high-five*

[Scott Neelan]

Since this is AR, and I'm about to die, I might as well go out with this:

"Goodbye cruel world,
I'm leaving you today.
Goodbye,
Goodbye,
Goodbye.

Goodbye, all you people,
There's nothing you can say
To make me change my mind.
Goodbye."

Pink Floyd - Goodbye Cruel World

[Jackofhearts2005]

I get the feeling that I'll get lynched, someone will die at night, JoH wil lget lynched...and everyone will be amazed as the game goes on, as neither JoH or I were the last remaining threat. We'll end up having been played against each other rather successfully, and whoever's in it for themselves will win.
That can't happen unless DocDoom is a liar.

Right now we have.
1) KitsuShel
2) JackofHearts2005
3) Doombot 3.1
4) JacinB
5) Thawmus
6) DocDoom187
7) Scott Neelan

Lets say we lynch you and Doom dies at night (just so that we get no more information).

That leaves us with.
1) KitsuShel
2) JackofHearts2005
3) Doombot 3.1
4) JacinB
5) Thawmus

Then lets say we lynch me and then....lets say Thawmus dies at night.

That leaves us with
1) KitsuShel
2) Doombot 3.1
3) JacinB

Then, Shel and Doombot lynch Jacin, since Jacin wasn't confirmed as a villian by DocDoom. We win, and this is even assuming that my power is going wack, that both of us are evil, and that Grey Gargoyle forgets to do anything at night.

I think it is much more likely that we kill you and win
OR We kill you and you are some random character, neither Tick Tock, nor a threat. Then, DocDoom scans me at night. The killer cannot prevent this, since the Grey Gargoyle is protecting DocDoom. Then, DocDoom tells everyone I'm a villian, and we lynch Jacin, who is the last unconfirmed person at that point.

I'm not saying Jacin isn't on our side, I'm just saying that he is the only guy other than you and myself that hasn't been looked at by DocDoom.

[Scott Neelan]

Yeah, I'm having fun with this. I'm practically dead anyway...so why not go out with a little flair?

"Have you heard the news that you're dead?
No one ever had much nice to say
I think they never liked you anyway
Oh take me from the hospital bed
Wouldn't it be grand? It ain't exactly what you planned.
And wouldn't it be great If we were dead?
Ohh dead."

My Chemical Romance - Dead

[Scott Neelan]

Nah, I'm Tick Tock. You'll find that out when you get the last vote on your side and lynch me.

[DocDoom187]

Jack I was thinking the same thing. But i figured if i say Jacin might possibly be a threat people may stupidly vote for him instead of Scott.

[Scott Neelan]

Can I vote to lynch myself and get it overwith? Is that legal?

[Peers]

Can I vote to lynch myself and get it overwith? Is that legal?

Legal but due to something like that happening in another game I played in, highly disadvised. As in, I won't let you play anymore. :)

[DocDoom187]

Can I vote to lynch myself and get it overwith? Is that legal?
It is in fact legal. It would be appreciated to end the game quickly ;)

[Jackofhearts2005]

You can always check Jacin or me tonight. GG has your back.

[DocDoom187]

Legal but due to something like that happening in another game I played in, highly disadvised. As in, I won't let you play anymore. :)
Care to expound upon that Peers?


Peers, you know you started a new trend. Sstralkoswki did a Wild West one, and now, people who played in his are starting a star wars, and star trek ones. LOL


In 10 years the realms will still be playing mafia games.

[Scott Neelan]

Legal but due to something like that happening in another game I played in, highly disadvised. As in, I won't let you play anymore. :)

In that case, since I want in on the inevitable followup game, I'll regretfully leave my vote as-is and not commit suicide, despite using my ability to look into the future to see my own death coming...:cheeky:

[Peers]

Care to expound upon that Peers?

It will forever be infamously known as "The Aussie Experiment". It began as an attempt to decide if someone who roleclaimed as preist was, in fact, a preist. It ended with a suicide-by-lynch, an auto-lynch with a suicide pact, and a whole lot of "WTF?"s.

[DocDoom187]

It will forever be infamously known as "The Aussie Experiment". It began as an attempt to decide if someone who roleclaimed as preist was, in fact, a preist. It ended with a suicide-by-lynch, an auto-lynch with a suicide pact, and a whole lot of "WTF?"s.
You must have misread my post. I said "expound" not "confuse the hell outta me" :p :p

[Jackofhearts2005]

It will forever be infamously known as "The Aussie Experiment". It began as an attempt to decide if someone who roleclaimed as preist was, in fact, a preist. It ended with a suicide-by-lynch, an auto-lynch with a suicide pact, and a whole lot of "WTF?"s.
That's pretty crazy, dude.

[DocDoom187]

That's pretty crazy, dude.
I still don't really get what happened.....

[DocDoom187]

SOMEONE ELSE PLEAZ VOTE!!!!!!!!


I know some people are online right now. I'm going nuts.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I still don't really get what happened.....
A suicide lynch meaning that a guy voted to kill himself, but since he was part of a suicide pact, the other members of the suicide pack were also killed.

Imagine if Scott voted to lynch himself and then him, Thawmus, and Shel died.

Wouldn't you be like "WTF?!?"

[DocDoom187]

A suicide lynch meaning that a guy voted to kill himself, but since he was part of a suicide pact, the other members of the suicide pack were also killed.

Imagine if Scott voted to lynch himself and then him, Thawmus, and Shel died.

Wouldn't you be like "WTF?!?"
Yea. I realized eventually. Thanks though.


Can SOMEONE vote....PLEASE

[DocDoom187]

I'm gonna cry if we don't do something soon. lol



I'm going crazy waiting!!!

[Scott Neelan]

It's only been a couple hours. Give a guy a break, will ya? Even condemned criminals get a last meal...

[KitsuShel]

I'm gonna cry if we don't do something soon. lol



I'm going crazy waiting!!!

How bout you go to bed?

:cheeky:

[Peers]

Actually, it was "If Player B dies, so do I. But if I vote for Player B, the day ends and they're lynched right away. Why doesn't anyone believe me? Fine, I'll prove it." But right before that, someone -else- had voted to lynch themselves. So after two days, we had lost three townies and still didn't know if the guy in question really was the priest or not...

[DocDoom187]

How bout you go to bed?

:cheeky:

Haha. I'm over anxious, but last game I was murdered, cuz I role claimed to save my arse. This time I'm gonna be around for the end!

[DocDoom187]

Actually, it was "If Player B dies, so do I. But if I vote for Player B, the day ends and they're lynched right away. Why doesn't anyone believe me? Fine, I'll prove it." But right before that, someone -else- had voted to lynch themselves. So after two days, we had lost three townies and still didn't know if the guy in question really was the priest or not...
Wow. Atleast there was a good element of mystery. lol

[Jackofhearts2005]

Actually, it was "If Player B dies, so do I. But if I vote for Player B, the day ends and they're lynched right away. Why doesn't anyone believe me? Fine, I'll prove it." But right before that, someone -else- had voted to lynch themselves. So after two days, we had lost three townies and still didn't know if the guy in question really was the priest or not...
:rolleyes: :laugh: BWAHAHAHAHAHA

It's only been a couple hours. Give a guy a break, will ya? Even condemned criminals get a last meal...
But you aren't a condemned criminal. We're the criminals. :devious:

[Scott Neelan]

Yes, and so am I. And it's my head on the chopping block. Which means I'm a condemned criminal...

[DocDoom187]

Lies!!!!!!!

[Scott Neelan]

I'd show you my original PM if it was legal to do so. Heck, I'd show you ALL my PMs. I'm not lying, and you're about to condemn yet another (not so) innocent man.

But hey, it's in the name of the game, right? Off me if you wish. I'm headed to bed...hopefully when I come back, I"ll still be alive. If not, then good luck finding the real final threat.

[DocDoom187]

I'd show you my original PM if it was legal to do so. Heck, I'd show you ALL my PMs. I'm not lying, and you're about to condemn yet another (not so) innocent man.

But hey, it's in the name of the game, right? Off me if you wish. I'm headed to bed...hopefully when I come back, I"ll still be alive. If not, then good luck finding the real final threat.
Thanks man. Good Night. I doubt anything will happen until tommorow.

[Jackofhearts2005]

But hey, it's in the name of the game, right?
Right, right. I won't hold it against anyone for killing my virtual self and I certainly hope everyone else feels the same. :cool:

[Thawmus]

Hey, I'm on!

So now I can vote, hooray!


Vote: JacinB

When the killing picked up again, there was really only one answer.

[DocDoom187]

Hey, I'm on!

So now I can vote, hooray!


Vote: JackofHearts2005




What, that didn't resolve anything? Too bad. Have a good night. :laugh:
I.... HATE YOU SO MUCH RIGHT NOW:angry: :angry: :angry: :angry:


Change vote thawmus. :p


not serious.


I;m actually not surprised in the least. I expected you to vote JackoHearts. I've been waiting for Jacin and Doombot, as I'm almost positive one of those 2 will vote Scott.

[DocDoom187]

Thawmus edited!!!!!!



He voted Jack.


He probably realized that that might be a serious vote in thje end, so he changed it to Jacin to be safe.

[Thawmus]

Let me make sure I understand JoH, Kitsushel, and Doc correctly here...

So Scott's powers WERE detected the first night, and they match up with the character he's roleclaimed as. On top of this, he's been able to ascertain things that have done nothing but help us take out 3 heroes and one independent.

But we also believe that he's capable of killing people without a single trace.

[Thawmus]

Thawmus edited!!!!!!



He voted Jack.


He probably realized that that might be a serious vote in thje end, so he changed it to Jacin to be safe.

Actually, I had an epiphany.




And I was still reading posts..........

[DocDoom187]

Let me make sure I understand JoH, Kitsushel, and Doc correctly here...

So Scott's powers WERE detected the first night, and they match up with the character he's roleclaimed as. On top of this, he's been able to ascertain things that have done nothing but help us take out 3 heroes and one independent.

But we also believe that he's capable of killing people without a single trace.
Or, you could look at it as his powers were detected the first night, but we don't know if he's telling the truth about his powers, and he claims to have targeted me, but JoH has proof that he's lying. So if Scott's Really who he says he is, JackofHearts most probably lied. He was gunning for Scott, then all of a sudden made a discovery that incriminated Scott. So its one of those 2 in mine, and probably Shel's, book. Kill one, and either game over, or we know who the liar is, and the next day hase we'll lynch him and win.


You're just being difficult Thawmus.

Scott will probably be lynched, for good reasons. Just be the final vote.

He claims to have some kind of prophetic visionary powers. That power may exist, but it may not be his. Seeing s he lied about his target, what good reason would he have to lie about his target?

[Peers]

I repeat: DO NOT EDIT POSTS FOR ANY REASON!!! That's been one of the rules from the begining, people...

[DocDoom187]

Because of these games, I see Peers as some sort of Omnipotent one, on a higher level than us all :p



Whenever he posts anywhere now, I make sure I se what he posts :laugh:



PS: Give Thawmus a smelly Metal Toed Boot!!!!

jk ;)

[Scott Neelan]

I never lied about my powers, but apparently can't prove it sufficiently for you, JoH, or Shel. Ah well, I'm probably dead here soon anyway.

Wait, I said I was going to sleep? I tried, I failed. I'm back for the moment.

Glad to see someone's playing the voice of reason...unfortunately, logic and reason can be twisted to protect me or to support lynching me. So again, probably gone. At least my death will prove JoH lied for whatever reason, and lead to the end of the game somehow.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Let me make sure I understand JoH, Kitsushel, and Doc correctly here...

So Scott's powers WERE detected the first night, and they match up with the character he's roleclaimed as. On top of this, he's been able to ascertain things that have done nothing but help us take out 3 heroes and one independent.

But we also believe that he's capable of killing people without a single trace.
I don't know about that. I detect the influnce of characters, not players. For all I know, I have found evidence of Scott's handiwork.

Here is my reasoning for lynching Scott:

I didn't find any evidence of an information gatherer on DocDoom. This worried me. I was thinking that Scott was going to target DocDoom, since he said he did.

Scott revealed that he was Tick Tock and claimed he had targeted DocDoom on night 3, as planned.

However, I found no evidence of Tick Tock on DocDoom. Both you (Thawmus) and I expressed concern that I might not be able to find evidence of Tick Tock at all. Since we had another night, I figured I would try to find out who Jacin is.

I targeted Purple Man. This was a mistake, since Jacin never targeted Purple Man. By sheer dumb luck, I found evidence of Tick Tock on Purple Man. This confirmed that I can find evidence of Tick Tock. Therefore, Tick Tock never targeted DocDoom.

Now Scott says he's Tick Tock, and Scott says he targeted DocDoom on night 3, but I KNOW that Tick Tock didn't target DocDoom on night 3.

Therefore, I vote for Scott.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Aaaaand I'm going back to bed.

[Thawmus]

Tell you what, let's have a trade-off.

I'll vote for Scott, and you guys hear me out during the night phase.

I have an idea.

Vote: Scott.

[Doombot 3.1]

Wow, you guys had a busy night. :)

If JoH2005 has found evidence of Tick Tock, and Tick Tock is not Scott, who the hell is Tick Tock, and why hasn't he spoken up?

In any event, I think the only way to move forward is to kill Scott and see if he was telling the truth. Nothing personal, Scott, but I will

VOTE: Scott Neelan

[Thawmus]

Wow, you guys had a busy night. :)

If JoH2005 has found evidence of Tick Tock, and Tick Tock is not Scott, who the hell is Tick Tock, and why hasn't he spoken up?

In any event, I think the only way to move forward is to kill Scott and see if he was telling the truth. Nothing personal, Scott, but I will

VOTE: Scott Neelan

Yeah, I'm pretty much 100% positive that we're way off track here. but I know who our killer is. So as a show of faith, I need to let them have their lynching.

[Scott Neelan]

So now can I post the PM I got as a result of being Tick Tock and targetting DocDoom?

[Scott Neelan]

Sorry, I guess being accused of lying when I know I'm telling the truth gets under my skin in a game just as much as in any other situation. Ah well...it's been fun, guys, and I'll see you in the next game.

[Thawmus]

Sorry, I guess being accused of lying when I know I'm telling the truth gets under my skin in a game just as much as in any other situation. Ah well...it's been fun, guys, and I'll see you in the next game.

Yeah, I hear ya. I got a little peeved earlier, even after admitting the hole I dug myself.

And I don't think there's any question about how hopping mad Doc's gotten at times here.

I know you're not the killer, but all the same, these guys just won't listen to reason. So I'm hoping they will after they see their error.

[Peers]

Day 6 is over!

There were seven of them, and only one had the finger of suspicion thrown at him. Maybe it was through pure disinformation, maybe it was a well-laid plan, but the short, portly, balding man using the alias of Scott Neelan was quickly surrounded and rendered no longer living.

Scott Neeland is dead. He was Tick Tock, Villain-Aligned Viewer Of Four Future Timelines

"Tonight," somebody said, "We should all stay together, so Cloak doesn't get one of us."

The answer was the loud clack of rounds being chambered. Doombot, Thawmus, and JackofHearts turned around to see pistols leveled at each of their heads, held by KitsuShel, JacinB, and DocDoom.

GAME OVER!

"What the he--"

"Quiet. In all the commotion, you boys forgot why we all came here in the first place... to divide up The Kingpin's old holdings. Well, I've decided... we're not splitting them up at all. They're mine... and these two? They're going to help me run things."

"Y-you aren't going to just kill us, right? We could be helpful... I helped protect your man over there from Bullseye!"

*clik-clack* "We'll see. But first? Go spread the word. The Maggia is back in business... and we own this town now."

Three cheers for our winners, the Maggia of KitsuShel, JacinB, and Docdoom187!

I know, I know, you're thinking "There was a second entire Mafia?" Well, let's reveal the roles.

The Arrested With all the killing, these three got off easy.
--kontrol was Gypsy Moth, and as theorized later in the game, was a roleblocker.
--Iron Ham was Calypso. Each night, he could pick a target, and a dead body to use on them. Whatever that body's power was, he would 'get' for the night and use on his target. He just couldn't know for sure what power each body had.
--Rokk_Krinn was Man-Bull, who could gore someone to death each night in an attempt to not look like a joke.

The Lynched
--Vicious X was Rattler. He was looking for respect... every successful lynch he was a part of, he would have gained a point. As he earned points, I would tell him what he could spend them on... for 1 point, get someone to confide in him what their power was. For 2 points, kill someone at night. For 3 points, cause an auto-lynch during the day. But you guys never let him get any, lynching him first.
--scehano was Moon Knight. He could either go beat someone up, preventing them from posting or voting in the next day, or sit back and the first person to target him would get beat up, with similar results. This only happened once, and I don't think anyone really noticed as that day phase went by fairly quickly.
--antipathy was Bullseye. He could kill someone each night, but if he hit Daredevil, it would be a standoff and Daredevil got a bonus power usable only to hunt down Bullseye. Interesting fact: Daredevil almost won, but changed his target before the night phase was over, and Bullseye survived long enough to finish off DD. He just couldn't do it until all the other Knights were down. he also was on official Thunderbolts business, and they just wanted everyone, villain or unregistered (well, Widow was registered, but who cares?) hero dead.
--Scott Neelan was Tick Tock, a member of the Night Shift who could see one minute into the future... four different possible futures. He could either try to figure out what someone was doing, or who they were doing it to, but he rarely got a clear picture... a fun power for me to play with, as he got to see the alternate future where Daredevil didn't change his mind and arrested Bullseye.

The Just Plain Killed
--theanalogkid was Ben Reily. He wasn't with the Knights, so he got amnesia, too. Each night, he could pick someone to 'out' himself to. If it was a Knight, they would recruit him onto the team. If not, well, he just outed himself to a villain. It didn't matter... Calypso got lucky and sicced a zombie Dagger on him.
--BigSoph was Firebrand, and Bullseye's first kill. He could make a single kill during the game... and he would set off the building's sprinkler system if he did so, meaning nothing else would happen that night, including arrests. It would have been a useful tool to stall the Knights with, but he went up in flames on the first night.
--TMNT99 was Purple Man, out to use his mind control powers to recruit people. Sheer bad luck saw him try to recruit JacinB on the first night and get gunned down. Had he been able to target two people and keep them (and himself) alive, then he would have formed another Mafia with himself as Don.
--JackAssterson was Black Widow, and once again, he was the Mafia's roleblocker. Completely at random, I swear. Oddly enough, Jack changed the course of the game before he died, roleblocking Calypso before her arrest. Calypso's target that night? Kitsushel, who would have been burned by Firebrand's zombie. If that had happened, the Maggia would have never been formed...
--St-Dumas was Daredevil, the Knights' "Don". He was also the Priest... he couldn't cast the final vote to lynch someone. he wanted to arrest, not kill. Once Bullseye found him, Bullseye became a priority... each night, in addition to the arrest, he could PM me the name of someone who he thought was Bullseye; if he was right, Bullseye would get arrested instead. He actually picked antipathy one night, then changed his mind. So Tick Tock got a vision of that happening...
--Melkhor was AC-DC, possibly the most obscure character here. AC-DC was a British pair of siamese twins with electrical powers. His vote did count double, as people later figured out... but as he was British and nobody knew him, he would turn up 'Hero' if investigated... or rather, 'Not Villain'. Didn't matter, nobody ever did.

The Surviving Losers
--Doombot 3.1 was The Grey Gargoyle, our 'doctor' for the game. He almost seemed to be teaming up with Thawmus and Melkhor for a bit, but protected DocDoom most of all. If he hadn't, Daredevil would have gotten DocDoom before Bullseye got him, and we'd've had to go at least one more turn. After the game, he'll probably be recruited into the Maggia.
--JackofHearts was Doc Ock, using hsi science skills to examine corpses for evidence of who had dealings with them before their death. unfortunately, he thought this meant -player- names... he was a bit deflated when he got -character- names instead. Although this did tell him a few names before anyone else figured them out. The Maggia will probably keep him around as well.
--Thawmus was Tombstone, and as he said, he has rock-hard skin. Man-Bull found that out, and seeing people freak out about The Thing was worth it. Regardless, nobody tried to kill him for the rest of the game... and when Gypsy Moth and Black Widow both went down quickly, he was pretty much safe as long as he didn't get lynched. The Maggia -might- keep him around... they'll need muscle.

THE WINNERS!
--JacinB was Wrangler. I'll wait a moment for you to go look that up. Basicly, a cowgirl with guns and a lasso who was in way over her head and decided to shut herself up in her room each night, shooting anyone who came after her. She was Purple Man's first target... but didn't realize she only had one night's worth of real bullets. The rest were blanks. If someone else had gone after her, they'd've succeeded... but nobody did until she was recruited into the Maggia.
--DocDoom187 was Tracer, probably the most recently-created character here. His mastery of machiens meant he could investigate someone each night to learn if they were Knight, Villain, or Independant. The only time he used this power on a hero was the night Daredevil died, so it didn't help much. But he did wind up killing AC-DC, which took away the one thing that could really stop the Maggia... and the man who could have saved AC-DC was working on saving him instead.
--KitsuShel was Hammerhead, and she had no power. At first. There were a handful of people (Tracer, Tick Tock, Gargoyle, Reily) who, if they targetted her, would manage to jog her memory and let her pick two people to recruit into her own Mafia group. She was scanned by Tracer on Night 2, and apparently totally at random picked him as one of her recruits on Night 3. If JacinB hadn't only had one night's worth of ammo, tho, she'd've been killed trying to recruit him, so Kitsu came close to death at least twice and managed to survive to win the game.

[Thawmus]

I never lied about my powers, but apparently can't prove it sufficiently for you, JoH, or Shel.

That's because one of those three is the killer.

[Thawmus]

Dammit, I knew it.

I was going to lynch Kitsushel the next day, for being Hammerhead, and starting up the Maggia.

I didn't figure it out until JoH said something about Hammerhead being around.

What I didn't know was that she was recruiting people. :ermm:

[Iron Ham]

Man, if I hadn't been roleblocked, the entire game would have been MUCH different...

And night 2 would have only 1 killing, being Shel.

[DocDoom187]

Peers, I'm in the Mafia, not Doombot!!!!




It was ME Shel and Jacn!!!!!



I'm hurt!

[Peers]

Peers, I'm in the Mafia, not Doombot!!!!

It was ME Shel and Jacn!!!!!

I'm hurt!

Ummm......

Fixed.

[DocDoom187]

Dammit, I knew it.

I was going to lynch Kitsushel the next day, for being Hammerhead, and starting up the Maggia.

I didn't figure it out until JoH said something about Hammerhead being around.

What I didn't know was that she was recruiting people. :ermm:
Yea!!!


Awesome game. We got you guys:laugh:


In the beginning, You guys were VERY wrong. I WAS a villain, and telling the truth, but when shel asked me to join her, I realized that now that I've convinced you all, I could kill, and no one would even think about it ;)



Peers, as always, THANKS!


Awesome, can't wait for the next one.

[DocDoom187]

Ummm......

Fixed.
THANX!!!


hehehe

[Doombot 3.1]

Congrats to the winners! I totally did not see the second Mafia (Maggia) coming.

[Thawmus]

And I just want to apologize to Rokk, once again, for getting him arrested.

I'll be sure to drop hints next time, buddy.

[DocDoom187]

Yo Thawmus. Now that the game's over, No hard feelings, right?



Same sentiment to everyone incase I offended you or something in the course of the game.

[kontrol]

Yeah she was the this version(Mafia 2's) of the Skrull.

It was painful towards the end not being able to vouch for Scott. I picked him the first night, but since I got arrested couldn't say anything about recognizing him. I knew from my first night that he was either Night Shift or Reformed Thunderbolt (leaning towards Night Shift since my character was Gypsy Moth and not Skein).

I don't know if we would have formed a group though. I rather doubt it actually, the two were never really nice to each other. Tick Tock actually capturing her at a point in their history.

The one thing this game should teach you is to trust no one unless you have absolutely definitive solid proof. Roles and alignments can change on you.

[kontrol]

Congrats to the winners.

The Crisis should be interesting.

[DocDoom187]

Kontrol ,it wouldn't have mattered. Whoever JoH voted for, as long as it wasn't one of us three, me Shel and Jacin would have voted for, and won.

[Melkhor]

Oh well, thanks for standing up for me throughout it all Thawmus, we really did make a good team :)

If only Doombot had covered my back on that last fateful night we could have strung up Kit together and brought this home in the end. Alas, it was not to be.

[Rokk_Krinn]

Know what was at least fun for me after dying?

Seeing everyone accuse Scott of being on a team with me despite the fact that -neither- of us ever said we were teammates. :grin:

[Doombot 3.1]

Oh well, thanks for standing up for me throughout it all Thawmus, we really did make a good team :)

If only Doombot had covered my back on that last fateful night we could have strung up Kit together and brought this home in the end. Alas, it was not to be.

Yeah, that was definitely a mistake on my part. :o What can I say? I really had no idea that there was a second mafia running around--I thought we were dealing with Cloak or an independent, so I opted to protect our cop. Which in hindsight was not a particularly brilliant idea. :cheeky:

[DocDoom187]

LOL. Doombot. I loved how that turned out! There's a certain satisfaction in knowing I was protected by my opposition.

[KitsuShel]

Wow, that really could have went a lot differently because of just one or two actions.

Jacin was a complete carp shoot, if he had had real bullets, I'd have been screwed.

And Doc is more of a liability that an asset, fyi. ;)

[kontrol]

Kontrol ,it wouldn't have mattered. Whoever JoH voted for, as long as it wasn't one of us three, me Shel and Jacin would have voted for, and won.
True, the other three would have had to been on board with what I would say, but I was surprised when Hammerhead got mentioned and nobody really ran with it. On a threat assessment level in a Mafia game, Hammerhead seems higher than Tick Tock.

I'll say this, the more players the more fun it gets. I hope the Crisis is a doozy and that I get to play a couple of nights at least.

[JackAssterson]

Yeah, that's right, Jack the professional mafia roleblocker changed the course of the game. Boo-ya.

Not that it helped the good guys much, but what can I say? I thought Hammy was Man-Bull/Rhino, and I really wanted to take out Man-Bull since he was a wild card. How ironical was my all-too-quick demise. :sleep:

[kontrol]

Know what was at least fun for me after dying?

Seeing everyone accuse Scott of being on a team with me despite the fact that -neither- of us ever said we were teammates. :grin:
That was funny. But it is the paranoia level of this game makes it so much fun.

[DocDoom187]

Wow, that really could have went a lot differently because of just one or two actions.

Jacin was a complete carp shoot, if he had had real bullets, I'd have been screwed.

And Doc is more of a liability that an asset, fyi. ;)
So totally not funny.


If I haven't vouched for you so much, you probably would have been Strung Up, and you know it.

[Rokk_Krinn]

Still think I should have tried to kill someone my final night but I was hoping that a protector/roleblocker would watch over me rather than the tracker (as I'd noted and dropped hints that if more than one person went after me I could be in trouble...but, alas, Doom187 was more valuable to you guys than a hitman. :) )


Not that it helped the good guys much, but what can I say? I thought Hammy was Man-Bull/Rhino, and I really wanted to take out Man-Bull since he was a wild card. How ironical was my all-too-quick demise.

It's almost becoming tradition for me to try and remove you via the second night. First game you became a Skrull the second night so I had to lead a lynch against you during the day phase. This time I just killed you. :) Hopefully next game we can actually be allies again and stay allies for more than a night or so.

[sstralkowski]

Yeah she was the this version(Mafia 2's) of the Skrull.

Ahhh, those wiley skrulls. Alignment switching is a fun aspect of the game.

[kontrol]

Still think I should have tried to kill someone my final night but I was hoping that a protector/roleblocker would watch over me rather than the tracker (as I'd noted and dropped hints that if more than one person went after me I could be in trouble...but, alas, Doom187 was more valuable to you guys than a hitman. :) )

Who would you have targeted?

[JackAssterson]

Hopefully next game we can actually be allies again and stay allies for more than a night or so.

I'd be happy with just being a townie for once. Heck, I'd be happy with just not being the Mafia Role-Blocker. :laugh: I initially thought Peers was kidding when I got the PM.

[Rokk_Krinn]

Who would you have targeted?

Honestly, I was going to go after Doom187 as I felt he was just being a liability to the villains and his info wasn't matching up. Once I knew he was protected though I was thinking Antipathy as I had reasons to believe he wasn't on my side. Decided to just hole up though as A) if I was wrong and killed an ally that would've cinched a lynching for me and B) figured if someone -did- go to protect me, it wouldn't help them if I was off hunting someone.

[DocDoom187]

I'd be happy with just being a townie for once. Heck, I'd be happy with just not being the Mafia Role-Blocker. :laugh: I initially thought Peers was kidding when I got the PM.
Yea, its kinda funny how me, you, and Jacin, all had VERY similar powers.

[kontrol]

Ahhh, those wiley skrulls. Alignment switching is a fun aspect of the game.
Yeah, it throws everything you thought about the game out the window. You switching to a Skrull was probably the most confusing part of that game for me. Though I probably should've gone with my first instinct on Doombot instead of the consensus of lensnart. Wouldn't have gotten you, but I wouldn't have died either.

It was a stroke of genius to dupe the tracker that night I protected him.

[Iron Ham]

I still wish I had more time to wreak havoc with my powers.

I had the coolest mafia power, ever. PERIOD.

[DocDoom187]

These things are sooo funny if you read them beggining to end.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Well, as it turns out, I knew the identities of all surviving players except JacinB.

I'm still confused about why I didn't get evidence from Tick Tock on DocDoom.

Good game, folks.

[Melkhor]

Yeah, that was definitely a mistake on my part. :o What can I say? I really had no idea that there was a second mafia running around--I thought we were dealing with Cloak or an independent, so I opted to protect our cop. Which in hindsight was not a particularly brilliant idea. :cheeky:

Would it have changed anything if I had specifically asked for protection (because I certainly considered it)?

Regardless, I had a great time with this game, and I don't think I made any particular critical mistakes (other than the unfortunate lynching of Vicious) either.

When I first got my role I was concerned I was going to be summarily lynched as soon as someone looked in my general direction before my power would have had any impact, so I'm glad that wasn't the case :)

[DocDoom187]

I still wish I had more time to wreak havoc with my powers.

I had the coolest mafia power, ever. PERIOD.
Yea, you had the power to potentially have any power in the game!


But you died


'points finger and does a Nelson laugh'

"ha ha!!"

[JackAssterson]

Yea, you had the power to potentially have any power in the game!


But you died


'points finger and does a Nelson laugh'

"ha ha!!"

Hmm. Put it that way and I feel a little better about missing Man-Bull.

:cool:

[Jackofhearts2005]

Anyone else want to see Scott's PMs now?

Cause I think those would be awesome.

[DocDoom187]

Hmm. Put it that way and I feel a little better about missing Man-Bull.

:cool:
That's what I'm good at, making people feel better about themselves


....mainly at my own expense :(


:p

[Rokk_Krinn]

Regardless, I had a great time with this game, and I don't think I made any particular critical mistakes (other than the unfortunate lynching of Vicious) either.



All respect meant towards Vicious but I don't think that was a mistake. Yes, we didn't necessarily buy his ID story - I admit, I'm the one who "pshawed" that the most - but he was busy screaming for lynching of people we were relatively certain of being villains. Heck, even when it was pointed out to him, he'd just switch to whomever and say "I want a lynch." That's not only really suspicious behaviour but a tad too "wildcard" in a game like this - you don't want someone on your team deciding to lynch you just because he wants more power points.

So anyone figure out who my teammates were yet? :)

[Doombot 3.1]

Would it have changed anything if I had specifically asked for protection (because I certainly considered it)?


I doubt I would have changed my mind because I really just did not see the second mafia (Maggia) angle. I was working from the very flawed assumption that the threat to the villains was Cloak (or some other Marvel Knight) or an independent. Consequently, it seemed to me that the cop would have been most useful in finding who the remaining hero/independent was. The possibility that someone else had recruited another mafia family never entered my mind, and I was really quite surprised by Peers' last write-up for this game.

[JacinB]

THE WINNERS!
--JacinB was Wrangler. I'll wait a moment for you to go look that up. Basicly, a cowgirl with guns and a lasso who was in way over her head and decided to shut herself up in her room each night, shooting anyone who came after her. She was Purple Man's first target... but didn't realize she only had one night's worth of real bullets. The rest were blanks. If someone else had gone after her, they'd've succeeded... but nobody did until she was recruited into the Maggia.
That's what you think.

Others might suspect that there was a reason I threw down the 'Don't attack me or I'll kill you card' at the beginning ...

;)

[DocDoom187]

That's what you think.

Others might suspect that there was a reason I threw down the 'Don't attack me or I'll kill you card' at the beginning ...

;)
Dude, whether or not that was luck, it was BRILLIANT ;)

[vicious x]

Dammit, I knew it.

I was going to lynch Kitsushel the next day, for being Hammerhead, and starting up the Maggia.

I didn't figure it out until JoH said something about Hammerhead being around.

What I didn't know was that she was recruiting people. :ermm:

haha all three people that I wanted to lynch :) well JacinB and Doc were recruited but if you all listen to me we would have lynched Kit :) and would have won :p good game well played by all

[Thawmus]

haha all three people that I wanted to lynch :) well JacinB and Doc were recruited but if you all listen to me we would have lynched Kit :) and would have won :p good game well played by all

Yeah, I've thrown at least two lynch votes at any of those three as well, but I can't honestly say that I was ever serious about a single one of them.

[Scott Neelan]

My PMs weren't all that interesting, though, if Peers doesn't mind I can post 'em up here.

I didn't see the Maggia angle coming, though I had kinda twigged onto something being up with JoH and DocDoom being the most vocal about lynching me...and then Shel coming out of nowhere to agree with them without any discussion whatsoever. But hey, that's what makes this game the fun time it is. Half the stuff that happens comes out of nowhere on you.

[DocDoom187]

My PMs weren't all that interesting, though, if Peers doesn't mind I can post 'em up here.

I didn't see the Maggia angle coming, though I had kinda twigged onto something being up with JoH and DocDoom being the most vocal about lynching me...and then Shel coming out of nowhere to agree with them without any discussion whatsoever. But hey, that's what makes this game the fun time it is. Half the stuff that happens comes out of nowhere on you.
Meh, I saw the ending coming....

:laugh: :grin: :grin: :p

[Scott Neelan]

For the ehck of it, I'm gonna post my Night 4 PM up here, the one where I got to watch BullsPathy kill DareDumas.

"You watch the four possible futures that you can see... and every single one of them shows Antipathy brutally killing St-Dumas in various fashions that make you vomit whenever you even -think- of looking at your watch for the rest of the night."

[JackAssterson]

For the ehck of it, I'm gonna post my Night 4 PM up here, the one where I got to watch BullsPathy kill DareDumas.


Guess that makes me the Jack Widow. Hee.

[Scott Neelan]

Yeah, but what sounds better, Tick Neelan, or Scott Tock?

[Thawmus]

Yeah, but what sounds better, Tick Neelan, or Scott Tock?

Scott Tock, definitely.


Thawstone, or Tombmus?

[Scott Neelan]

Go with Thawstone...it's catchy and much easier to pronounce.

[TMNT99]

Yea, I had a completely non-lethal power, and was a villian, and yet I picked the worst possible choice for targets!

[CarlosMucha]

Well, if it keeps Carlos away then its a keeper. ;)


:eek:


:(


....

[St-Dumas]

I was gonna get rid of Antipathy, but then scehaono PM's me and says "No. Do Rokk instead."

It was smart, but I would have preferred to get rid of Bullseye rather than just the psycho.

[Melkhor]

Scott Tock, definitely.


Thawstone, or Tombmus?

Hey, quit taunting me with your fancy composite names! What on Earth am I supposed to do with my characters name?

[Jackofhearts2005]

Lets elaborate a bit on the ending
Day 6 is over!
"Tonight," somebody said, "We should all stay together, so Cloak doesn't get one of us."

The answer was the loud clack of rounds being chambered. Grey Gargoyle, Tombstone, and Doctor Octopus turned around to see pistols leveled at each of their heads, held by Hammerhead, Wrangler (who's pistols were empty), and Tracer.

GAME OVER!

Are you sure the right team won, Peers? ;)

I don't think all three of them with pistols could take any one of us. :p

[Melkhor]

Lets elaborate a bit on the ending

Are you sure the right team won, Peers? ;)

I don't think all three of them with pistols could take any one of us. :p

Actually, now that you mention it, you're absolutely right. Doc Ock, Grey Gargoyle AND Tombstone would make mince-meat out of those poor saps in less time than it took me to write this :)

[Rokk_Krinn]

I think Grey and Tombstone can just sit back and watch Ock drop them.

Though, y'know, for a nuclear physicist his power was surprisingly biological. :)

[Jackofhearts2005]

I think Grey and Tombstone can just sit back and watch Ock drop them.


My pleasure. :devious:

Hammerhead ruined my wedding. :mad:

[Melkhor]

In fact, I remember back in Spider-Man when Tombstone came back. The first thing he did was break down the door to Hammerhead's office, pound his bodyguards to mush, make Hammerhead cry "uncle", toss him out of town and take over his criminal organisation.

As I recall, all that took him about two pages :)

[Jackofhearts2005]

Alternate ending 1:

Doc Ock laughs and uses three tentacles to grab each pistol and smash them.
He uses the other to make himself some coffee.

Then he takes three tentacles and grabs each of his enemies' arms.
Then he uses the other to stab each of them through the heart.

Winners: Doc Ock, Grey Gargoyle, Tombstone

Alternate Ending 2:
Grey Gargoyle laughs and then turns all three of them to stone.
Then he breaks them.

Winners: Doc Ock, Grey Gargoyle, Tombstone

Alternate Ending 3:
Tombstone grins and then beats all three of them to death.

Winners: Doc Ock, Grey Gargoyle, Tombstone

[Thawmus]

Since I forgot to ever mention it, my real power never saw the light of day.

I was both immune to killings AND arrests. I still can't believe nobody ever called my bluff, or took the bait. It would have saved us some time to converse a bit more.

[Melkhor]

Alternate ending 1:

Doc Ock laughs and uses three tentacles to grab each pistol and smash them.
He uses the other to make himself some coffee.

Then he takes three tentacles and grabs each of his enemies' arms.
Then he uses the other to stab each of them through the heart.

Winners: Doc Ock, Grey Gargoyle, Tombstone

Alternate Ending 2:
Grey Gargoyle laughs and then turns all three of them to stone.
Then he breaks them.

Winners: Doc Ock, Grey Gargoyle, Tombstone

Alternate Ending 3:
Tombstone laughs and then beats all three of them to death.

Winners: Doc Ock, Grey Gargoyle, Tombstone


Small correction to Alternate Ending 3: Tombstone can't really laugh since he can't produce noises louder than a whisper. He can grin though :p

[Thawmus]

Small correction to Alternate Ending 3: Tombstone can't really laugh since he can't produce noises louder than a whisper. He can grin though :p

Can you imagine if I had a drawback that didn't allow me more than two posts during the day period?


I would have gone friggin' nuts.

[Melkhor]

Can you imagine if I had a drawback that didn't allow me more than two posts during the day period?


I would have gone friggin' nuts.

Oh man, that would have been pure torture. Along the same line, if Echo had been in the first game (or this one), she should have been required to put everyone in the game on her ignore list since she can't hear them! :)

Unless Bendis is writing her, that is...

[Jackofhearts2005]

****ing Bendis *grumble grumble*

[JacinB]

Why does it stink of sore loser in here ... ?

:cheeky:

[Doombot 3.1]

Alternate ending 1:

Doc Ock laughs and uses three tentacles to grab each pistol and smash them.
He uses the other to make himself some coffee.

Then he takes three tentacles and grabs each of his enemies' arms.
Then he uses the other to stab each of them through the heart.

Winners: Doc Ock, Grey Gargoyle, Tombstone

Alternate Ending 2:
Grey Gargoyle laughs and then turns all three of them to stone.
Then he breaks them.

Winners: Doc Ock, Grey Gargoyle, Tombstone

Alternate Ending 3:
Tombstone grins and then beats all three of them to death.

Winners: Doc Ock, Grey Gargoyle, Tombstone

You must spread some Reputation around before giving it to Jackofhearts2005 again.

[DocDoom187]

Why does it stink of sore loser in here ... ?

:cheeky:
You smell that too?


:laugh:

[DocDoom187]

I just looked. I have 277 posts in this thread.


WOW

[Doombot 3.1]

--theanalogkid was Ben Reily. He wasn't with the Knights, so he got amnesia, too. Each night, he could pick someone to 'out' himself to. If it was a Knight, they would recruit him onto the team. If not, well, he just outed himself to a villain. It didn't matter... Calypso got lucky and sicced a zombie Dagger on him.


I was bored and re-read the Game 2 summary. This jumped out at me. What an awful power to have.

[Thawmus]

I was bored and re-read the Game 2 summary. This jumped out at me. What an awful power to have.

Well, keep in mind that he didn't HAVE to out himself. He could have faked his way until the end, and suddenly bolstered the Mafia numbers.

I mean, let's face it. My list would have given him a roadmap to who he really needed to out himself to.

[Melkhor]

Well, keep in mind that he didn't HAVE to out himself. He could have faked his way until the end, and suddenly bolstered the Mafia numbers.

I mean, let's face it. My list would have given him a roadmap to who he really needed to out himself to.

Heh, I wonder what would have happened if Calypso had tried to re-animate poor Ben and have him use his awesome power on his target? :laugh:

[Doombot 3.1]

Well, keep in mind that he didn't HAVE to out himself. He could have faked his way until the end, and suddenly bolstered the Mafia numbers.

I mean, let's face it. My list would have given him a roadmap to who he really needed to out himself to.

I realize that he didn't have to out himself, but even so, there's very little upside to that power. The best case scenario is that he would become one of the Marvel Knights, but without any other ability. The best he could hope for was that he'd be recruited into another faction, which doesn't seem very impressive when compared to some of the other abilities we've seen (immunity to being night-killed, ability to recruit others, tracking, etc.). Ben Reilly was really in a tough spot.

[Thawmus]

I realize that he didn't have to out himself, but even so, there's very little upside to that power. The best case scenario is that he would become one of the Marvel Knights, but without any other ability. The best he could hope for was that he'd be recruited into another faction, which doesn't seem very impressive when compared to some of the other abilities we've seen (immunity to being night-killed, ability to recruit others, tracking, etc.). Ben Reilly was really in a tough spot.

Yeah, I hear ya there.

Of course, he didn't have the unfathomable luck of roleclaiming someone else's role, which had NEVER been witnessed before........ :ermm:

You had come off so fishy to me the whole game, and then when you finally made an appearance, it all made sense. I was the fishy one. :laugh:

[DocDoom187]

Well look at Shel. Until her memory was refreshed she was powerless. Maybe once Reily joined the Marvel Knights he'd "suddenly remember what his powers were" or something to that effect, and get a new power.

[Peers]

Actually, Reily would have gotten another power had he joined the Knights, depending on how the game was going. If either Widow or Moon Knight was dead, he'd get a duplicate of their power. But I figured no way he'd guess right without at least one of them being dead.

[DocDoom187]

Actually, Reily would have gotten another power had he joined the Knights, depending on how the game was going. If either Widow or Moon Knight was dead, he'd get a duplicate of their power. But I figured no way he'd guess right without at least one of them being dead.
Callled it!



*Virtua high fives Peers!*


:grin:

[Jackofhearts2005]

I know I've already asked this but...how come I didn't figure out that Tick Tock had targeted DocDoom?

Was Scott lieing? Was the dark figure that found the memory dust and remembered how to move/how people moved me and I learned how to detect Tick Tock from that?

Those are the only things I could think of. :ermm:

[Scott Neelan]

That's something I've been wondering myself, as I certainly wasn't lying. I have the PM to prove it:

"You see four possible futures. In one, you see docdoom187 sending a flood of tiny machines tou scan someone. In another, you see him talking to a security camera. In a third, you see him blasting someone with a laser. And in the final, you see Daredevil attacking Bullseye and whupping his butt. You don't know how that one got in there..."

[Antipathy]

I know I've already asked this but...how come I didn't figure out that Tick Tock had targeted DocDoom?

Was Scott lieing? Was the dark figure that found the memory dust and remembered how to move/how people moved me and I learned how to detect Tick Tock from that?

Those are the only things I could think of. :ermm:

The dark figure was me. I was sniffing memory dust in order to remember how to kill Daredevil.

Due to me not remembering Daredevil's radar sense, if I had targeted Daredevil with no Knights being killed, then I would've had a 50/50 chance of being arrested, or running away with the knowledge that I had to kill 2 Knights in order to be able to kill Daredevil. If one Knight was killed, then I would just have a stand-off, and would need to kill one more knight. Many thanks, Rokk.

Targeting DareDumas on night 2 is probably one of the main reasons I lost. IMO the serial killer should try to go after townies at the beginning. However, I was forced to try to eliminate the mafia, because I was pretty sure Daredevil gained a new power that could arrest me.

I actually had switched my target that night to Iron Ham, but decided to change it back to St. Dumas.

I had figured out scehaono was another Knight, due to having very few posts, and then suddenly voting JacinB with no reason given. Unfortunately, I got beaten up that night due to Moon Knight's power, and couldn't post the next day.

JoH, I knew who Daredevil was, but Daredevil didn't know who I was. If you look back at the night 2 writeup, you see that I am speaking from the shadows, while Daredevil is in clear view of me. That meant Daredevil knew I was there, but couldn't tell who I was, while I could.

[Peers]

I know I've already asked this but...how come I didn't figure out that Tick Tock had targeted DocDoom?

Was Scott lieing? Was the dark figure that found the memory dust and remembered how to move/how people moved me and I learned how to detect Tick Tock from that?

Those are the only things I could think of. :ermm:

The answer: Doc Ock has a huge ego. If he found -physical- evidence, he'd be so proud of himself for 'figuring it out' that he wouldn't check for non-physical evidence... chronal energy, etc, etc. Gil Grissom, he ain't. So until he actually found someone who had only been targetted by Tick Tock, he didn't realize he was out there.

[Jackofhearts2005]

The answer: Doc Ock has a huge ego. If he found -physical- evidence, he'd be so proud of himself for 'figuring it out' that he wouldn't check for non-physical evidence... chronal energy, etc, etc. Gil Grissom, he ain't. So until he actually found someone who had only been targetted by Tick Tock, he didn't realize he was out there.
Bummer. :cool:

[Antipathy]

Peers, any memorable moments from this or the previous game? Anything that gave you a headache from trying not to laugh and/or scream at your players as they did something amazingly funny or cool, completely at random? ;)

[Antipathy]

A bump so it can get moved to the Games sub-forum.