Harry Potter Mafia :: Game Thread

[Amora's_best_friend]

A recap of the rules.

NEW PLAYERS MUST READ!

Things to remember:
1) A full writeup of the rules can be found here. (http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Main_Page) This game will be more complicated than what's described there, as it is a themed game, and in the magical world of Mr. HP everyone can use magic to a certain extent.

2) When you vote tp lynch, please do so by saying Vote: [Player] in bold. If you wish to change your vote, please say Change Vote: [Player] instead. Voting "Nobody" is a valid vote; if a majority votes for 'nobody' then nobody will be lynched and we'll move on to the Night phase.

3) If your role says you *may* PM me a target, you don't have to do anything at night. Even so, it'll speed things along quite a bit if you'd still just send me a PM saying "Not using my [whatever] power tonight, thanks."

4) If your role says you *must* PM me a target, and you do not? I'll pick one randomly. Or, perhaps, not-so-randomly. (*Laughs maniacally*) Don't blame me if you target someone who kills you.

5) You may NOT send a PM to anyone about this game unless your role explicitly says you can. This is cheating. Nor can you discuss this game in any other thread than this.

6) Do NOT edit your posts in this thread. This is cheating.

7) Please do not copy-and-paste anything from any PM I send you to the thread. This is also cheating.

8) Please do not post in this thread after you are killed. This, too, is cheating and can ruin the game if done wrong.

10) Remember, it's just a game. You will get paranoid, you will be stabbed in the back by someone, you will see somebody do or say something stupid and want to smack them. Just breathe deep and relax. If things get out of hand, we do have a mod playing who will forcibly remind you to chill out if needed. It hasn't happened yet, and we'd all like to keep it that way.

11) Remember, magic happens where it is least expected!


(I didn't just nick this off JacinB/Peers :cheeky:)

[Rokk_Krinn]

"Lord Voldemort!"

There, just figured I'd get the fear of using his name out of the way. :)

[Amora's_best_friend]

J.K Rowling typed the final words of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, and breathed a sigh of relief. "Now only one more book!" she thought to herself. She got herself a cup of tea, and a biscuit.

Suddenly she started coughing, desperately trying to remove the choc chip that was lodged in her throat, restricting her breathing. With no-one else there, she could do nothing but collapse on the floor dead.

J.k Rowling is dead. She was the author of the first 6 books. Amora's_best_friend and those playing in this game will be the authors of the 7th book.




A group of people stepped into the grounds of Hogwarts castle, leaving a giant dead in the forbidden forest behind them. All other ways of entering the castle apart from through the forest had been blocked. The murderer of Dumbledore was in the castle somewhere, and sooner or later that murderer would be dead aswell.

****

Voldemort laughed a high pitched screech of a noise. The tracing spell was complete, and his revenge on Harry Potter was almost realised. The first phase of his plan had worked so well.

****


Day 1 begins now.


There are 26 people playing (14 is a majority)

Antipathy
bamf!
CarlosMucha
DargFoenix
DocDoom187
Doombot3.1
Goodman
hot_fusion
Iron Ham
JackAssterson
Jackofhearts2005
JKLantern
KitsuShel
m_a_caque
Magnito
MSU
NAES72
Pashmina
RCricket55
ReZourceman
Rokk_Krinn
splashy66
St-Dumas
Thawmus
theanalogkid
The Vision

[Pashmina]

Oh no.

*isn't sure what happens now*

EDIT:

Vote : No Lynch

I don't understand how she choked on a Chocolate chip. They're miniscule.

[Thawmus]

Alright, day one, so I'm sticking to the usual:

Vote: No Lynch


I'd also like to ask that I be protected tonight, so that I can actually play in this one. :laugh:

[Magnito]

Now we decide if we want to lynch anyone on the first day despite the fact that no one knows anything about anyone.

I'll start with a standard No lynch vote.

[Doombot 3.1]

J.K Rowling typed the final words of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, and breathed a sigh of relief. "Now only one more book!" she thought to herself. She got herself a cup of tea, and a biscuit.

Suddenly she started coughing, desperately trying to remove the choc chip that was lodged in her throat, restricting her breathing. With no-one else there, she could do nothing but collapse on the floor dead.

J.k Rowling is dead. She was the author of the first 6 books.


Everybody's a critic. :cheeky:

[KitsuShel]

OK, well, its the first day, so I'm going to vote No Lynch. I am really not a fan of Russian Roulette and lynching someone randomly, especially on the very first day when none of us know anything.

:)

This looks to be super fun!

[JKLantern]

No lynching today.

[Thawmus]

OK, well, its the first day, so I'm going to vote No Lynch. I am really not a fan of Russian Roulette and lynching someone randomly, especially on the very first day when none of us know anything.

:)

This looks to be super fun!

She smiles at me when I'm looking, but I know I'll be getting a visit tonight, and it won't be pleasant!!! :angry: :angry: :angry:




;)

[Amora's_best_friend]

Could everyone preferably just post No Lynch, since the first day is more-or-less pointless, and I want to start the night phase before I go to bed.

[Doombot 3.1]

I guess it's the old Day 1 standby:

VOTE: No lynch

[EmperorNorton]

If I had known that this game starts with a dead J.K. Rowling I would've wanted to play...

[The Vision]

No Lynch

filler

[Jackofhearts2005]

Well, if the mod himself calls for it....

Vote: No Lynch

[The Vision]

Thats 8 so far.

[Amora's_best_friend]

Oh no.

*isn't sure what happens now*

EDIT:

Vote : No Lynch

I don't understand how she choked on a Chocolate chip. They're miniscule.

Editting posts is not allowed.

You will be let off this time, but next time you will be modkilled.


Also, what can I say? She must have a very small larynx/trochea :cheeky:

[Jackofhearts2005]

Potter Puppet Pals (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1yn9mrZELg&mode=related&search=)

[JKLantern]

Editting posts is not allowed.

You will be let off this time, but next time you will be modkilled.


Also, what can I say? She must have a very small larynx/trochea :cheeky:

It was an EVIL chocolate chip.

[Doombot 3.1]

It was an EVIL chocolate chip.

Not only that, it was cursed by Lord Voldemort too.

[JackAssterson]

Not only that, it was cursed by Lord Voldemort too.

It was an EVIL curse.

Vote: No lynch, btw.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Not only that, it was cursed by Lord Voldemort too.
Shhhhhhh! Don't say his name! :noid:




;)

[Amora's_best_friend]

Votes

No lynch (9): Pashmina, Thawmus, Magnito, KitsuShel, JKLantern, Doombot 3.1, The Vision, Jackofhearts2005, JackAssterson

[Thawmus]

Votes

No lynch (9): Pashmina, Thawmus, Magnito, KitsuShel, JKLantern, Doombot 3.1, The Vision, Jackofhearts2005, JackAssterson


You know, I don't think it would hurt to end the day phase just before you decide to go to bed.


I think most of us like having a day phase to start out with, just so we can converse, and get a player list going.


Not to mention, beg for protection or tracking the first night.

[NAES72]

Vote: No lynch

[Rokk_Krinn]

Shhhhhhh! Don't say his name! :noid:




;)

Coward. I already said his name...

...which was really to let Thawmus play the game longer as I'll be the one iced tonight. :laugh:

I may not be in favour of "Russian Roulette" lynching but I am in favour of keeping the thread open a tad longer so we can formulate a few ideas.

Okay, and because I can actually speak in this game. :laugh:

[St-Dumas]

No lynch

It's tradition.

[DocDoom187]

Thawmus! Tradition!


Lynch: Amora's Best Friend


:p


no lynch

[Antipathy]

Vote: No Lynch

To move things along

[Jackofhearts2005]

Coward. I already said his name...

'Arry? 'Arry Potter? :eek:

[Amora's_best_friend]

Vote: No Lynch

To move things along

A total of 14 votes for No Lynch has been reached.

Day 1 is over.

Hogwarts is still.

***

The students have sought refuge in Gryffindor Tower, but is it safe from the intruders that roam the castle?

***

Dumbledore's office looks very different after his death. All the curious objects have been shunted to the side, and the normally busy portraits have all been removed from the walls.

A group of people stand in a circle, speaking in hushed tones, each with their wand out, just in case...

Nowadays, nobody knows who to trust.


Night 1 has now begun.

26 players survive:

Antipathy
bamf!
CarlosMucha
DargFoenix
DocDoom187
Doombot3.1
Goodman
hot_fusion
Iron Ham
JackAssterson
Jackofhearts2005
JKLantern
KitsuShel
m_a_caque
Magnito
MSU
NAES72
Pashmina
RCricket55
ReZourceman
Rokk_Krinn
splashy66
St-Dumas
Thawmus
theanalogkid
The Vision

Day 2 shall begin when I receive all the PMs.

[Amora's_best_friend]

Night 1 has ended


Snape checked the fireplace again, just incase the floo network was back online. It wasn't. That must mean the ministry have switched it off. There was no way out the castle now. Snape's dark mark seared with pain, the Dark Lord was close.

There was a noise behind him. Snape spun around, and shouted "SECTUMSEMPRA!" pointing his wand at the empty space where the noise came from.

There was a cry of pain, and out of thin air appeared Harry Potter, his invisibility cloak fallen to the floor. He clutched his left arm in pain, there was a huge gouge, where flesh had been before.

Snape's expression did not change.

"If you are here to kill me, you will only be betraying Dumbledore. Dumbledore instructed me to kill him."

"Save your words, Snape" spat Harry, his body shaking with anger and pain.

Before Snape could reply, there was a blinding flash of green light.

Pashmina is dead. He was Severus Snape. His loyalty was undetermined.

***

Wormtail scurried through the herbology labs, now empty and overgrown. He had received valueable information, and the Dark Lord was sure to be pleased.

The snake had found its next meal. The little man.

Waiting for the moment when Wormtail stopped to take a breath and wipe his brow, the snake's fangs found the victim's shoulder. Wormtail cried out in pain, but before he knew what was happening, the snake had been hoisted into the air by an invisible force, and before his very eyes, was cut into multiple pieces by an invisible cleaver.

A voice came from the darkness a distance away "You can thank me later".

CarlosMucha is dead. He was Nagini, the snake that only knew how to kill. It was also a horcrux of You Know Who.


***

Hagrid was devastated when he learned of Dumbledore's death. He was pushed over the edge when he encountered Grawp, his half-brother and giant, dead in the forbidden forest. His life no longer had any meaning.

He would not rest until the murderer(s) of Grawp and Dumbledore were dead.

His first target was Harry Potter.

He had not believed it at first, when he had seen Harry running away from the scene of Dumbledore's death. After a while, the idea that Harry was responsible grew more and more appealing to him. Harry had been a burden to him more than anything else.

Harry's death was quick and painless. He was thrown from a 6th floor window, and had dyed of shock before he hit the ground.

Goodman is dead. He was Harry Potter. The boy who lived (well, for 17 years).

***

McGonagal strode through the castle, with her wand, waving the white flag of peace. Her mission was clear in her mind.

From behind a statue, a familiar face appeared.

"Oh, you surprised me!" said McGonagal.

A blinding flash of green light errupted through the corridor.

Doombot 3.1 is dead. He was Minerva McGonagal, Dumbledore's deputy.

"This is almost too easy." said the now-criminal.

***

There are 22 people left in the game (12 is a majority)

Antipathy
bamf!
DargFoenix
DocDoom187
hot_fusion
Iron Ham
JackAssterson
Jackofhearts2005
JKLantern
KitsuShel
m_a_caque
Magnito
MSU
NAES72
RCricket55
ReZourceman
Rokk_Krinn
splashy66
St-Dumas
Thawmus
theanalogkid
The Vision

Day 2 has begun

[DocDoom187]

How did Harry Kill Snape!?!?


Poly juice potion anyone?

[theanalogkid]

Thats a lot of carnage. Lord Voldermont must be beside himself. 2 allies dead. That can only help us.

[RCricket55]

there were some very busy people last night...4 died. Harry Potter is already dead...what a rough night.

Please someone tell me you got something to go on.

[Thawmus]

4 deaths in one night.

That means it's likely we had two serial killers, a vigilante, and mafia. Or some other combination

Harry was likely a tracker, and he's dead.

Carlos was one of the serial killers, and he was either auto-killed, or there's a doctor who has auto-killing powers.

Regardless, they likely need to come forward, since they would have targeted mafia last night.

The vigilante targeted Harry.

The other serial killer, or mafia, targeted Snape.

Another serial killer, or mafia, killed the woman at the end.

[Thawmus]

Thats a lot of carnage. Lord Voldermont must be beside himself. 2 allies dead. That can only help us.

Okay, I see how the snake was an ally, but what's the other?


I don't know anything about HP.

[Thawmus]

How did Harry Kill Snape!?!?


Poly juice potion anyone?

I don't think he did. I think someone else killed Snape, during that encounter.

[theanalogkid]

Snape was an ally at one time.

[JKLantern]

Perhaps Harry was a vigilante who later in the night, got taken out by Hagrid.

[theanalogkid]

That is what he is saying, Thawmus. The potion allows you to look like other people.

[St-Dumas]

I'm worried and confused.

[Thawmus]

Perhaps Harry was a vigilante who later in the night, got taken out by Hagrid.

I don't think so. He wasn't ready to kill him during that encounter, and he was invisible at the time. He was very likely a tracker.

I think ABF is being too obvious when he's trying to lead us to that conclusion.

[DocDoom187]

I don't think he did. I think someone else killed Snape, during that encounter.
Polly Juice potion is a potion that aloows you to look liike anyone as long as you put some of their DNa into the potion.


I think someone has PJ potion.

[Thawmus]

That is what he is saying, Thawmus. The potion allows you to look like other people.

Oh.




I am so outta my league in this game..... :ermm:


Maybe that means I'll survive longer! :)

[Thawmus]

Polly Juice potion is a potion that aloows you to look liike anyone as long as you put some of their DNa into the potion.


I think someone has PJ potion.

But if that were the case, wouldn't they make themselves look like someone that Snape WOULDN'T get nasty with, and then kill him while in that form?

That seems to make the most sense to me.


Something like a PJ potion is probably being used as a simple shape changing role. Which could be either mafia or townie.


I dunno, like I said, I have 0 experience with Harry Potter, so I'm going to take a back seat while you guys figure some of this out. Call me when you need some heavy leaning.

[St-Dumas]

I don't think we have much info so for now i'll vote no lynch.

[Rokk_Krinn]

The vigilante targeted Harry.
.

I'm thinking Hagrid is more likely a serial killer. He's always been a stanch ally of Harry but his write-up suggests he's gone over the deep end and is just killing anyone he feels is connected with Dumbledore's death, be they Good or Evil.

I don't think the polyjuice potion was used to look like Harry. The key is the cloak of invisibility which no one other than Harry would have had on him. That doesn't mean Harry killed Snape though as it could have been someone watching.

[theanalogkid]

We'll help you with the lingo, Thawmus. And your not burdened with knowlegde in helpful, as I just realized this. If that is not Harry, how did they get his cloak? The potion is easy to come by, the cloak isn't.

[theanalogkid]

Slow typing does me in again.

[Rokk_Krinn]

I do know this is like the Rob Zombie version of the Harry Potter series. ;)

[Thawmus]

I'm thinking Hagrid is more likely a serial killer. He's always been a stanch ally of Harry but his write-up suggests he's gone over the deep end and is just killing anyone he feels is connected with Dumbledore's death, be they Good or Evil.

that still sounds like a Vigilante to me.

[St-Dumas]

I'm thinking Hagrid is more likely a serial killer. He's always been a stanch ally of Harry but his write-up suggests he's gone over the deep end and is just killing anyone he feels is connected with Dumbledore's death, be they Good or Evil.

I don't think the polyjuice potion was used to look like Harry. The key is the cloak of invisibility which no one other than Harry would have had on him. That doesn't mean Harry killed Snape though as it could have been someone watching.

What's that one mind control curse? Could that be involved?

[Amora's_best_friend]

I do know this is like the Rob Zombie version of the Harry Potter series. ;)

Lol!

Death is commonplace in the reign of You Know Who.

[JKLantern]

What's that one mind control curse? Could that be involved?

The Imperius Curse. It could theoretically be involved. Or (at the risk of getting slightly metagame) Harry could've decided or discovered that, in this HP Universe, Snape was indeed evil, and killed him of his own volition. And then run into something he didn't expect.

[DocDoom187]

What's that one mind control curse? Could that be involved?
Imperius I believe. And yea, I forgot, thats a possibility.

[KitsuShel]

It seems to me that Harry distracted Snape and someone else killed him. I can't see Harry as just outright killing SNape. :ermm:

As for Hagrid, maybe that person is using polyjuice? Hagrid couldn't hurt a fly in any of the books I read, especially 'Arry.[

Oh and Minerva! Poor Minvera, I wonder what kind of power she had. Probably role blocker or Shapechanger due to her Animangus.

Severus was probably neutral, waiting for a catalyst to join either side.

[DocDoom187]

It seems to me that Harry distracted Snape and someone else killed him. I can't see Harry as just outright killing SNape. :ermm:

As for Hagrid, maybe that person is using polyjuice? Hagrid couldn't hurt a fly in any of the books I read, especially 'Arry.[

Oh and Minerva! Poor Minvera, I wonder what kind of power she had. Probably role blocker or Shapechanger due to her Animangus.

Severus was probably neutral, waiting for a catalyst to join either side.
She probably couldnt be targeted at night. She'd change form. That's my guess.

[JKLantern]

She probably couldnt be targeted at night. She'd change form. That's my guess.

Slight flaw in that, unless I'm missing something: she's dead now.

[RCricket55]

I dunno, like I said, I have 0 experience with Harry Potter, so I'm going to take a back seat while you guys figure some of this out. Call me when you need some heavy leaning.

I made it through the first 2 movies:laugh:

roomie has a few more, may be the best way to get into this more.

Death is commonplace in the reign of You Know Who.

You Know Who is Lord Voldemort right??

[St-Dumas]

She IS dead, isn't she...

[RCricket55]

Slight flaw in that, unless I'm missing something: she's dead now.

I was thinking the same thing...haha:)

[JKLantern]

You Know Who is Lord Voldemort right??

That is correct, the Darkest Wizard this side of the Rio Gra-er, Thames.

[St-Dumas]

I made it through the first 2 movies:laugh:

roomie has a few more, may be the best way to get into this more.



You Know Who is Lord Voldemort right??

Yeah, but people are too scared to outright say his name.

[Amora's_best_friend]

You Know Who is Lord Voldemort right??

You Know Who is indeed He Who Must Not Be Named.

[DocDoom187]

Slight flaw in that, unless I'm missing something: she's dead now.
Role Blocked?

[Jackofhearts2005]

How did Harry Kill Snape!?!?


Poly juice potion anyone?
I think not.

He had the invisibility cloak.

I'm pretty sure that was the real Harry...who is now dead. :(

Sidenote: Snape could have been the mafia traitor...or just a mafia person.
Sidenote2: We have Horcruxes here. I'm not sure how many there are in this game. It might have been Harry, Ron, and Hermione's job to track them down and destroy them at night. That, or Naggi was the only one. Point being, Voldemort might have things protecting him from being killed but now one of them is gone.

[St-Dumas]

Role Blocked?

I like where his head's at.

[DocDoom187]

IDK It was just a guess. Its early and I'm tired lol.

[DocDoom187]

I think not.

He had the invisibility cloak.

I'm pretty sure that was the real Harry...who is now dead. :(

Sidenote: Snape could have been the mafia traitor...or just a mafia person.
Sidenote2: We have Horcruxes here. I'm not sure how many there are in this game. It might have been Harry, Ron, and Hermione's job to track them down and destroy them at night. That, or Naggi was the only one. Point being, Voldemort might have things protecting him from being killed but now one of them is gone.
Voldy is probably mafia, and the Horcruxes are either minions, or on his minions, meaning we can;t kill him, the don, unless we kill his minions, like in One of Peers earlier games.

[theanalogkid]

Harry was the only one to use Voldermont's name. I think in his honor, we should all be that brave.

[Amora's_best_friend]

People fear Him for a reason.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Voldy is probably mafia, and the Horcruxes are either minions, or on his minions, meaning we can;t kill him, the don, unless we kill his minions, like in One of Peers earlier games.
Thats a cool idea.

How many Horcruxes should be left?

The ring and diary should be gone already, along with the snake.

The cup and locket could be gone already or be on You-Know-Who's mafia members.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Harry was the only one to use Voldermont's name. I think in his honor, we should all be that brave.
Except saying his name gives you away....if you know what I mean. :noid:

[Thawmus]

I saw someone mention the Imperius curse earlier. What is that?

[DocDoom187]

I saw someone mention the Imperius curse earlier. What is that?
A curse that allows you to control the targte. Which might be what happened to Harry, though I doubt it. That woulds be insanely powerful, to imperiius AND get to night kill, with no downside?

[KitsuShel]

I saw someone mention the Imperius curse earlier. What is that?

In the simplest of terms, its mind control. You can force someone to do what you tell them to.

[DocDoom187]

Thats a cool idea.

How many Horcruxes should be left?

The ring and diary should be gone already, along with the snake.

The cup and locket could be gone already or be on You-Know-Who's mafia members.
My gues is the ring and locket are gone. And now nigini. Leaving 4, and 4 afia membersm, which wouls be about right, considering the size f the game, and the probability of a second mafia/ independent team.

[theanalogkid]

It is a curse that allows you to control others.

[Rokk_Krinn]

that still sounds like a Vigilante to me.

How so? A Vigilante is on one specific side and acts as a Night Killer for them. Hagrid was opposed to both sides: Harry (Good) and Voldemort (Evil).

I don't suppose you're trying to make Hagrid look less harmful because you accidentally killed the wrong person (or don't want to look like a serial killer until later) by chance? :p

[Jackofhearts2005]

My gues is the ring and locket are gone. And now nigini. Leaving 4, and 4 afia membersm, which wouls be about right, considering the size f the game, and the probability of a second mafia/ independent team.
And the diary. Its been gone since book 2.

[Thawmus]

A curse that allows you to control the targte. Which might be what happened to Harry, though I doubt it. That woulds be insanely powerful, to imperiius AND get to night kill, with no downside?

Who normally does that?

[Amora's_best_friend]

imperium, imperii, (n.) - power

[Jackofhearts2005]

Who normally does that?
Only bad guys.

On very rare occations, good guys will use the killing curse, which makes a green light (like that which was used on Snape).

Most of the time, good guys will use the stunning curse, which makes a red light.

[Thawmus]

How so? A Vigilante is on one specific side and acts as a Night Killer for them. Hagrid was opposed to both sides: Harry (Good) and Voldemort (Evil).

I don't suppose you're trying to make Hagrid look less harmful because you accidentally killed the wrong person (or don't want to look like a serial killer until later) by chance? :p

Not at all. There'll be no subtle hinting this time around, I'm afraid.

[KitsuShel]

My gues is the ring and locket are gone. And now nigini. Leaving 4, and 4 afia membersm, which wouls be about right, considering the size f the game, and the probability of a second mafia/ independent team.

What an interesting theory. Lets say He Who Must Not Be Named is the don of one team and the Horocruxes are on another? Or even Dumbledore's Army being a Mafia?

[Amora's_best_friend]

Votes

No lynch (1) St-Dumas

[theanalogkid]

The evil people, the Death Eaters.

[DocDoom187]

Who normally does that?
A vigilante which is what you're getting at. And no offense to ABF, but Since hes only played in a couple games, I hope he realized that powers, not all but alot, need some form of downside. Do not reply to this ABf, as you might confrim or deny something.


But I can not, for thwe life of me, think of a vigilante who would use the Imperius Curse. Maybe the Ministry is anti-townie? Though I doubt it. I don't know.

[DocDoom187]

Only bad guys.

On very rare occations, good guys will use the killing curse, which makes a green light (like that which was used on Snape).

Most of the time, good guys will use the stunning curse, which makes a red light.
Oh./ I thought he meant what role in the game normally allows you to kill without a downside. To which I answered Vigilante, but Imperius curse is only used by Villains, and once by Harry. Its one of 3 forbidden curses.

[DocDoom187]

No atter how you spin it, Someone got insanely lucky if they targeted Harry with Imperius Curse, and Hagrid got insanely unlucky killing Harry the first night.

[Antipathy]

I would agree Hagrid is the serial killer. From the way the write-up is written, it seems Hagrid is slowly going mad.

[kontrol]

Hmm, I kind of wish I signed up for this, now. Even though at the time I probably thought I didn't have the time, I'm finding myself with more opportunity to play. Oh well.

[ReZourceman]

Dang Harrys gone.....How do I feel about this.

[Jackofhearts2005]

What an interesting theory. Lets say He Who Must Not Be Named is the don of one team and the Horocruxes are on another? Or even Dumbledore's Army being a Mafia?
I doubt the Horcruxes are a team.

They are almost all inanimate objects. The only living one has been destoryed already.

The horocruxes are probably either all destroyed, being held by Deatheaters and are destroyed when the Death Eaters are killed, or Harry Ron and Hermione have to somehow seek out and destroy them.

As for the DA being a mafia? That seems a little ridiculous, seeing as the DA are good guys, but it wouldn't surprise me if they were on a team and had a vigilante, similar to the New Avengers or James-Younger gang.

[DocDoom187]

I would agree Hagrid is the serial killer. From the way the write-up is written, it seems Hagrid is slowly going mad.
I disagree to some extent. I do not think hes a fullblown serial killer. As previouisly mentioned, he literally would not hamr a fly. I can not see him being a serial killer. Maybe under certain circumstanced he can kill. Who knows>? It might not have actually been Hagrid.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I would agree Hagrid is the serial killer. From the way the write-up is written, it seems Hagrid is slowly going mad.
Sounds right to me.

[DocDoom187]

I doubt the Horcruxes are a team.

They are almost all inanimate objects. The only living one has been destoryed already.

The horocruxes are probably either all destroyed, being held by Deatheaters and are destroyed when the Death Eaters are killed, or Harry Ron and Hermione have to somehow seek out and destroy them.

As for the DA being a mafia? That seems a little ridiculous, seeing as the DA are good guys, but it wouldn't surprise me if they were on a team and had a vigilante, similar to the New Avengers or James-Younger gang.
DA might be able to recruit though....

IDK, its a possibility

[Jackofhearts2005]

Dang Harrys gone.....How do I feel about this.
You should feel bad...unless you're a death eater!!!! :angry:

[Thawmus]

I sincerely doubt that Harry got the Imperius Curse. His actions and dialogue in the writeup just don't really speak to being mind controlled, or getting ready to cast a curse.

That's not to say that the Imperius curse doesn't exist, though. I just doubt that Harry was targeted with it.

[theanalogkid]

I have to agree with Hagrid being the Serial Killer. He does seem to be slowly losing it.

[DocDoom187]

Ok. First, out of everyone killed, could any of those have been a doctor?


I don't think so, But I'm not sure. I want more opinions, if the general consensus is the Doctor is alive, I requestfully ask either a Cop or Tracker to tell us any info they may have. If they have no info though, don't bother

[Antipathy]

I disagree to some extent. I do not think hes a fullblown serial killer. As previouisly mentioned, he literally would not hamr a fly. I can not see him being a serial killer. Maybe under certain circumstanced he can kill. Who knows>? It might not have actually been Hagrid.

What happened when the Ministry tried to arrest him?

He fought knocked out a couple of Aurors, saw he wouldn't win, and ran to the hills.

Due to Dumbledore's death, he becomes unhinged.

[Jackofhearts2005]

DA might be able to recruit though....

Possibly.

If the DA is here, it probably don't have its full membership yet(because, lets face it, nearly every "townie" would fall into either the DA or the Order).

[JKLantern]

What if the Aurors are a team of vigilantes?

[theanalogkid]

i think that Harry was the tracker, unfortunately. Him killing Snape could be some kind of condition like the bounty hunter had in the wild west Mafia.

[theanalogkid]

I think JOH is right. There are more than likely a pool of neutrals waiting to be recruited by either side. Luckily, Snape and Naggy got taken out before they could join.

[Jackofhearts2005]

What if the Aurors are a team of vigilantes?
I doubt they are a team of them, as that would mean there would be a lot more death.

There could be teams of Aurors that have members that could track and also members that could kill.

[DarqFeonix]

Couple things I think we might want to think about. I'm sure that Polyjuice Potion was probably a part of the game, but I imagine that the only person who could've used that was Snape, as it takes a month to make the Polyjuice, and in the books he was really the only one who ever had an ample supply of the stuff.

It was pretty clear since Harry had the cloak, that it was definitely Harry who killed/helped kill Snape. I'm leaning more towards help kill... possibly a Don role? Maybe Harry is on the side of Evil? That would make Hagrid a Vigilante, not a Serial Killer, right?

At no point did ABF give Good/Evil, so I'm wondering if we're following the book-roles too literally.

[DocDoom187]

HMmmm.

Do you think Snape the potions master could have been a doctor?

Maybe Aberforth Dumbledores the doctor....

[Jackofhearts2005]

I think JOH is right. There are more than likely a pool of neutrals waiting to be recruited by either side. Luckily, Snape and Naggy got taken out before they could join.
Or just good and bad guys that can't be recruited/can only be recruited by one side.

Snape is just about the only person who could be recruited to either side.

Wormtail and Naggi were obviously not in the same mafia.

Also, just to spread some discord among the mafia: Wormtail could be a traitor. So could any Malfoys. Watch your backs, Death Eaters. :cheeky:

[Jackofhearts2005]

Maybe Harry is on the side of Evil?
If Harry is evil, we're all screwed. :laugh:

[DocDoom187]

Or just good and bad guys that can't be recruited/can only be recruited by one side.

Snape is just about the only person who could be recruited to either side.

Wormtail and Naggi were obviously not in the same mafia.

Also, just to spread some discord among the mafia: Wormtail could be a traitor. So could any Malfoys. Watch your backs, Death Eaters. :cheeky:
Hmmm. If we're goign book here, weren't the Malfoys, besides Belatrix, not really active i nthe seventh book when it came to the death eaters? They were more worried about keeping the family together. Kinda.

Maybe they're an independent team. and want to kill Dumbledore. Or something like that.

Maybe I'm crazy. Its just a guess.

[DocDoom187]

Come to think of it, they're probably evil. I might be looking to much into the book.

[JKLantern]

.

Wormtail and Naggi were obviously not in the same mafia.



Which begs the question: if the Dark Lord is leading one evil mafia, who's in charge of the other one?

[DocDoom187]

Wormtail might be independent

[Rokk_Krinn]

I disagree to some extent. I do not think hes a fullblown serial killer. As previouisly mentioned, he literally would not hamr a fly. I can not see him being a serial killer. Maybe under certain circumstanced he can kill. Who knows>? It might not have actually been Hagrid.

Re-Read the write-up; it doesn't appear that it was anyone other than Hagrid. It wasn't just someone who -looked- like Hagrid showing up and killing Harry but Hagrid with a whole background and reason given for killing Harry. He wants both sides dead.

If it had just been Harry getting killed out of the blue by someone that appeared to be Hagrid I would agree, there may be deception involved but being we got the full write-up on Hagrid's frame of mind, I have to say it looks like he's gone off the deep-end and is just killing people willy-nilly (and I would like to find him today before he decides I'm his next target just for calling him cuckoo for kobald puffs :) ).

[Rokk_Krinn]

Maybe they're an independent team. and want to kill Dumbledore. Or something like that.


If so, they've already won as Dumbledore is dead at the beginning of the game. The rest of us are just playing for second. :laugh:

[DocDoom187]

If so, they've already won as Dumbledore is dead at the beginning of the game. The rest of us are just playing for second. :laugh:
I meant Dumbledore's Army. Stupid Not allowed to edit. lol

[Thawmus]

Wormtail scurried through the herbology labs, now empty and overgrown. He had received valueable information, and the Dark Lord was sure to be pleased.

The snake had found its next meal. The little man.

Waiting for the moment when Wormtail stopped to take a breath and wipe his brow, the snake's fangs found the victim's shoulder. Wormtail cried out in pain, but before he knew what was happening, the snake had been hoisted into the air by an invisible force, and before his very eyes, was cut into multiple pieces by an invisible cleaver.

A voice came from the darkness a distance away "You can thank me later".

CarlosMucha is dead. He was Nagini, the snake that only knew how to kill. It was also a horcrux of You Know Who.

I've underlined the important bits.


My hypothesis at this point is that Carlos was misdirected or mind controlled.

Who uses invisibility besides Harry?

[DocDoom187]

I've underlined the important bits.


My hypothesis at this point is that Carlos was misdirected or mind controlled.

Who uses invisibility besides Harry?
Dumbledore, but hes dead. Thats it. Theres no cloak in the world like Harry's

[Rokk_Krinn]

I've underlined the important bits.


My hypothesis at this point is that Carlos was misdirected or mind controlled.

Who uses invisibility besides Harry?

It appears less like invisibility and more like a TK-related capability as the voice was off in the darkness and used spell capabilities to hoist and hack the snake.

[Thawmus]

Dumbledore, but hes dead. Thats it. Theres no cloak in the world like Harry's

Then who could be invisible while killing Carlos?

Read that writeup again.


You might still be on the money about the PJP.

Has anyone been killed while using it, in the books? If so, how long does it take before they revert to their old self?

[Jackofhearts2005]

I've underlined the important bits.


My hypothesis at this point is that Carlos was misdirected or mind controlled.

Who uses invisibility besides Harry?
Nobody, to the same extent.

Lots of wizards can go invisible and anybody could have been hiding from the shadows.

The attack used to kill Naggi seems very Snapish, though.....which doesn't help because Snape was already dead.

[Amora's_best_friend]

When McGonagal's body is found, her thoughts are extracted for viewing in the penseive. However, because she has has been dead for most of the night, the thoughts have become nothing more than a mist.

The penseive shows the faces of Nymphadora Tonks, Hermione Granger, Ernie Macmillan, and shows how McGonagal intended to kill that night.

[Thawmus]

It appears less like invisibility and more like a TK-related capability as the voice was off in the darkness and used spell capabilities to hoist and hack the snake.

And who would normally be capable of doing that?


Sorry for all the questions, I had a feeling I'd be out of my element in this game, but this is a little severe.....

[Rokk_Krinn]

Should we really be trying to out the individual that hacked up the snake? That's likely a very useful person to keep in the game.

I would be more concerned about, say, Hagrid going nuts on each of us than I would the one who went after Carlos.

Honestly, anyone trying to out that individual is likely someone that wants to know whom to remove to protect Voldemort and his forces. :devious:

[Rokk_Krinn]

and shows how McGonagal intended to kill that night.

Criminey! Am I the only person in this game that didn't get a Kill power?!?

[DocDoom187]

Criminey! Am I the only person in this game that didn't get a Kill power?!?
Shut up Luna!


I mean.......
;)

[Jackofhearts2005]

When McGonagal's body is found, her thoughts are extracted for viewing in the penseive. However, because she has has been dead for most of the night, the thoughts have become nothing more than a mist.

The penseive shows the faces of Nymphadora Tonks, Hermione Granger, Ernie Macmillan, and shows how McGonagal intended to kill that night.
1) We have someone/someplace with a penseive. This is good.

2) McGonagal tried to kill someone last night. That is pretty odd, but she is quite the dueler.

3) All the faces are those of good guys. Tonks is an Auror in the Order of Phoenix. Ernie is a student who is also a member of the DA, IIRC.

[JKLantern]

And who would normally be capable of doing that?


Sorry for all the questions, I had a feeling I'd be out of my element in this game, but this is a little severe.....

Pretty much anyone, although Mad-Eye Moody and Barty Crouch Jr. were both seen doing this.

Could this statement of "being out of your element" be a facade designed to throw us off your trail, perhaps?

[DocDoom187]

1) We have someone/someplace with a penseive. This is good.

2) McGonagal tried to kill someone last night. That is pretty odd, but she is quite the dueler.

3) All the faces are those of good guys. Tonks is an Auror in the Order of Phoenix. Ernie is a student who is also a member of the DA, IIRC.
Maybe those are three Townie teams.

Aurors, Harry's friends, and DA

[Rokk_Krinn]

Honestly, between his desire to stick up for Hagrid and out the person who protected us from the snake, I'm going to toss in an early vote, if only to get discussion going here (besides, if he's out of his element, he might be thankful. :laugh: )

I'm more than willing to change it but for now the best lead I have on a suspect - other than someone I know to be innocent from what I garnered last night - is Phoenix, er, Shore, er, Thawmus.

Lynch Vote: Thawmus

[Thawmus]

Should we really be trying to out the individual that hacked up the snake? That's likely a very useful person to keep in the game.

Since they protected mafia from mafia, I'd say the jury's out on that one. Obviously there's mistakes made the first night, but I don't think we can simply forget that little bit.

I would be more concerned about, say, Hagrid going nuts on each of us than I would the one who went after Carlos.

Mind explaining why? I mean, don't get me wrong, serial killers need to be lynched ASAP, but the mafia is several times more potent, and dangerous. The serial killer has to survive to be one of the last two people. The mafia needs to only survive until the last 7-9, typically.

I'd be WAY more worried about mafia right now, than a serial killer. The only people worried about a serial killer at this stage of the game should be mafia.

Honestly, anyone trying to out that individual is likely someone that wants to know whom to remove to protect Voldemort and his forces. :devious:
Considering they protected Voldemort and his forces from Voldemort and his forces, I dunno that they're really considered a threat to him yet....

[DocDoom187]

Vote: Kitsushel

Don't read more into this than you should fellas,.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Maybe those are three Townie teams.

Aurors, Harry's friends, and DA
Makes sense.

I can see Kingsley, Tonks, and Mad Eye together.

I can't imagine Harry, Ron, and Hermione NOT being together.

The DA is less certain. They might be split up. Someone (Neville) could slowly recruit them all or maybe Ernie and the other Hufflepuffs are a team, while the DA Griffindors are a different team.

I don't see any Weaslys but Ginny being in the DA, since none of the other ones were at Hogwarts this year. Still, I'm sure Fred and George are going to be making an appearance.

[DocDoom187]

Makes sense.

I can see Kingsley, Tonks, and Mad Eye together.

I can't imagine Harry, Ron, and Hermione NOT being together.

The DA is less certain. They might be split up. Someone (Neville) could slowly recruit them all or maybe Ernie and the other Hufflepuffs are a team, while the DA Griffindors are a different team.

I don't see any Weaslys but Ginny being in the DA, since none of the other ones were at Hogwarts this year. Still, I'm sure Fred and George are going to be making an appearance.
Maybe Weasly is a whole other tema?


Probably not though. That would make Ron on 2 teams, lol.

[Thawmus]

Pretty much anyone, although Mad-Eye Moody and Barty Crouch Jr. were both seen doing this.

Could this statement of "being out of your element" be a facade designed to throw us off your trail, perhaps?

No, I've seriously never read a single HP book, nor watched a single HP movie.

Which was kinda why I decided to play in this one. It seems it's gotten me through the first night successfully.

[DocDoom187]

No, I've seriously never read a single HP book, nor watched a single HP movie.

Which was kinda why I decided to play in this one. It seems it's gotten me through the first night successfully.
Do you mind me asking why? Was there just no appeal. I can understand that.

[Thawmus]

Honestly, between his desire to stick up for Hagrid and out the person who protected us from the snake, I'm going to toss in an early vote, if only to get discussion going here (besides, if he's out of his element, he might be thankful. :laugh: )

I'm more than willing to change it but for now the best lead I have on a suspect - other than someone I know to be innocent from what I garnered last night - is Phoenix, er, Shore, er, Thawmus.

Lynch Vote: Thawmus

Can I ask why you roleclaimed already, when you don't have a suspect?

[JKLantern]

Can I ask why you roleclaimed already, when you don't have a suspect?

Perhaps the DA or the Auror's have a "Mason" type ability, and he got info from someone else who got info...

[Thawmus]

Do you mind me asking why? Was there just no appeal. I can understand that.

Why I've had nothing to do with HP?

There's lots of reasons for that. Due to the rules of this forum, I won't go into it.


Why I wanted to play in this game? I've gotten night killed the first night in two games in a row. I didn't want my next one to be #3, so I made sure I joined one that I was definitely out of my element in.

[DocDoom187]

Can I ask why you roleclaimed already, when you don't have a suspect?
I don;t think he means from what he gathered via Night power, rather via the Write up. That was just my understanding.

[DocDoom187]

Why I've had nothing to do with HP?

There's lots of reasons for that. Due to the rules of this forum, I won't go into it.


Why I wanted to play in this game? I've gotten night killed the first night in two games in a row. I didn't want my next one to be #3, so I made sure I joined one that I was definitely out of my element in.
No i meant why you didn't do Harry Potter.


Religious, political, sounds to be something like that. I'll Mind my own buisness now.:classic:

[Thawmus]

Perhaps the DA or the Auror's have a "Mason" type ability, and he got info from someone else who got info...

Regardless, he put a bullseye on his forehead without even presenting any evidence.

That seems like a pretty poor tactic to me.

Now if anyone else has information to bring forward, they have his soon-to-be demise on their conscience.

[JackAssterson]

I have reason to believe voting for Thawmus would be a good idea.

Vote: Thawmus

[Thawmus]

I don;t think he means from what he gathered via Night power, rather via the Write up. That was just my understanding.

Again, it's regardless. Saying you know someone's innocent means that you have a way of divining who is who. And the Mafia likes killing people who have that.

[DocDoom187]

Regardless, he put a bullseye on his forehead without even presenting any evidence.

That seems like a pretty poor tactic to me.

Now if anyone else has information to bring forward, they have his soon-to-be demise on their conscience.
I don't see it. He never said from tracking. From what he garnered lasrt night could very well mean from what he learned fro mthe right up. I think your jumping on bad wording on Rokks part.

[Thawmus]

I have reason to believe voting for Thawmus would be a good idea.

Vote: Thawmus

Um.......what???

[Jackofhearts2005]

Now if anyone else has information to bring forward, they have his soon-to-be demise on their conscience.
Are you telling us not to bring forward information? :confused:

[DocDoom187]

Again, it's regardless. Saying you know someone's innocent means that you have a way of divining who is who. And the Mafia likes killing people who have that.
Not necessarily. It could mean he's on a team with said person. Or hes on a team with a tracker who told him info, or who knows. I'm just saying, its not enough for me to think Rokk actually gave away his role. He might have a night protective power and is hoping he'll be targeted by the mafia.

[Rokk_Krinn]

How often do I play the game smart when I'm trying to feint out information from you? Seriously, my track record isn't so hot on that and I hadn't even taken it as a "role claim" so much as I know one person is innocent. You're reading too much into that. :ermm:

Meanwhile, you really haven't addressed the charges that you're sticking up for Hagrid and want the name of the person that protected MacGonagle.

[JKLantern]

I don't see it. He never said from tracking. From what he garnered lasrt night could very well mean from what he learned fro mthe right up. I think your jumping on bad wording on Rokks part.

There wasn't a whole lot in the wording that would prove one character innocent aside from the dead people. Likewise, there's nothing in the write-up that would give Thawmus away as one of the murderers. Not to say that he isn't neccessarily...

[DocDoom187]

Thawmus seems like a reasonable vote. But I'm gonna wait for now.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Meanwhile, you really haven't addressed the charges that you're sticking up for Hagrid and want the name of the person that protected MacGonagle.
Someone protected McGonagol?
Then why did she die?

I agree those things are suspicious and JackAssterson seems to have info on Thawmus as well.

Vote: Thawmus

[RCricket55]

1) We have someone/someplace with a penseive. This is good.

since this just showed up does is it a day power??

[Jackofhearts2005]

since this just showed up does is it a day power??
Probably. filler

[DocDoom187]

Ok. One thing to remember, lynch BandWagons are bad. Faster we lynch less time to talk. However


Change Vote: Thawmus

[Amora's_best_friend]

Votes (12 is a majority)

Thawmus (4) DocDoom187, Jackofhearts2005, JackAssterson, Rokk_krinn

No Lynch (1) St-Dumas

[bamf!]

Gonna jump on the bandwagon. JackAsserton seems to have some information he's not telling us, and Thawmus is acting a little suspicious. Need to get the ball rolling too. So...

Vote: Thawmus

[Thawmus]

Meanwhile, you really haven't addressed the charges that you're sticking up for Hagrid and want the name of the person that protected MacGonagle.

Actually, I did.

The fact of the matter is, I don't know jack nor #### about Harry Potter. So I want to know if that'd be a good guy or a bad guy that'd do what that protector did.

And since when did a townie protector KILL the person they're protecting from?

It sounds to me like a mafia power.

[RCricket55]

Votes (12 is a majority)

Thawmus (4) DocDoom187, Jackofhearts2005, JackAssterson, Rokk_krinn

No Lynch (1) St-Dumas

St-Dumas why so quick with the no lynch...we still have tons of people to potentially get info from.

[JKLantern]

Rokk seems pretty adamant about taking out the alleged serial killer. A little too adamant if you ask me. How do we know he isn't the serial killer, fabricating evidence to cover his own tacks.

Vote: Rokk Krinn

[Rokk_Krinn]

Someone protected McGonagol?
Then why did she die?


Sorry, I meant Wormtail.

Frankly, I don't care if he survives or dies but whomever took out the snake shouldn't be forced to come forward either way.

[Thawmus]

You guys are not lynching a bad guy, here.

If you want a roleclaim, ask for it. But you're going to want to hear it before you lynch me.

I'd also like to hear the grounds for my accusing.

[RCricket55]

Votes (12 is a majority)

Thawmus (4) DocDoom187, Jackofhearts2005, JackAssterson, Rokk_krinn

No Lynch (1) St-Dumas

I'll go with the wagon too.

lynch vote: Thawmus

Rokk and Jack, just to have it in writing you know what happens if he's good;) With 4 deaths last night, figured I'd get it on the boards while I can.

[Rokk_Krinn]

You guys are not lynching a bad guy, here.

If you want a roleclaim, ask for it. But you're going to want to hear it before you lynch me.

I'd also like to hear the grounds for my accusing.

Grounds were already given and I also said I'm more than happy to retract if there's good reason.

Reiterate though: You insist on protecting Hagrid - whom seems to be out for all of us - and making the killer of a villain (the snake) come forward, painting a bullseye on him.

[DocDoom187]

Change Vote:JKLantern


I think even Thawmus would agree Rokk is not mafia. He does not p;ay like that. He may not have townie intentions in mind, but its incredsibly apparent hes not mafia, and only a mafia member would want an independent dead.

[RCricket55]

I'll go with the wagon too.

lynch vote: Thawmus

Rokk and Jack, just to have it in writing you know what happens if he's good;) With 4 deaths last night, figured I'd get it on the boards while I can.

can't edit:angry:

lynch vote: Thawmus

[Amora's_best_friend]

Votes (12 is a majority)

Thawmus (6) DocDoom187, Jackofhearts2005, JackAssterson, Rokk_krinn, RCricket55, bamf!

Rokk_krinn(1) JKLantern

No Lynch (1) St-Dumas

[Rokk_Krinn]

Rokk and Jack, just to have it in writing you know what happens if he's good;) With 4 deaths last night, figured I'd get it on the boards while I can.

Yep, I know. I'm also a tad suspicious of the fact that so many people were eager to jump on this without more debate. In the interest of giving Thawmus more time to defend himself (but it better be good as he's already tried protecting Hagrid and getting a Vigilante to come forward), I'll postpone mine for now.

Change Vote: Withdrawing for Now

[Rokk_Krinn]

Oh, and it's not too good for Thawmus that JKLantern is so eager to protect him...almost looks like they're teammates.

[JKLantern]

Oh, and it's not too good for Thawmus that JKLantern is so eager to protect him...almost looks like they're teammates.

Or I'm suspicious of someone who casts the first stone.

[Amora's_best_friend]

Change Vote:JKLantern


I think even Thawmus would agree Rokk is not mafia. He does not p;ay like that. He may not have townie intentions in mind, but its incredsibly apparent hes not mafia, and only a mafia member would want an independent dead.

The day phase is over

The Dark Lord was untrustful of Wormtail. He put a curse on him, so that he would become a magical ticking bomb.

DocDoom187 was blown up for lynching JKLantern.


DocDoom187 is dead. He was Narcissa Malfoy, she was good, despite having a evil family.

JKLantern is dead. He was Professor Flitwick, desguised as Wormtail using the Polyjuice Potion.

[Thawmus]

Meanwhile, you really haven't addressed the charges that you're sticking up for Hagrid and want the name of the person that protected MacGonagle.

Did....did you read my post? :ermm:

[Rokk_Krinn]

Or I'm suspicious of someone who casts the first stone.

You mean the one who wanted the possible Vigilante revealed for everyone?

[JackAssterson]

Wuzzahooza?!?!

[JKLantern]

Is it just me, or did the day end rather abruptly there?

[theanalogkid]

Wow. That was...unexpected.

[Rokk_Krinn]

[B]

[B]DocDoom187 is dead. He was Narcissa Malfoy, she was good, despite having a evil family.


Figures. One of the only people that seemed to know me and the direction I was headed gets taken out by a bomb.

I seriously think ABF is going for body count here. :laugh:

[Thawmus]

Grounds were already given and I also said I'm more than happy to retract if there's good reason.

Reiterate though: You insist on protecting Hagrid - whom seems to be out for all of us - and making the killer of a villain (the snake) come forward, painting a bullseye on him.

Why are you always this stubborn? I'm not protecting Hagrid.

[Rokk_Krinn]

Why are you always this stubborn? I'm not protecting Hagrid.

It's our usual feint - not a stone casting - as we try to figure things out. You know it always leads to you getting me killed so relax. :laugh:

[Amora's_best_friend]

There are 20 people left in the game (11 is a majority)

Antipathy
bamf!
DargFoenix
hot_fusion
Iron Ham
JackAssterson
Jackofhearts2005
KitsuShel
m_a_caque
Magnito
MSU
NAES72
RCricket55
ReZourceman
Rokk_Krinn
splashy66
St-Dumas
Thawmus
theanalogkid
The Vision

Night 2 Begins now

[Amora's_best_friend]

Night 2 has ended.


It had felt a pain in its heart when one of the Order had died. After all, the Order was named after it. Little did it know though, the Order were traitors to Dumbledore's will.

It had spent the best part of the day and night by McGonagal's side, mourning her death. It was so involved that it didn't notice a person watching it from the shadows. Finally, a tear dropped into her lifeless mouth, and as if by magic, she woke up with a start.

Minerva McGonagal has been resurrected. Doombot 3.1 is back in the game.

She suddenly remembered how she had been betrayed by a friend, and instead of going back to the Order headquarters, she followed her resurrector.

***

Draco's hand was sweaty, holding his wand so tightly. The Dark Lord had ordered, and his only choice was to obey. The Dark Lord knew where his target was, and sure as anything Draco found the woman with beautiful blonde flowing hair and a body to kill for casting a spell in an abandoned room on the 4th floor.

He slipped into the room, without her notice. She was in a deep state of meditation, muttering a stream of words under her breathe. Draco recognised this as a long-range incapacitation charm. The door slammed behind him. Her eyes opened instantly.

He decided to do it quickly. She died with a look of surprise on her face, since normally no man could resist her Veela charm.

Jackofhearts2005 is dead. He was Fleur Delacour, and despite her glamour-modelesque looks, she was an accomplised witch.

Draco turned to leave the room, and out of the corner of his eye he saw a pair of tennis balls floating in the darkness. Before he could turn his head to get a proper look, there was a loud crack, and the room was empty.

***

Luna Lovegood enjoyed playing with the lovely animals in the forbidden forest. Too bad tonight she chose the wrong animal to play with. Rubeus didn't even know who the girl was, nor did he care. One more potential killer of Dumbledore dead.

RCricket55 is dead. He was Luna Lovegood, innocent and so young.

***

Lupin felt wrong. Dirty. Kingsley Shacklebolt had been a friend. Too bad now they were on different sides now. He knew where Shacklebolt was, and wasn't looking forward to his mission.

Ron followed Shacklebolt, his wand out. He knew the man he was protecting was wanted dead. Shacklebolt suddenly stopped in his tracks, and motioned to Ron to be silent.

Lupin took aim, a simple stunning spell would do the trick, he didn't want Shacklebolt dead after all. The red light errupted out his wand, and before it reached its target Ron had shouted "Protego!" creating a barrier of light around the pair.

Shacklebolt's face fell as he saw Lupin flee from the scene. His old friend would act to kill him? What was the world coming to?

***

Lucius Malfoy stood in the main hall, his wand at the ready. Finally the great doors flew open, the person behind them holding up their wand also. Lucius looked surprised, the assaultant was not who he had expected.

Lucius had never been that great a dueler, despite his boasts.

Rokk_Krinn is dead. He was Lucius Malfoy, despite having the dark mark, he was a good man at heart.


There are 18 players left (10 is a majority).

Antipathy
bamf!
DargFoenix
Doombot 3.1
hot_fusion
Iron Ham
JackAssterson
KitsuShel
m_a_caque
Magnito
MSU
NAES72
ReZourceman
splashy66
St-Dumas
Thawmus
theanalogkid
The Vision

Day 3 begins now.

[Thawmus]

That's.....unprecedented....

[theanalogkid]

Wow. Even the Order is evil. Who knew?

[Doombot 3.1]

That's.....unprecedented....

Tell me about it. :cheeky:

[Thawmus]

It's our usual feint - not a stone casting - as we try to figure things out. You know it always leads to you getting me killed so relax. :laugh:

I hate it when you're right.

[Amora's_best_friend]

The rest of Minerva McGonagal's memory has been taken for the penseive. She cannot remember anything of the Order.

If she miraculously remembers anything, she will be modkilled.

(So don't ask)

[Thawmus]

I'm still waiting to hear what JackAssterson has to say today.

[Doombot 3.1]

Wow. Even the Order is evil. Who knew?

Things have definitely strayed from the books. Either that, or there are a lot of Imperiused people running around.

A few thoughts:

1. If there was any doubt about it before, Hagrid is definitely a serial killer.

2. The Malfoys appear to be good. I believe the write-ups described Narcissa and Lucius as basically good, despite being Muggle and Mudblood-hating Death Eaters. :p Too bad only Draco is left (unless Fawkes feels like resurrecting them). Anyway, it's pretty clear from the writeup that Dobby (or possibly Kreacher) knows who Draco is. I'm not entirely sure that's a good thing--Dobby had plenty of good reasons to hate the Malfoys in the books. But unless Dobby wins when the Malfoys are dead, he should keep quiet about Draco's identity. Indeed, given that the Malfoys appear to be good, and that Draco can kill, he may be a vigilante. (Then again, maybe the Malfoys constitute still another mafia.)

[JackAssterson]

I'm still waiting to hear what JackAssterson has to say today.

You were investigated and the investigation came back evil.

[Thawmus]

You were investigated and the investigation came back evil.

You were misdirected.

Do you want a roleclaim or not?

[m_a_caque]

wow i got to post before the thread closed!

[theanalogkid]

Don't roleclaim. Just tell us how Jack was misdirected.

[JackAssterson]

Don't roleclaim. Just tell us how Jack was misdirected.

What analog said. DON'T roleclaim.

[Thawmus]

Don't roleclaim. Just tell us how Jack was misdirected.

That's not something I would know.

However, I do know that there's a definite logical that I'm NOT mafia, if people read the writeup for last night. Which is, I'm guessing, why he isn't voting for me today.

There's two other people that'd be capable of verifying this, but they'd end up roleclaiming to do it.

[theanalogkid]

So you saying your evil but not mafia evil. Nagini, Snape and the elder Malfoys are all evil in the books but are not out and out Death- Eaters. The only evil people we have seen in the write-ups that aren't "normally" are Lupin or Hagrid.

[Thawmus]

So you saying your evil but not mafia evil. Nagini, Snape and the elder Malfoys are all evil in the books but are not out and out Death- Eaters. The only evil people we have seen in the write-ups that aren't "normally" are Lupin or Hagrid.

Nope, not evil, period.

I'm saying that someone mucked with the investigation.

I know a few things too, that's why I wanted to hear from Jack. I can confirm at this point that he's on the level, and not Mafia.


Which kinda sucks, for me.

[Amora's_best_friend]

Lucius Malfoy's thoughts are extracted and put in the penseive. Again, the memorys are clouded. His last few memories are a complete blur apart from the faces of Hermione Granger and Nymphadora Tonks.

Also, it becomes obvious that he was deliberating whether to kill to save an unlikely ally.

[The Vision]

Wow with 4 dead each night this could be a quick game.

[Amora's_best_friend]

Wow with 4 dead each night this could be a quick game.

Short and sweet ;)

[theanalogkid]

So then you must be either under the Imperius Curse to appear evil or have drank Polyjuice Potion and you are impersonating someone evil.

[Thawmus]

So then you must be either under the Imperius Curse to appear evil or have drank Polyjuice Potion and you are impersonating someone evil.

The first is a distinct possibility that I could support, if I roleclaimed.

I don't drink PJP, however.

[Amora's_best_friend]

There is no reason why Polyjuice Potion can't be force fed.

[Antipathy]

I have information that Antipathy is evil.

Vote: Antipathy

[MSU]

I have information that Antipathy is evil.

Vote: Antipathy

well that just doesn't make any sense...why do you want to lynch yourself?

[St-Dumas]

So what's going on right now?

[Antipathy]

I have information that Antipathy is evil.

Vote: Antipathy

[MSU]

It's day and Thawmus is not evil apparently.

[Antipathy]

well that just doesn't make any sense...why do you want to lynch yourself?

I have information that Antipathy is evil.

Vote: Antipathy

[St-Dumas]

I think Antipathy is talking in code, like Rokk_Krinn in the Arkham game.

[Antipathy]

I think Antipathy is talking in code, like Rokk_Krinn in the Arkham game.

I have information that Antipathy is evil.

Vote: Antipathy

[St-Dumas]

That means yes, right?

Communicate with smiley faces, if possible.

[The Vision]

Clearly he has been mind controlled.

A hedge wizard can see that.

[Doombot 3.1]

I have information that Antipathy is evil.

Vote: Antipathy

That parallels JackAssterton's lynch vote for Thawmus the other day. Are you trying to point to one of them?

[m_a_caque]

Clearly he has been mind controlled.

A hedge wizard can see that.


i think i agree with that.

otherwise with all the deaths i'm.... blown away.

*drumroll* da dum ching!

[Thawmus]

I have information that Antipathy is evil.

Vote: Antipathy

He's being forced to say this.

[Thawmus]

There is no reason why Polyjuice Potion can't be force fed.
Well....that sucks.... :(

[Iron Ham]

Vote: No Lynch

[DarqFeonix]

Forget Polyjuice Potion, I think someone fed Antipathy Veritaserum, which forces people to tell the truth.

Vote: Anitpathy

[Amora's_best_friend]

Votes

Antipathy (2) DarqFeonix, Antipathy

No Lynch (1) Iron Ham

[The Vision]

A no lynch could be pretty dangerous at the rate that we are dropping.

[Doombot 3.1]

Forget Polyjuice Potion, I think someone fed Antipathy Veritaserum, which forces people to tell the truth.

Vote: Anitpathy

Based on his reply to St-Dumas above, it's far more likely that Antipathy has been Imperiused and forced to talk in code. Moreover, Veritaserum wouldn't force someone to vote to lynch themselves; they'd just have to admit they were evil, if asked. An Imperius curse, on the other hand, could quite plausibly force someone to vote to lynch themselves.

Finally, it's rather suspicious that you voted to lynch an obviously mind-controlled Antipathy, don't you think?

VOTE: DarqFeonix

[Amora's_best_friend]

Votes

Antipathy (2) DarqFeonix, Antipathy

DarqFeonix (1) Doombot 3.1

No Lynch (1) Iron Ham

[St-Dumas]

Doomie has made the most persuasive argument so far.

Lynch vote: DarqFeonix

[DarqFeonix]

I stand by my vote, as I think mind-control is too easy an excuse. And as ABF clearly has a love for all things Potter, I imagine Veritaserum would probably come into play some part in this game. I'm not asking for or indicating any roleclaim, but if we lynch someone now who is saying they are evil, and "Lynch Me", we should be able to find out the next day if that person is mind-controlled or under Veritaserum.

Either way, we get very important info going forward into future days, and we know how to treat people who can only vote for themselves. I perosnally think it cuts the strongs off this power pretty quickly.

That being said, there's always a chance Antipathy is the Jester role, and this is his way of getting attention...

[DarqFeonix]

Also note, I have no idea what you mean by "talking in code during the Arkham Game", as I didn't play in that one. Any explanation would be appreciated.

Oh, and I'm voting to lynch someone who obviously had something done to them... you are assuming mind-control, I assume Veritaserum. Either way, by lynching Antipathy, we find out the power tomorrow... better to find out now while we have the numbers then further down the line.

[Doombot 3.1]

I stand by my vote, as I think mind-control is too easy an excuse. And as ABF clearly has a love for all things Potter, I imagine Veritaserum would probably come into play some part in this game. I'm not asking for or indicating any roleclaim, but if we lynch someone now who is saying they are evil, and "Lynch Me", we should be able to find out the next day if that person is mind-controlled or under Veritaserum.

Either way, we get very important info going forward into future days, and we know how to treat people who can only vote for themselves. I perosnally think it cuts the strongs off this power pretty quickly.

That being said, there's always a chance Antipathy is the Jester role, and this is his way of getting attention...

I can easily see a tracker or cop using Veritaserum to force their target to reveal their identity or alignment. I just don't see someone using Veritaserum to compel another player to vote to lynch themselves. The Imperius curse is a far more plausible explanation for Antipathy's posts.

(For those of you who didn't read the books or watch the movies, it's basically truth serum; it forces whoever drinks it to answer questions truthfully, and that's it.)

I'd also have to say that it's a pretty odd strategy for a jester to post as Antipathy has done. Basically, a jester would have to try to get himself lynched without letting people know that's his goal. I just don't see voting to lynch themselves as a reasonable way to do that.

You were quick (too quick) to vote to lynch Antipathy, and in my book, that makes you suspicious.

[St-Dumas]

Also note, I have no idea what you mean by "talking in code during the Arkham Game", as I didn't play in that one. Any explanation would be appreciated.

Rokk_Krinn could only post in the form of a riddle he was given. His only real form of communication was smiley faces.

I don't know why he had to talk like that, as I was lynched that same day.

[Thawmus]

I'd like to ask that we not discuss the Arkham game until it is done with. Discussing it like this is just asking to be mod-killed in either game, not to mention being banned from future games.

I'm not saying anything's been said thus far that could or couldn't be used as info for the other game, but we could cut it close.


My general rule of thumb is to pretend other games don't exist, unless they've been completed.



That being said, I don't think Antipathy was given truth serum, and I think he's under the Imperius curse. What little information I'm aware of at this point, indicates to me that this is the most likely way for the Imperius curse to be used in this game. The truth serum seems more like a night power "ask and answer" power to me.

[DarqFeonix]

You were quick (too quick) to vote to lynch Antipathy, and in my book, that makes you suspicious.

Fair enough on that, I'll take the extra scrutiny this time, simply because I think we are better suited if we find out what this power is right off the bat, instead of ignoring it and making assumptions.

Personally, I think you may be right on the mind control aspect, as is it true that Veritaserum doesn't make you do anything other than tell the truth. So if Antipathy was simply saying "I have information that Antipathy is evil" without the Lynch Vote, the case for VS would be even stronger.

However, perhaps the only defense against VS in this case is to put as big a target on yourself. Antipathy would not technicallybe lying by saying vote for him, is could simply be the only recuse for a guilty man.

[KitsuShel]

Wow, oh what a crazy night.

So Dobby knows who Draco is? And now Antipathy keeps telling us he's evil.

Hmmm, does this mean 'Arry can be resurrected for our side?

[Magnito]

Are evil people the mafia? or is it maybe the Order that is the mafia?

[Pashmina]

*is finally allowed to post*

I hate having no life. Like trying to learn to play but just thrown in the bin without pasing go or collecting £200.

I didn't even know we were allowed to choose people to kill. I thought it was lynchs that killed people. (Especially on the first night)

[KitsuShel]

There are too many deaths per night for this to end well.

Should we go with a lynch on Antipathy, who might be evil forced to say that about himself.

or

DarqFeonix for insisting that it was Veritaserum and being understandably itching on the trigger finger.

The way I see it, we have a 50/50 chance of hitting one of our own either way. I wish we had something more substantial to go on. :(

[Magnito]

...this large number of deaths have me worried. There are too many people with the power to kill.

[DarqFeonix]

Should we go with a lynch on Antipathy, who might be evil forced to say that about himself.
or
DarqFeonix for insisting that it was Veritaserum and being understandably itching on the trigger finger.


Well, I personally vote NOT ME (heh-heh). Can I just point out though I'm not insisting VS, I merely brought it up as a viable alternative to Mind-Control. My vote is more a "holy hell there are 4 deaths a night and we're in trouble" choice, and Antipathy put himself out there, forced by either Mind-Control (evil) or Veritaserum (Good).

Once we know either way, we have ALOT to go on after what I can only guess would be four deaths tonight.

If Antipathy is murdered tonight, we have nothing to go on, and the next person we face who votes for themselves, we'll be stuck in the same situation.

Of course, by trying to figure this out with extensive Harry Potter knowledge, I'm probably just putting a big target on my back for tonight.

[bamf!]

I think some lynching has to happen. Too many people have the ability to kill. Serial killers and other evils with the ability to kill win when no one tries to act to stop them. If we don't wait only more will die. But act to hesitantly and we could kill an innocent.

Basically a rock and a hard place.

[Iron Ham]

A no lynch could be pretty dangerous at the rate that we are dropping.

:nervous:
Vote: No Lynch
Vote: No Lynch

[Thawmus]

:nervous:

Vote: No Lynch

Quote my post if you're being forced to say "no lynch"

[Iron Ham]

Wow with 4 dead each night this could be a quick game.

:noid:

:speechles

Vote: No Lynch

[KitsuShel]

I agree. Someone needs to go.

The problem with Antipathy is: He's either lying or telling the truth.

Due to some of our previous game experiences, I think some of us just think that this is a red herring since its similar to whats been done before.

But what if its not? What if someone or something is forcing him to tell the truth? If we let him off, he might be a killer. If we lynch him, he might be an townie.

SOmetimes this game calls for some hard decisions.

Vote Antipathy

Unless someone picks a more viable target for us to remove from the game, my vote stands there and my fingers remain crossed.

[Iron Ham]

Quote my post if you're being forced to say "no lynch" :grin:

Vote: No Lynch

[Iron Ham]

I agree. Someone needs to go.

:cool:

SOmetimes this game calls for some hard decisions.

:confused:

Vote Antipathy

:noid:

Vote: No Lynch

[KitsuShel]

:noid:

Vote: No Lynch

Would you rather I vote for you? :eek:

I'd rather not die in my sleep before I even have a chance to use my obscure, yet intriguing power. :cheeky:

[Iron Ham]

Would you rather I vote for you? :eek:

:angry:

I'd rather not die in my sleep before I even have a chance to use my obscure, yet intriguing power. :cheeky:


:ermm:

Vote: No Lynch

[DarqFeonix]

Okay, so Iron Ham is probably being forced to Vote No Lynch. I think this just reinforces my VS thought. It would be strange to be able to force two separate people to do things, and if one is being forced to protect the other from a lynching, it would make sense that the other person is evil...

...man, I hope I'm making sense to someone other than me.

[Iron Ham]

Okay, so Iron Ham is probably being forced to Vote No Lynch. I think this just reinforces my VS thought. It would be strange to be able to force two separate people to do things, and if one is being forced to protect the other from a lynching, it would make sense that the other person is evil...

...man, I hope I'm making sense to someone other than me.

:confused:

Vote: No Lynch

[KitsuShel]

:ermm:

Vote: No Lynch

Ok, Lassie, how about this:

Would you like us to vote no lynch? :cool:

Or would you like us to lynch Antipathy? :knockedou

Or would like us to lynch DarqPheonix? :squareeye

Or anyone else in general? :ermm: