Stand-up Comedy mafia: Last Comic(s) Standing

[Immortal_Raven]

Rules... stolen from JOH, and Darqfeonix's Joss Whedon thread, and modified just a bit...

1) There is a Town. They win by getting rid of the mafia/non-friendly neutrals. Each night, many of them do something (investigate or protect for instance) to try to find the mafia. During the day, they try to vote off the mafia.

2) There is a Mafia, maybe even more than one. They win by getting rid of everybody that isn't in their mafia. Each night, they will remove townies from the game. Each day, they will try to prevent the townies from voting them off.

3) If more than half the players vote for the same player during the day (i.e. Majority), that player is lynched and is removed from the game. You should bold your lynch votes so that I don't miss them or think you are kidding. You can vote for anyone but chances are nothing will happen if you try to lynch someone who isn't playing. You can also vote for a No Lynch, but some mods will remove a random player from the game to ensure that the game doesn't stagnate if no player is voted off. If you feel like leaving a vote with someone, you can say Leave Vote with: Player X. You cannot "leave with majority".

4) There are unfriendly neutrals that could be trying to kill everybody or recruit their own mafia or maybe something else entirely. They win in odd ways but they hurt the town so the town must eliminate them to win.

5) There are friendly neutrals. They also have strange win conditions but they don't really hurt the town. Sometimes they can win with either the town or the mafia but in general the town doesn't need to get rid of them. Friendly and unfriendly neutrals are hard to tell apart and you'll just have to use your best judgment on whether you want to vote for them or leave them be.

6) Don't do these 3 things: Quote your role pm or the role pm of anybody else, talk about this game outside of this thread even via pm unless you are pming a mason teammate or a mafia teammate, and don't edit your posts. If you do one of these 3 things, you may be modkilled to ensure the game's fairness. I'm a stickler for these. You see how it says 'may'? Assume may = will.

Raven's personal notes:
-Phases during the week will last 24 hours. I will post the deadline for votes to be accepted. The thread may not close exactly at that time, but no votes will be counted after the deadline.

-weekend phases will be approximately 36 hours with some variation depending on my schedule. Again, there will be a posted deadline.
All deadlines posted will be Mountain Standard Time, or MST.

-This is my first time out of the gate, so forgive me if I screw up. If you don't get your action in during the night phase, tough. I will try to pm people who haven't sent in with about 2 hours remaining in the night phase, but that's all I'll do. If you still don't get it in, you took no action.

[Immortal_Raven]

This will be the player tracking post and night write-up post. I will update it each day and night with lynches, kills, and write-ups.

Still Standing-(1)
12. SIlver Lantern-Christopher Titus(Neutral)

Off the Stage-(17)
15. Jackofhearts2005-Ron White(Mafia)
1. Quebbster-Eddie Izzard(Town)
6. Mr. Stranger-Richard Jeni(Neutral)
13. Ouchmaker-Lewis Black(Town)
7. Magnito-Dane Cook(Neutral)
16. SLVRSR4-Ken Jeong(Town)
17. Rokk_Krinn-Louis C.K.(Town)
2. Darqfeonix-Mitch Hedberg(Town)
3. batfink (formerly The Darkstone)-Larry the Cable Guy(mafia)
10. Jerry_Damage01-Ellen Degeneres(Town)
4. Wade Wilson-Bill Engvall(Mafia)
14. Cornucopia2(formerly CrusaderC)-George Carlin(Town)
8. Truffle Shuffle-Kathy Griffin(Town)
11. normalview-Chris Rock(Town)
5. deadshot042-Jeff Foxworthy(Mafia)
9. Cornucopia1-Carlos Mencia(Neutral)
18. eternalrage-Brian Posehn(Town)

Write-ups:
D1/N1: http://www.hcrealms.com/forum/showthread.php?t=303983&page=5
D2/N2: http://www.hcrealms.com/forum/showthread.php?p=5336424#post5336424
D3/N3: http://www.hcrealms.com/forum/showthread.php?p=5343247#post5343247
D4/N4: http://www.hcrealms.com/forum/showthread.php?p=5348085#post5348085
D5/N5: http://www.hcrealms.com/forum/showthread.php?p=5353734#post5353734
D6/N6:http://www.hcrealms.com/forum/showthread.php?p=5358171#post5358171
D7/N7:http://www.hcrealms.com/forum/showthread.php?p=5360973&posted=1#post5360973

[Immortal_Raven]

Night 0:

The best thing about being a comedian, they don’t ask for a urine sample. If they do, it’s to make sure you’re on something. No one right in the head can actually think this stuff up. In fact, a raging drug problem or criminal record is a badge of honor in the business. It shows true dedication. Nevertheless, sometimes it gets the better of us, sometimes in a fatal way.

Another thing you need, balls of solid rock and a thick skin. Yeah, you’re going up there and it’s just you, and a Mike. No props unless your a chump like Carrottop and Gallagher. No back-up singers. Just you, your brain, your voice, your body, and a mike. And if you suck, they’ll let you know it. Sometimes with words and boos, sometimes with beer bottles and congealed left over food. Utter crap if you ask me. You don’t see a secretary getting pelted with food because she didn’t answer the phone on time. I would pay to see that though, but I’m a twisted, sentimental fool like that.

Anyhow, life on the road is rough. You think it’s all glamour and applause, it’s not. It’s cutting your teeth in a dingy, dive bar as a second job while you’re a janitor for a crappy public school during the day. It’s driving all night to play a 30 minute set in the hopes that your cut of that night’s take will pay for the gas to return to your home. Home, a crummy one-bedroom apartment with a nagging wife and a screaming child. And people wonder why I drink.

Eventually, it pays off though. Soon, you’re playing in larger places, places without permanent urine stains in the bathrooms, places that actually pay you a fee in addition to your cut of the night’s take. Then the unthinkable happens, you get a call from Comedy Central or HBO asking to put you on television. Television, true recognition. Naturally you do it, and hope it will land you a permanent gig somewhere. More often than not, you get your special, then fade into obscurity. But a select few have bigger success, even making a living at this. I presume that’s why you’re all here.

As much as I complain, it’s better than the alternative. I mean, I have a law degree from Harvard, from freaking Harvard. Have you guessed who I am yet? Don’t worry, I’ll tell you soon. I died last year, but it wasn’t from a drug overdose, though that did contribute. I was a laywer making tons of cash as most of them do, but I was miserable. A tool of the system. Ask around, conformity and serving the system are considered uncool in my line of work. Almost making you a social pariah.

I drank for many years, and I was darn good at it. In fact, it caused my divorce and a bunch of other crap to happen. I was trying to make amends, I figured I had to walk the walk if I was to be taken seriously as a father. But I got careless. I had to take some prescription medication for something, I don’t even remember what, and I overdosed. While I was in the hospital....

The mob approached.

“He’s here” said one.

“Yes, this will be awesome”

“We’ll teach him to mock us even when it’s not our Roast.”

“Yeah, permanently.”

Moving inside the hospital, the mob proceeded straight toward my room. When they entered, I looked up feebly. Never did I think all these people would get along and find some common ground, but apparently I had caused it. Kind of gratifying, I did what I didn’t think was possible. As they started pummeling me in rage and in jubilation, I closed my eyes and let go. This wasn’t a terribly awesome way to go, but I wasn’t going to give them the satisfaction. They all took their shots, and in the end, I was dead, never to perform again.

Immortal_Raven is dead. He was Greg Giraldo(Neutral). Roaster, skeezebag, and comedian extraordinaire.

iPTowp3e77k

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iPTowp3e77k

With 18 players left, 10 is majority. This day phase will end at 8:25 AM, Tuesday, February 15th, 2011.

[Quebbster]

Yay, new game!
Is the typo in the title intentional?

[Immortal_Raven]

No, just me rushing. You can fix it with your mod powers right?

[normalview]

New game! Yay :)

[Quebbster]

Let us never speak about it again.

[eternalrage]

Checking in.
Bwahahaha!

[Silver Lantern]

This ought a be a lot of fun, but someone needs to teach IR how to link You Tube videos for the enjoyment of all.

[Immortal_Raven]

This ought a be a lot of fun, but someone needs to teach IR how to link You Tube videos for the enjoyment of all.

So I forgot to post the link. I don't know how to embed the whole video directly on the thread though. So if anyone has knowledge, shoot me a pm.

[Silver Lantern]

I would if I knew, but you tube video links don't work for me half the time I try to link them. You can go to another game where someone has linked videos and try to quote the post to see the formatting though.

[normalview]

So I forgot to post the link. I don't know how to embed the whole video directly on the thread though. So if anyone has knowledge, shoot me a pm.

Just type "youtube"xxxxxx"/youtube" where the quotes are brackets [ ] and the xxxxx are the alphanumeric code at the end of the youtube url.

For example (hit reply to see the code I've used):

hp69rg6Hdlo

[normalview]

Just type "youtube"xxxxxx"/youtube" where the quotes are brackets [ ] and the xxxxx are the alphanumeric code at the end of the youtube url.

For example (hit reply to see the code I've used):

hp69rg6Hdlo

And by "reply" of course I mean "quote" because I am an idiot ;)

[Immortal_Raven]

Sweet, it's up, all nice and shiny.

[DarqFeonix]

Poor Greg... man, he was my favorite, and his sudden loss sucked... sucked just as hard as all the great ones before him sucked.

My personal favorite Giraldo moment: Greg totally destroying Denis Leary on Tough Crowd after taking hit after hit from, and Leary's hilairous "Oh ####" face when he knows he just got schooled.

[Wade Wilson]

I remember that fluffy guy or something :-/ don't remember his name though

[deadshot042]

Checking in. I'd try to act like the cool kids and give IR crap, but I'm more excited about the game starting.

[Magnito]

Sad that I'm not Mitch. :(

[DarqFeonix]

Sad that I'm not Mitch. :(

I'm guessing a lot of people are sad about that.

[Wade Wilson]

Who is Mitch?

[Cornucopia]

Who is Mitch?

I'm here. Yay new game


Wade - I hope you're kidding

[Wade Wilson]

I know very little to nothing about stand up comedians

[DarqFeonix]

Lynch: Wade Wilson

[deadshot042]

I know very little to nothing about stand up comedians

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitch_Hedberg

Do yourself a favor and spend sometime on youtube with this man. :)

[Wade Wilson]

Will have to look into it later, is past my bedtime...

[Immortal_Raven]

Yay, my first vote count:

Wade Wilson(1): Darqfeonix



Again, 10 votes is majority.

[Ouchmaker]

Figures, the day a new game opens, I'm killed in the only one I was still in.

Vote: Wade

[Mr Stranger]

Vote: Wade

Checking in.

[Immortal_Raven]

Vote count:

Wade Wilson(3): Darqfeonix, Ouchmaker, Stranger



Again, 10 votes is majority.

[Jerry_Damage01]

New Game!

And Vote Wade for not knowing who Mitch Hedburg is.

[Immortal_Raven]

New Game!

And Vote Wade for not knowing who Mitch Hedburg is.

Modslap for not knowing how to spell Hedberg.


Vote Count:

Wade Wilson(4): Darq, Ouch, Stranger, Jerry

[deadshot042]

Are we really going to put four votes on Wade for not knowing who Mitch is?

I think he deserves our pity, not our condemnation. :laugh:

[Mr Stranger]

Are we really going to put four votes on Wade for not knowing who Mitch is?

I think he deserves our pity, not our condemnation. :laugh:

Oh, you mean we're not just voting for Wade because we want him dead?

Well damn.

[Jerry_Damage01]

Modslap for not knowing how to spell Hedberg.

Oh yeah....your face!

Totally nailed him on that one. :)

[deadshot042]

Oh yeah....your face!

Totally nailed him on that one. :)

You think you're the funniest person here... You must be Dane Cook. :cheeky:

[Silver Lantern]

You think you're the funniest person here... You must be Dane Cook. :cheeky:

Please do not mention that name in a thread about comedy...

[deadshot042]

Please do not mention that name in a thread about comedy...

If you didn't pick up on it, I'm not exactly a fan either.

[Wade Wilson]

I love Dane Cook!









No, not really most movies he is in pretty much suck :-/

[deadshot042]

I love Dane Cook!

You already have four people voting for you. You cannot say things like that or else others may make rash decisions and lynch away.

[DarqFeonix]

Dane Cook Hate is beyond cliche.

The dude is hilarious. End of story.

[Wade Wilson]

lynch Darq

[Jerry_Damage01]

Change Vote Darq for thinking Dane Cook is hilarious.

[Jackofhearts2005]

You might want to replace Rokk. He's kinda got some stuff going on.

That said, he's been around a bit. He might welcome a distraction. IDK.

[Immortal_Raven]

You might want to replace Rokk. He's kinda got some stuff going on.

That said, he's been around a bit. He might welcome a distraction. IDK.

I've talked with him and he said he's playing. If I fail to get actions from him, he will be replaced.

Vote Count:

Wade(3): Darq, Ouch, Stranger
Darq(2): Jerry, Wade

[Jackofhearts2005]

Just wanted to make sure. Glad to have Rokk back. Hopefully that means things are going well.

[deadshot042]

I'm glad to be in another game with Rokk, hope he's able to stick around. :)

[Mr Stranger]

The voting is interesting :)

[Cornucopia]

Oh yeah....your face!

Totally nailed him on that one. :)

You think you're the funniest person here... You must be Dane Cook.

[Jerry_Damage01]

You think you're the funniest person here... You must be Dane Cook.

No not Dane Cook. Although I probably have interviewed him before.

[deadshot042]

No not Dane Cook. Although I probably have interviewed him before.

I don't normally think of Jon Stewart as a comic, but that could be it...

You think you're the funniest person here... You must be Dane Cook.

This is what I said earlier, therefore you steal jokes, therefore you might be Carlos Mencia. I'm getting good at this game.

[Silver Lantern]

I don't normally think of Jon Stewart as a comic, but that could be it...

This is what I said earlier, therefore you steal jokes, therefore you might be Carlos Mencia. I'm getting good at this game.

You think you're clever when you really aren't, therefore, you might be Dane Cook...

Boy, I think I'm getting good at this game too... :p

[Mr Stranger]

You think you're clever when you really aren't, therefore, you might be Dane Cook...

Boy, I think I'm getting good at this game too... :p

You insult everyone around you and think it's actually funny.

You must be Silver Lantern.

[deadshot042]

You think you're clever when you really aren't, therefore, you might be Dane Cook...

Boy, I think I'm getting good at this game too... :p

I think that just makes me any college student wearing a t-shirt with a slogan on it. :laugh:

[deadshot042]

You insult everyone around you and think it's actually funny.

You must be Silver Lantern.

Rep for being the first person to get one right.

[SLVRSR4]

Sorry I'm just now getting on here guys. Did I miss anything?

[Quebbster]

lynch Wade

[Immortal_Raven]

Vote Count:

Wade(4): Darq, Ouch, Stranger, Quebbs
Darq(2): Jerry, Wade

Phase ends in roughly one hour.

[Rokk_Krinn]

You might want to replace Rokk. He's kinda got some stuff going on.

That said, he's been around a bit. He might welcome a distraction. IDK.

I'm around...kind-of. My schedule is just busier these days.

[Quebbster]

I'm around...kind-of. My schedule is just busier these days.

A little Rokk is way better than no Rokk.

[Cornucopia]

I wonder if Demetri Martin is here? I think he's pretty funny.

[Cornucopia]

Dane Cook Hate is beyond cliche.

The dude is hilarious. End of story.

I saw him once. I thought he was pretty funny. Then when I saw his next show on TV, I realized his material all sounds. Or it at least sounds the same to me. I still think he's funny, but I think hilarious is not the best word to describe him.

[Immortal_Raven]

Day 1: Bruised Egos, Limbs intact

The comics circled one another, roaming the room like socialites at a high-society ball. Each one was under the perception that they, and they alone were the star, the reason that everyone was here. Alas, some dreams came to a halt rather suddenly, and others never really materialized. Some punches were thrown, metaphorically speaking. Verbal jabs and insults were heaped upon several people, but in the end, everyone was a little leary of doing anything. Can’t make the first move, lest it be a wrong one. And so, instead of a lynch, you get to hear more of my drivel. Or better yet, how about one of the best comedians who is not in this game since he’s not really a stand-up, Stephen Colbert.


taPTqd8g7yg

AGi8jSGpr5U&feature=related


Night 1 begins now. You have 24 hours.

[Immortal_Raven]

Night 1: Things that go bump in the Night.
“Someone always has to do the dirty work, but it seems like it’s always me.”

The man went about his task dutifully, if grudgingly. Stuff needed to be done and that was that. Searching this way and that, he thought he saw his quarry disappear down an alley. Hastening his step, he quickly caught up to the figure and aimed his gun. Shining a flashlight at his prey, he discovered that it was not his intended prey.

“Put that light down, and the gun too for that matter.”

“I ain’t supposed to kill you, but I think I can make an exception.”

Raising the gun, he squeezed the trigger. The bullet struck his prey in the arm.

“You’ll have to do better than that.” said the man as he dashed down the alley and disappeared.

“Well, that’s a new one.”


---------------------------------------------------------------

The awkward man was stumbling home through the dark. He’d been out performing until 2:00 AM. He was tired, slightly drunk, and desperately needed a shower.

“Stupid barkeep took my keys. I can drive 13 blocks. I’m upright for Pete’s Sake and I’m six foot six.”

On he ranted and rambled through the darkened streets. He was so preoccupied with his misery that he did not see or hear the car coming as he started crossing the street. By the time he saw it, nothing could be done. His legs flew out from under him in a snapping blur, catapulting him over the roof of the car and crashing to the street below.

The car stopped immediately after impact. A shadowy figure emerged from the driver’s side and strode over to the body. Glancing down:

“Good, that dork had it coming.”

Then the figure went back to the car, got in, and drove off.

eternalrage is dead. He was Brian Posehn, awkward, dorky, metal comedian, a man who made being creepy look acceptable.(Town)

YDJDpuKG7Pw&feature=related

I couldn't find any stand-up where he wasn't cussing up a storm. Don't know what is acceptable and what is not.
One player has been silenced and may not post
With 16 active players left, 9 is majority.

[DarqFeonix]

Can you Bold the Dead and Silenced bits?

[Magnito]

Lynch Cornucopia

Yes, I have my reasons.

[Jerry_Damage01]

Lynch Cornucopia

Yes, I have my reasons.

Alright, I'll help out with a pressure vote.

Vote Corn

[SLVRSR4]

Lynch Cornucopia

Yes, I have my reasons.

I've got nothing better to go on, so I'll help put some pressure on

Lynch vote: Cornucopia

[normalview]

Sure, why not.

vote Cornucopia



In the interest of further other avenues of discussion, how was your night Quebbster?

[Silver Lantern]

Lynch Cornucopia

Yes, I have my reasons.

Ooohhh!!! This isn't the typical Mags out for revenge vote...

Vote: Corn-heiser-u-copia

[deadshot042]

Lynch: Corn

That makes for six, plenty of pressure.

[normalview]

Lynch: Corn

That makes for six, plenty of pressure.

Enough, in fact, for a quick rush to "accidentally" finish him.

remove vote for now.

[Jerry_Damage01]

Enough, in fact, for a quick rush to "accidentally" finish him.

remove vote for now.

Yeah 5 of 9 is over half so it's good enough for pressure.

[Immortal_Raven]

Vote Count:

Cornucopia(5): Mags, Jerry, SLVRSR4, Silver, Deadshot

[Quebbster]

Sure, why not.

vote Cornucopia



In the interest of further other avenues of discussion, how was your night Quebbster?
I've had better... My action failed.

[Wade Wilson]

Intersting...

[Cornucopia]

Lynch Cornucopia

Yes, I have my reasons.

I highly doubt it. I'm interested to see what info. you got.

I'm Carlos Mencia. Neutral.

I win with either side.

I steal someone's power and use it on another player. The player whose power I steal will receive a fail message.

I targeted Quebbs to use his power on Darq.

You can lynch me if you want to take out a neutral, but both Quebbs and Darq and still alive, so it should be clear that I'm not the SK.

[Quebbster]

That's an interesting claim.

[deadshot042]

I highly doubt it. I'm interested to see what info. you got.

I'm Carlos Mencia. Neutral.

Haha. I actually called this.

[normalview]

I highly doubt it. I'm interested to see what info. you got.

I'm Carlos Mencia. Neutral.

I win with either side.

I steal someone's power and use it on another player. The player whose power I steal will receive a fail message.

I targeted Quebbs to use his power on Darq.

You can lynch me if you want to take out a neutral, but both Quebbs and Darq and still alive, so it should be clear that I'm not the SK.

This is easy enough to confirm:

Darq, what happened to you last night?

Then, Quebbster can confirm whether or not that is what his power is supposed to do.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I'm Carlos Mencia.

Vote: Cornucopia :p

[Immortal_Raven]

Vote Count:

Cornucopia(6): Mags, Jerry, SLVRSR4, Silver, Deadshot, JoH

On a side note, I officially love office potlucks. Curry surf and turf, yum yum.

[Quebbster]

Anyone want to speculate on why Mencia would be Neutral?
Any guesses about Mafia themes?

[Ouchmaker]

Anyone want to speculate on why Mencia would be Neutral?

Look at his power description, and the fact that Mencia has more than once stolen material from other comedians. Why would he be anything else (except maybe Mafia).

Vote: Cornucopia

[normalview]

Anyone want to speculate on why Mencia would be Neutral?

Because he's a no talent, theiving hack?

Any guesses about Mafia themes?


People who are even less funny than Mencia?




Seriously, though, I've got no idea.

[Quebbster]

I don't know anything about Mencia, I guess I should be thankful for that. :)

7 votes out of 9 at this point in the day phase is a bad sign though.

[Immortal_Raven]

Vote Count:

Cornucopia(7): Mags, Jerry, SLVRSR4, Silver, Deadshot, JoH, Ouchmaker

[normalview]

7 votes out of 9 at this point in the day phase is a bad sign though.

I agree. Which is one of the reasons I removed my vote when I did.

Sure, he's (at best) neutral, so no great loss to the town if he's lynched... but if we rush this, we lose any oppotunity for other information to come out.

At least we'll get some voting history, I guess. :ermm:

[Jerry_Damage01]

Carlos has some good material. I've seen him live and he's really good. Of course he did steal some jokes, which kind of taints everything, but outside of that I thought he was good.

[normalview]

Carlos has some good material. I've seen him live and he's really good. Of course he did steal some jokes, which kind of taints everything, but outside of that I thought he was good.

Some of the skits he did on his Comedy Central show were okay, but I really didn't care for his stand-up act.

To each their own :)

[Truffle Shuffle]

My bad. Completely forgot I was in this one. Didn't send in an action last night. My bad.

I'm not going to vote for Corn until we hear from Darq and Quebbs. Seriously folks, why the rush on a neutral? And Mags might have something else to say as well now that Corn has claimed.

[deadshot042]

Remove Vote

I believe the claim and power and he isn't a direct threat to the town.

[Wade Wilson]

My bad. Completely forgot I was in this one. Didn't send in an action last night. My bad.

I'm not going to vote for Corn until we hear from Darq and Quebbs. Seriously folks, why the rush on a neutral? And Mags might have something else to say as well now that Corn has claimed.

No need to rush but there is a higher chance he is the SK. I think I would have believed it better if Quebbs didn't say he was roleblocked before the claim honestly, and with one kill last night...one must have been blocked. Food for thought.

[Quebbster]

By the way, the odds of being able to tell if my power was used on Darq are not good.
Also, Corn is not a good lynch at this point, but he's definitely better than no lynch if no better target comes along.

[Rokk_Krinn]

I have reason to doubt the validity of what Corn is saying about his actions.

[Quebbster]

No need to rush but there is a higher chance he is the SK. I think I would have believed it better if Quebbs didn't say he was roleblocked before the claim honestly, and with one kill last night...one must have been blocked. Food for thought.
To me it looks like one of the killers hit a target with kill immunity...

Also, I'm very interested in hearing from Darq after rereading the writeup.

[Wade Wilson]

I will need to reread it later, was exhausted when I read it earlier but now I got to head out for awhile...

[Rokk_Krinn]

Pity as I think Wade has some answers for us.

[Truffle Shuffle]

Worried Darqles is the silenced one.

[Wade Wilson]

So did anyone successfully target Quebbs last night?

[Rokk_Krinn]

So did anyone successfully target Quebbs last night?


You're back? Great. As I said I think you can shed some light on things about DF. What do you think of Truff's theory?

[normalview]

Worried Darqles is the silenced one.

He was the first post of the day, unless I misread things.

[normalview]

So did anyone successfully target Quebbs last night?

Possibly. I did ask him how his night went, after all ;)


And, no, for the moment I don't think I want to say anything more.

[Wade Wilson]

You're back? Great. As I said I think you can shed some light on things about DF. What do you think of Truff's theory?

This basically(what Normalview said), though it is weird that he made a post at the beginning of the thread and is now quiet. If he posted while silenced I would assume he would've been modkilled as Darq should know better.

He was the first post of the day, unless I misread things.

Possibly. I did ask him how his night went, after all ;)


And, no, for the moment I don't think I want to say anything more.

Ok, I was under the impression he was jailkept last night *shrugs*

[Immortal_Raven]

This basically(what Normalview said), though it is weird that he made a post at the beginning of the thread and is now quiet. If he posted while silenced I would assume he would've been modkilled as Darq should know better.





Ok, I was under the impression he was jailkept last night *shrugs*

Ok, my first mod mistake. I sent Darq's pm after opening the thread. Since the post was immaterial, he's still alive.

[Wade Wilson]

I guess that answers Truffle's Question then

[Truffle Shuffle]

Ok, my first mod mistake. I sent Darq's pm after opening the thread. Since the post was immaterial, he's still alive.

Well, I would hope he would be alive even if it wasn't immaterial, since, if I'm reading this right, it wasn't actually his fault?

So, Quebbs, is your power to silence?

[normalview]

I guess that answers Truffle's Question then

Indeed.

And now we know that the four others who haven't yet checked in today are either sandbagging or have legitimately just not checked in.

[Wade Wilson]

I will be back in a few hours, need to go take care of some things.

[SLVRSR4]

wade's gone again. Dufraine...search party of 3

[Silver Lantern]

This is easy enough to confirm:

Darq, what happened to you last night?

Then, Quebbster can confirm whether or not that is what his power is supposed to do.

Not sure this is necessary to out Quebs power to save a neutral.

I agree. Which is one of the reasons I removed my vote when I did.

Sure, he's (at best) neutral, so no great loss to the town if he's lynched... but if we rush this, we lose any oppotunity for other information to come out.

At least we'll get some voting history, I guess. :ermm:

Also not sure that a neutral vote record is all that beneficial.

My bad. Completely forgot I was in this one. Didn't send in an action last night. My bad.

I'm not going to vote for Corn until we hear from Darq and Quebbs. Seriously folks, why the rush on a neutral? And Mags might have something else to say as well now that Corn has claimed.

At this point we have to presuming that Mags copped corn.

SO FOR THOSE NOT PAYING TOO MUCH ATTENTION, IF YOU'RE A DOCTOR, A DOUBLER, A GUIDE, OR A REVERSE TRACKER, YOU NEED TO BE ON MAGNITO FROM HERE ON OUT, EVERY SINGLE NIGHT.

Remove Vote

I believe the claim and power and he isn't a direct threat to the town.

Well, he could be a direct threat. If he steals a NK and starts killing townies. Or if he starts stealing the cop's or doctor's powers. Not sure he's safe enough to keep around. In fact, the more I think about it, the more I think his claim is a safe claim for the mafia Control Misdirector. As there wouldn't be much of a way for us to distinguish the power & effect that Corn is claiming and that of a CMDer.

No need to rush but there is a higher chance he is the SK. I think I would have believed it better if Quebbs didn't say he was roleblocked before the claim honestly, and with one kill last night...one must have been blocked. Food for thought.

Well if he did steal Quebs power that could explain why Quebs thought he was blocked, but he may have been blocked from an independent source. Quebs did you get a failed message or a "you were blocked" message?

Corn, why do you steal our powers? What is the point of it? I'm not sure I understand it too well. You say you're just a neutral survivor, right? No funky win condition?

I have reason to doubt the validity of what Corn is saying about his actions.

Suspicion/deductive reasoning based reason, or something more substantial? I ask because you're not voting for him so I am not sure how strong the reason is or isn't.

This basically(what Normalview said), though it is weird that he made a post at the beginning of the thread and is now quiet. If he posted while silenced I would assume he would've been modkilled as Darq should know better.

Ok, I was under the impression he was jailkept last night *shrugs*

Anyone else reading this like Wade is the silencer and he's upset that Darq posted and didn't get modkilled? Maybe I'm just reading into it too much.

Well, I would hope he would be alive even if it wasn't immaterial, since, if I'm reading this right, it wasn't actually his fault?

So, Quebbs, is your power to silence?

Yeah, don't think it's fair to mod kill him if he wasn't even on notice that he was silenced. That would be a mafia due process violation! :p

wade's gone again. Dufraine...search party of 3

Hehehe, Mitch ftw!

[Wade Wilson]

Now I have the Dee Dee Dee song stuck in my head -_-; but I don't know, just all seems convient to me is all.

[Quebbster]

Well, I would hope he would be alive even if it wasn't immaterial, since, if I'm reading this right, it wasn't actually his fault?

So, Quebbs, is your power to silence?
No it is not.

And since my action failed I wasn't CMD'd either.

[Rokk_Krinn]

Wade is the Silencer. Corn did not target DF, near as I can tell. Hadn't voted yet as we had time and some things needed answering but...

lynch vote Corn

[Quebbster]

Wade is the Silencer. Corn did not target DF, near as I can tell. Hadn't voted yet as we had time and some things needed answering but...

lynch vote Corn
Interesting.

Vote Corn... Mmm... Corn...

[Mr Stranger]

That's 8/9, absurd.

Vote: Wade

I have more problem with him...being a silencer I mean.

[SLVRSR4]

SO FOR THOSE NOT PAYING TOO MUCH ATTENTION, IF YOU'RE A DOCTOR, A DOUBLER, A GUIDE, OR A REVERSE TRACKER, YOU NEED TO BE ON MAGNITO FROM HERE ON OUT, EVERY SINGLE NIGHT.

Why would one need to be on magnito if you have one of those powers? I'm confused by this.

[Quebbster]

I'm not sure we have time to pressure Wade today.

[Quebbster]

Why would one need to be on magnito if you have one of those powers? I'm confused by this.
Because the cop is a very important role and should be protected and aided.
Doing that lets the scum kill of other players at their leisure though.

[SLVRSR4]

Because the cop is a very important role and should be protected and aided.
Doing that lets the scum kill of other players at their leisure though.

Did I miss something where Magnito role claimed or something?

Or do we just KNOW or insinuate that he's the cop?

[Mr Stranger]

I'm not sure we have time to pressure Wade today.

But we instead have time to lynch Corn?

I doubt he's the serial killer.

[Silver Lantern]

Why would one need to be on magnito if you have one of those powers? I'm confused by this.

What Quebs says below

Because the cop is a very important role and should be protected and aided.
Doing that lets the scum kill of other players at their leisure though.

I would prefer a sure copping of 2 people per night with accurate results than hoping our doctor gets lucky and is somehow able to predict who the mafia/SK is going to hit anyway.

Did I miss something where Magnito role claimed or something?

Or do we just KNOW or insinuate that he's the cop?

Not a direct claim, he just implied he did. If he doesn't want all that support and attention directed at him, I am sure he will let us know.

[Wade Wilson]

That's 8/9, absurd.

Vote: Wade

I have more problem with him...being a silencer I mean.

Not a silencer, granted I don't expect to be believed over Rokk as I am not as popular so it may be best just not to fight it at this point. Just hope someday people learn from their mistakes.

[Mr Stranger]

Not a silencer, granted I don't expect to be believed over Rokk as I am not as popular so it may be best just not to fight it at this point. Just hope someday people learn from their mistakes.

Interesting, so Corn claims that Quebbs is a silencer.
Quebbster denies this.
Rokk says Wade is the silencer.
Wade denies this.

One of you is the damn silencer.

[Wade Wilson]

It depends on who you want to believe. You said that Corn isn't the SK, which means you believe him meaning Quebbs is the silencer, correct? You can either believe Corn or Rokk here, not both.

[Mr Stranger]

It depends on who you want to believe. You said that Corn isn't the SK, which means you believe him meaning Quebbs is the silencer, correct? You can either believe Corn or Rokk here, not both.

I believe strongly that you're mafia, although I'm not positive on the silencer part.

[Wade Wilson]

People always think I am mafia when I am not, I think it may be my play style *shrugs* I have only been trying to be helpful this phase, if you have seen where I haven't been then please point it out.

[Quebbster]

Not a silencer, granted I don't expect to be believed over Rokk as I am not as popular so it may be best just not to fight it at this point. Just hope someday people learn from their mistakes.
Wade, the "poor little me" routine gets old real fast. Just saying.
Interesting, so Corn claims that Quebbs is a silencer.
Quebbster denies this.
Rokk says Wade is the silencer.
Wade denies this.

One of you is the damn silencer.
I don't think Corn ever implied I was a silencer. He just said my power was used on Darq. Darq ended up silenced, but that does not necessarily mean that my power was the one that silenced him.
That's sort of the reason I think Corn is a good lynch at this point though, to test the validity of Rokk's statement. If Corn is indeed Neutral Carlos Mencia, we know he told the truth as far as he knew it and that Rokk's info is not accurate. That's good info to get from the lynching of a Neutral.
If Corn is not who he says he is he should be lynched anyway. :)

[Mr Stranger]

Wade, the "poor little me" routine gets old real fast. Just saying.

I don't think Corn ever implied I was a silencer. He just said my power was used on Darq. Darq ended up silenced, but that does not necessarily mean that my power was the one that silenced him.
That's sort of the reason I think Corn is a good lynch at this point though, to test the validity of Rokk's statement. If Corn is indeed Neutral Carlos Mencia, we know he told the truth as far as he knew it and that Rokk's info is not accurate. That's good info to get from the lynching of a Neutral.
If Corn is not who he says he is he should be lynched anyway. :)

And what if we instead harness Corn's power like a cop?

We could tell him who to target at night, and if we feel he can't prove his powers then we lynch him.

But why lose that opportunity now?

[Quebbster]

And what if we instead harness Corn's power like a cop?

We could tell him who to target at night, and if we feel he can't prove his powers then we lynch him.

But why lose that opportunity now?

remove vote - though I may still put it back if we don't get close to a lynch.
Main problem here is that Neutrals generally cannot be trusted. On the other hand, a Neutral outed on an early stage better do his best to at least appear to be acting in the Town's best interests.
But hey, if Corn wants to try to use Wade's power tonight and see if his target gets silenced I'm willing to give him a chance - I don't like the "Neutrals = scum" train of thought that some have, although it is dangerous to let Neutrals run around unchecked.

[SLVRSR4]

remove vote - though I may still put it back if we don't get close to a lynch.
Main problem here is that Neutrals generally cannot be trusted. On the other hand, a Neutral outed on an early stage better do his best to at least appear to be acting in the Town's best interests.
But hey, if Corn wants to try to use Wade's power tonight and see if his target gets silenced I'm willing to give him a chance - I don't like the "Neutrals = scum" train of thought that some have, although it is dangerous to let Neutrals run around unchecked.

I hear you there. In another game, Thanos was a character and was neutral. I'm a Thanos fan, but wouldn't trust him any further than I could throw him!

[Quebbster]

I hear you there. In another game, Thanos was a character and was neutral. I'm a Thanos fan, but wouldn't trust him any further than I could throw him!

The way I think of Neutrals is that they are on the side that is currently stronger. Early in the game, they are mostly Town oriented as the Town outnumbers the Mafia. The longer the game goes on the more they shift towards supporting the Mafia though.

[SLVRSR4]

The way I think of Neutrals is that they are on the side that is currently stronger. Early in the game, they are mostly Town oriented as the Town outnumbers the Mafia. The longer the game goes on the more they shift towards supporting the Mafia though.

Well, then on that note I am goint to REMOVE VOTE, but let's not forget who could come back and get us later when we get closer to the end.

[Wade Wilson]

Not always, I have seen Mafia aligned Neutrals...hell I have killed them before as mafia(you can see Thawmus' Heroes) because they were starting to step onto our toes. Most neutrals are wild cards, which are dangerous in the wrong hands.

[Quebbster]

Not always, I have seen Mafia aligned Neutrals...hell I have killed them before as mafia(you can see Thawmus' Heroes) because they were starting to step onto our toes. Most neutrals are wild cards, which are dangerous in the wrong hands.

Yeah, I have been a Mafia aligned Neutral too. The Mafia lynched me the last day as the day opened after I went to bed...
But hey, if you feel that Corn should be lynched then by all means vote for him.

[Quebbster]

Totally unofficial vote count:

Cornucopia(6): Mags, Jerry, Silver, JoH, Ouch, Rokk
Wade (1): Mr S

[SLVRSR4]

Loathe as I am to do this to a fellow Ogre, I am going to Vote: LYNCH WADE to hopefully get a role claim out of him.

[Quebbster]

Yeah, Wade is giving me a bad vibe.
vote Wade

[normalview]

Wade, the "poor little me" routine gets old real fast. Just saying.

I don't think Corn ever implied I was a silencer. He just said my power was used on Darq. Darq ended up silenced, but that does not necessarily mean that my power was the one that silenced him.
That's sort of the reason I think Corn is a good lynch at this point though, to test the validity of Rokk's statement. If Corn is indeed Neutral Carlos Mencia, we know he told the truth as far as he knew it and that Rokk's info is not accurate. That's good info to get from the lynching of a Neutral.
If Corn is not who he says he is he should be lynched anyway. :)

I completely agree with this. VOTE Corn

If you're telling the truth, Corn, sorry, but at least we learned some more about the other people voting for you.

[Cornucopia]

Well if he did steal Quebs power that could explain why Quebs thought he was blocked, but he may have been blocked from an independent source. Quebs did you get a failed message or a "you were blocked" message?

Corn, why do you steal our powers? What is the point of it? I'm not sure I understand it too well. You say you're just a neutral survivor, right? No funky win condition?

Yes. I can leave the game early. If I steal 5 different powers, I can leave the game. I'm not told what power I steal. I'm not given any results based upon my night action. I only find out whether my number of stolen powers needed to leave goes down.

I'm still at 5. So the power that I stole last night from Quebbs must not be one of the powers that I'm looking for. I was not told what powers are the 5 that I need.

all that being said, please go back and look at the BOE game. This power is what IR claimed was his power. He had that power in mind for this game and he claimed it in the BOE game.

[Cornucopia]

I completely agree with this. VOTE Corn

If you're telling the truth, Corn, sorry, but at least we learned some more about the other people voting for you.

Hey, I'm telling the truth. But there's really no need for apologies. If I can win with either side, I think both town and mafia should let me live. That being said, if I were town and there was no other target to go after, then I would take out the neutral that can mess with night actions.

[Quebbster]

Yes. I can leave the game early. If I steal 5 different powers, I can leave the game. I'm not told what power I steal. I'm not given any results based upon my night action. I only find out whether my number of stolen powers needed to leave goes down.

I'm still at 5. So the power that I stole last night from Quebbs must not be one of the powers that I'm looking for. I was not told what powers are the 5 that I need.

all that being said, please go back and look at the BOE game. This power is what IR claimed was his power. He had that power in mind for this game and he claimed it in the BOE game.

That power was his actual power in BoE... but hey, pretty much all of us have borrowed cool power concepts from other games.
Keeping it a secret what powers you need to get does sound a little odd though.

[Cornucopia]

I don't think Corn ever implied I was a silencer. He just said my power was used on Darq. Darq ended up silenced, but that does not necessarily mean that my power was the one that silenced him.
That's sort of the reason I think Corn is a good lynch at this point though, to test the validity of Rokk's statement. If Corn is indeed Neutral Carlos Mencia, we know he told the truth as far as he knew it and that Rokk's info is not accurate. That's good info to get from the lynching of a Neutral.
If Corn is not who he says he is he should be lynched anyway. :)

Many people could have targeted Darq last night. So you may not be the mafia silencer. When I come up Carlos Mencia/Neutral, I do hope you are looked into though as it is possible that you're the mafia silencer.

[Quebbster]

Many people could have targeted Darq last night. So you may not be the mafia silencer. When I come up Carlos Mencia/Neutral, I do hope you are looked into though as it is possible that you're the mafia silencer.

I have no problem claiming if people feel it is warranted.

[Cornucopia]

That power was his actual power in BoE... but hey, pretty much all of us have borrowed cool power concepts from other games.
Keeping it a secret what powers you need to get does sound a little odd though.

Not getting information from my night actions also makes it difficult to take sides. I truly am a neutral survivor in the sense that I can't really help out either side. I can disrupt the night actions. My only real contribution would be a vote during the day phase.

My night action kind of limits how I can play the game. I was hoping to be left alone for a little bit so that I could collect some of the required powers and be seen as less of a threat and soon to leave the game. But this early makes it unlikely that I will not hang today.

Vote: Wade

[Rokk_Krinn]

Guys I'm pretty sure they're both up to shenanigans. Either is a good lynch but with time running low, Wade's not very feasible.

[Quebbster]

The main reason I do not change my vote right now is that I would like the mod to return and make a vote count.

[Immortal_Raven]

Totally official vote count:

Cornucopia(7): Mags, Jerry, Silver, JoH, Ouch, Rokk, normal
Wade (4): Mr S, Quebbs, SLVRSR4, Corn

You have approximately 3 hours. Phase ends exactly 24 hours from the original night 1 post. I'll grab a time in a sec.

[Quebbster]

change vote: Cornucopia

[Silver Lantern]

I think Corn is a good lynch. He's saying that his claim is what IR had in BoE and IR had an alternate win condition as an SK in that game. IR also knew what the powers he needed to steal were in that game. I would think that if anything, after a long game he would have made the role easier, not harder. Also the 5 powers that IR needed to steal were pretty broad IIRC, things like "an info gathering power, a kill, etc."

Quebs, can you think of any reason why whatever your power is, it would not satisfy one of those conditions for Corn here?

[Quebbster]

Quebs, can you think of any reason why whatever your power is, it would not satisfy one of those conditions for Corn here?
My power is not exotic and can be neatly categorized if that is what you are asking. In other words, not off the top of my head.

[Silver Lantern]

That's exactly what I was asking, thanks.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Wade's probably a good lynch for tomorrow and/or someone to be looked into tonight.

[Cornucopia]

Guys I'm pretty sure they're both up to shenanigans. Either is a good lynch but with time running low, Wade's not very feasible.

Wrong on half of that. No shenanigans here. Straight up honesty from me. I'm a neutral with nothing to lose, but my life. And I'm okay with losing it this early. I haven't invested that much time into this game. Wade is definitely worth looking into. However, my death should reveal that Rokk's info. may not be on the up and up. He was probably messed with last night. And if Quebbs is the mafia silencer, he's not exactly going to confirm that his power is silencing. Rarely do you see a town silencer.

[Cornucopia]

I think Corn is a good lynch. He's saying that his claim is what IR had in BoE and IR had an alternate win condition as an SK in that game. IR also knew what the powers he needed to steal were in that game. I would think that if anything, after a long game he would have made the role easier, not harder. Also the 5 powers that IR needed to steal were pretty broad IIRC, things like "an info gathering power, a kill, etc."

I didn't write the role. Simply playing it. I've told you everything that I was told. You'll see at end game.

I do not turn into a SK, nor am I the SK. So after I'm dead, the SK will still be around. Remember that.

[Truffle Shuffle]

Does nothing that will help the town, but could mess.

Vote: Corn

[Immortal_Raven]

Totally official vote count:

Cornucopia(9): Mags, Jerry, Silver, JoH, Ouch, Rokk, normal, Quebbs, Truffle
Wade (3): Mr S, SLVRSR4, Corn


A majority has been reached. Write-up coming shortly.

[Immortal_Raven]

Day 2: Copyright Infringement

The crowd moved decisively. If there’s one thing a comedian can’t stand, it’s other comedians taking their jokes. You wrote that, not them. That’s your intellectual property, that’s your livelyhood. Sadly, the Mexican did not understand that. He tried to explain that he wasn’t hurting anyone, but there is no sympathy from your peers when you broke rule number one. They grabbed him, stuffed him in the car, and drove him to the border. He was ticked, but the border patrol threw him in with the next group to be sent back, despite his insistance that he was a US citizen. The mob had conveniently left all evidence back at the comedy club in downtown Los Angeles.

Cornucopia has been deported. He was Carlos Mencia, alleged joke thief, Mexican, and smart-mouth extraordinaire.(neutral)


exBN25OdXxg

jpvC88ZJ8vI&feature=related

Night 2 begins now. You have 24 hours.

[Immortal_Raven]

Night 2: A whole lot of getting nothing done

“Dang it, why am I always the one doing the dirty work?! Really starting to piss me off. Ah well, best to be about it quickly. Now if only that idiot would come out of the laundromat.”

Our “hero” waited patiently in a dark alley behind the laudromat in East LA. All he wanted to do was conk his target over the head, and be done. Unfortunately, clothes are never finished after only one rinse cycle. Nevertheless, like a dutiful assassin, he waited. After a long wait, his target emerged. Jumping silently, he hit the person over the head with the crow bar. Not pausing to check his work, he ran off down the alley, leaving his victim to bleed to death. Or so he thought....


-----------------------------------------------------------------

Some time later.

The groggy man slowly got up.

“What the hell was that all about? He didn’t even take my wallet. Not like there’s much in there, but still. It’s the principle. You don’t go around clubbing people over the head for no reason.”

Well, almost no reason. And with that, the more lucid man was off about his business. Driving through LA, he came to a secluded house in a moderate neighborhood. He knew his target lived here. All he had to do was go inside, wait if necessary, and do the deed. Strange how he had initially done this for fun, and now does it for a career.

He gently picked the lock and stepped inside.

“I’ve been waiting for you” a shrill voice called from the living room.

“What? How did you know I’d come here?” the fully lucid man replied.

“One develops a sixth sense about such things. However, I do not want to kill you, and you should not want to kill me. We are kindred spirits in a way.”

“And what way is that?”

“We respect death, population control, and the pure pleasure of killing. We just go about it in different ways.”

“Uh huh.” said the lucid, yet unnerved man.

“I’ll make you a deal the first one continued. You leave my home in peace, or you leave my home in pieces.”

With that the lucid man left.

No one has died. With 16 players, 9 is majority.

This phase will end at 8:00 PM MST Saturday, February 19th.

Effective immediately
batfink has replaced The Darkstone
Cornucopia has replaced CrusaderC

[Jackofhearts2005]

Vote Conucopia :p



Yay nobody dying. Where has the darkstone gone?

[Magnito]

Lynch Quebbster

[Jackofhearts2005]

Looks like one mafia member tried to kill another killer (serial killer with bullerproofness?) and failed and then the 2nd killer tried to kill...another scummer? How odd.

[SLVRSR4]

hmmmm...my power failed last night. I don't know how that would have happened outside of a role block.

Edit: I just realized that the above post makes me look like a rabid killer. (I was not the attempted assassin if that helps.)

[Jackofhearts2005]

Fine by me. Vote: Quebbster

[SLVRSR4]

Yeah, it was quebbster that I tried my power on, so I am curious to know why:

LYNCH: Quebbster

[normalview]

While I can support voting for Quebbster (since it would seem Magnito has a good reason to do so), I would also like to find out why Ouchmaker was faking silence yesterday.

VOTE Ouchmaker

[Quebbster]

Lynch Quebbster
Yeah, it was quebbster that I tried my power on, so I am curious to know why:

LYNCH: Quebbster
Assuming I was jailkept then since my action failed.

Did I mention that I am from Europe, where history comes from?

[Cornucopia]

Looks like one mafia member tried to kill another killer (serial killer with bullerproofness?) and failed and then the 2nd killer tried to kill...another scummer? How odd.

I would agree with this evaluation. Except for the bullerproofness part. I'm not sure what that word is :laugh:

Vote: Quebbster

[normalview]

Did I mention that I am from Europe, where history comes from?

I sincerely doubt that, actually.

change VOTE Quebbster

[Quebbster]

I sincerely doubt that, actually.

change VOTE Quebbster
How so?

To be clear, I'm Eddie Izzard, Town, misdirector.

[Quebbster]

Both my actions have failed, but my night 1 target was deadshot042 and last night I targeted Ouchmaker.

[normalview]

How so?

To be clear, I'm Eddie Izzard, Town, misdirector.

Yes, I knew who you were hinting at. And, based on my information, that is a fake claim.

So between what I know and Magnito's seeming confidence in voting for you, I am pretty sure you are lying.

[Quebbster]

Yes, I knew who you were hinting at. And, based on my information, that is a fake claim.

So between what I know and Magnito's seeming confidence in voting for you, I am pretty sure you are lying.
I'm not lying, so your info is not accurate.
If I was going to fake claim I wouldn't pick the one role who was almost guaranteed to be here.

[normalview]

Yes, I knew who you were hinting at. And, based on my information, that is a fake claim.

So between what I know and Magnito's seeming confidence in voting for you, I am pretty sure you are lying.

And, for the record, I am still very intersted in knowing why Ouchmaker was pretending to be silenced yesterday.

[deadshot042]

Lynch Quebbster

Is it safe to assume you have a good reason for this? I'm a little lost as to why we're voting on Quebbs, so I'm holding my vote for now.

[normalview]

If I was going to fake claim I wouldn't pick the one role who was almost guaranteed to be here.


That's a matter of opinion. I know he's your favorite comedian, but that doesn't mean that the mod thinks so. Heck, I know if I was designing this game, I probably wouldn't have included Eddie Izzard. He's funny, no doubt, just not among my favorites.

[deadshot042]

I probably would have included Izzard, but he's hardly a guaranteed role.

[Quebbster]

That's a matter of opinion. I know he's your favorite comedian, but that doesn't mean that the mod thinks so. Heck, I know if I was designing this game, I probably wouldn't have included Eddie Izzard. He's funny, no doubt, just not among my favorites.
You do know what the mod's first game here was, right?

[SLVRSR4]

You do know what the mod's first game here was, right?

Did you hear that Engelbert Humperdink died today? :sleep:

No he didn't :laugh:

Yes, Yes he did.....:(

no, he didn't :rolleyes:

[normalview]

You do know what the mod's first game here was, right?

My first game was Weird Al and even though I have the entire Weird Al Show on DVD, I haven't included it in any DVD Marthon games ;)

[Quebbster]

My first game was Weird Al and even though I have the entire Weird Al Show on DVD, I haven't included it in any DVD Marthon games ;)
Yeah, because it fits so well with Scooby Doo or Super Friends... :)

It's interesting that you don't even seem to consider the possibility of misdirection though.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I would agree with this evaluation. Except for the bullerproofness part. I'm not sure what that word is :laugh:

Vote: Quebbster

It means you're okay with people skipping school.

[Immortal_Raven]

Vote Count:

Quebbs(5): Joh, Mags, normal, Corn, SLVRSR4

9 is majority.

[deadshot042]

I guess the flipside to the Izzard argument is that even if he is here, there's no reason to think he's batting for the town. If the mod's a big fan, then why not give him a prominent role?

The mafia theme could be British or European comedians.

[normalview]

I guess the flipside to the Izzard argument is that even if he is here, there's no reason to think he's batting for the town. If the mod's a big fan, then why not give him a prominent role?

The mafia theme could be British or European comedians.

Also true. But I really don't think Quebbster is Eddie Izzard.

[Jerry_Damage01]

Checking in for the day. Quebbster is at half so I'm going to hold my vote for now.

[Quebbster]

I guess the flipside to the Izzard argument is that even if he is here, there's no reason to think he's batting for the town. If the mod's a big fan, then why not give him a prominent role?

The mafia theme could be British or European comedians.
I'm not stupid enough to claim my actual role when I am scum.
And with no dead Mafians, there's no way to tell the theme.

[batfink]

I'm not stupid enough to claim my actual role when I am scum.
And with no dead Mafians, there's no way to tell the theme.

Sooo, this is a false claim?

[Quebbster]

Sooo, this is a false claim?
Noooooo. I have already pointed out that I am not lying.
I have claimed in full, and all normalview has said is "that's not right". Magnito hasn't said why he started the train. At this point in the game and in the phase, I don't think that is enough to convict. But then it's not really up to me to decide...

[batfink]

Unless someone RTed Mags there is no way to know if he was misdirected for sure. Common wisdom is to believe the Cop, its how we won BOE so quickly. However, thsi is a fast moving train, and the day is young. I'll wait to vote.

[Quebbster]

Unless someone RTed Mags there is no way to know if he was misdirected for sure. Common wisdom is to believe the Cop, its how we won BOE so quickly. However, thsi is a fast moving train, and the day is young. I'll wait to vote.
I don't think Mags is the cop, given what has been said in the thread so far.

I'm getting a big scum feeling from deadshot though - I tried to MD him on night 1 because I had a feeling he was trying to steer pressure away from Wade, and now it seems like he is trying to implicate me without actually voting. Could just be paranoia though.

[deadshot042]

Magnito hasn't said why he started the train. At this point in the game and in the phase, I don't think that is enough to convict. But then it's not really up to me to decide...

Ordinarily it's a good idea to follow information gatherers at this point. :ermm:

[deadshot042]

I'm getting a big scum feeling from deadshot though - I tried to MD him on night 1 because I had a feeling he was trying to steer pressure away from Wade, and now it seems like he is trying to implicate me without actually voting. Could just be paranoia though.

I'd vote for pressure, but you're already at five. I'm not sure you're scum, so I'm trying to figure it out.

[Quebbster]

Ordinarily it's a good idea to follow information gatherers at this point. :ermm:
*shrugs* I like to give people the benefit of the doubt. Mags may not be an info gatherer at all, and whatever normalview has is either not accurate or misinterpreted.

[Quebbster]

I'd vote for pressure, but you're already at five. I'm not sure you're scum, so I'm trying to figure it out.

Let me know if I can be of assistance. My hunches are often wrong, but I figured it was worth sharing.

[deadshot042]

Quebbs, you only MD people, but I failed altogether on Night 1.

[Quebbster]

Quebbs, you only MD people, but I failed altogether on Night 1.
Not my fault. I was blocked by Corn on night 1, so someone else blocked you.

[Quebbster]

By the way, before I go to bed I want to point out that this:
While I can support voting for Quebbster (since it would seem Magnito has a good reason to do so), I would also like to find out why Ouchmaker was faking silence yesterday.

VOTE Ouchmaker
is also not accurate. Ouch made a post yesterday:
Look at his power description, and the fact that Mencia has more than once stolen material from other comedians. Why would he be anything else (except maybe Mafia).

Vote: Cornucopia
That was the 7th vote in Corn's lynch train, mere hours after the thread had started, and the main reason I targeted him last night.

[Truffle Shuffle]

Interesting. Not sure in which direction to go here. Normal and Mags, to have two people saying you're vote worthy isn't good. Yet deadshot is also making me itch with his postings. Really torn here.

[Quebbster]

Interesting. Not sure in which direction to go here. Normal and Mags, to have two people saying you're vote worthy isn't good. Yet deadshot is also making me itch with his postings. Really torn here.
There's more than 24 hours left in the phase. I think you have time to explore other options. Particularly since I am a waste of time - I have already given all I have to give.

[Silver Lantern]

Yes, I knew who you were hinting at. And, based on my information, that is a fake claim.

So between what I know and Magnito's seeming confidence in voting for you, I am pretty sure you are lying.

So now you too are backing up this lynch train with "information?"

That's pretty damning Quebs.

Yeah, because it fits so well with Scooby Doo or Super Friends... :)

It's interesting that you don't even seem to consider the possibility of misdirection though.

Unless someone RTed Mags there is no way to know if he was misdirected for sure. Common wisdom is to believe the Cop, its how we won BOE so quickly. However, thsi is a fast moving train, and the day is young. I'll wait to vote.

Since I had called for Mags to be RTed and Guided, there should have been no Misdirection going on.

Funny how there is relatively no pressure on Wade today though despite being outted as the silencer last day phase...

Vote: Quebs

If it was only Mags, I'd give you the benefit of the doubt Quebby, but apparently NV also has something to doubt your claim.

[Mr Stranger]

I can guarantee that Quebbster is town.

So stop voting for him.

[DarqFeonix]

Guarantee? Really?

Can you also guarantee he's not a Silencer? If he's not, that means Wade silenced me yesterday, right?

Appears Quebbs was Jailkept, and there's no one silenced today, so still seems good

[Mr Stranger]

Guarantee? Really?

Can you also guarantee he's not a Silencer? If he's not, that means Wade silenced me yesterday, right?

Appears Quebbs was Jailkept, and there's no one silenced today, so still seems good

I don't know if he's a silencer or not, that part I can't prove.

But I know for certain that Quebbs is town (even though misdirectors and whatnot could exist).

[Wade Wilson]

So you aren't actually certain then? That part you put in parenthesis seems to contradict what you just said in the actual sentence. I think Magnito is trying to claim a roleblocker not a cop though and he noticed that no one was silenced this phase...granted I could be wrong on that, just the vibe I get from him. I have had a scum vibe from Quebb since last phase but I think I have been getting misdirected since day 1 :-/

[Mr Stranger]

So you aren't actually certain then? That part you put in parenthesis seems to contradict what you just said in the actual sentence. I think Magnito is trying to claim a roleblocker not a cop though and he noticed that no one was silenced this phase...granted I could be wrong on that, just the vibe I get from him. I have had a scum vibe from Quebb since last phase but I think I have been getting misdirected since day 1 :-/

I knew that came out oddly.

I meant to say that, even though there are probably misdirectors and whatnot in the game, I can STILL guarantee that Quebbs is town.

[Wade Wilson]

So you are masoned to him?

[Mr Stranger]

So you are masoned to him?

No, not masoned.

And that's all I'm going to say as I'm sure this has already put a target on my head.

So trust what I know, because I am not wrong on this one.

[Wade Wilson]

So what I am getting is that you believe Quebbs to be town from your information? No way to be certain, there is probably about a 25% chance of not getting good results this early in the game with only one death. That is factoring in misdirection, busdriving, and town cloaks.

So...do we pressure deadshot now then if you guys are ok with this information? (sorry Mr Stranger, just from your posts I am getting a "I want to believe my information is correct but I am not sure" feeling from them.)

[Mr Stranger]

So what I am getting is that you believe Quebbs to be town from your information? No way to be certain, there is probably about a 25% chance of not getting good results this early in the game with only one death. That is factoring in misdirection, busdriving, and town cloaks.

So...do we pressure deadshot now then if you guys are ok with this information? (sorry Mr Stranger, just from your posts I am getting a "I want to believe my information is correct but I am not sure" feeling from them.)

I'll try this one more time.

I am 100% sure Quebbster is town.

No other effects could have influenced that information. At all.

Now if you want to move onto someone else then I'm good with that.

Vote: Deadshot

[Truffle Shuffle]

I seem to have posted this in the wrong game. My bad. Anyway, I was going to vote Wade, since we were wondering on the silencing, but I can get behind voting for deadshot.

Vote: deadshot

[Wade Wilson]

Still getting that feeling a bit but I think it's just the way you've been posting it LOL don't worry about it, things will balance out after a bit.

lynch Deadshot

[normalview]

By the way, before I go to bed I want to point out that this:

is also not accurate. Ouch made a post yesterday:

That was the 7th vote in Corn's lynch train, mere hours after the thread had started, and the main reason I targeted him last night.

Huh.

No idea how I missed that. My notes had Ouch, CrusaderC (who was replaced), and The Darkstone (also replaced) as not posting. Since it was pretty obvious that the two who were replaced were not posting because they weren't actually participating, it seemed pretty odd that Ouch was trying to fake silence even though we knew DF had been the actual target.

But anyway, yeah, I'll stop badgering him now.

YOU though, Quebbster, I am still pretty sure you're not on the level. It is possible my information is flawed (it always is in these games) and if someone can give me a MUCH better lynch target, I'll switch my vote... but it stays for now.

[Immortal_Raven]

Vote Count:

Quebbs(6): Joh, Mags, normal, Corn, SLVRSR4, Silver
Deashot(3): Wade, Truffle, Stranger

9 is majority. You have roughly 24 hours.

[Ouchmaker]

While I can support voting for Quebbster (since it would seem Magnito has a good reason to do so), I would also like to find out why Ouchmaker was faking silence yesterday.

VOTE Ouchmaker

*looks at last day's voting*
*looks at normal*
*looks at last day's voting*

So, you saw me there, knew I voted. You were aiming that vote gun, going through possible scum to lynch, aiming the gun at them, and then you turned around and shot at me. Is that pretty much what happened? That's, that's not even hunting.

:cheeky:

Both my actions have failed, but my night 1 target was deadshot042 and last night I targeted Ouchmaker.

And why target me? Because I wanted to vote off a neutral that was also a "comedian" that I disliked?

[normalview]

*looks at last day's voting*
*looks at normal*
*looks at last day's voting*

So, you saw me there, knew I voted. You were aiming that vote gun, going through possible scum to lynch, aiming the gun at them, and then you turned around and shot at me. Is that pretty much what happened? That's, that's not even hunting.

:cheeky:

That post actually makes absolutely no sense to me. I have no idea what you mean by "hunting" and "looking for possible scum" other than what I already explained in my last post: as far as I could tell (looking at my notes), you had not posted.

That was a mistake, obviously, and I admitted as such once it was called to my attention.

Relax.

[Ouchmaker]

That post actually makes absolutely no sense to me. I have no idea what you mean by "hunting" and "looking for possible scum" other than what I already explained in my last post: as far as I could tell (looking at my notes), you had not posted.

That was a mistake, obviously, and I admitted as such once it was called to my attention.

Relax.

It would have made more sense if you'd have known the source material. And if Quebbs hadn't told you that you made a mistake earlier. :p

[SLVRSR4]

Just got back from my venue. Why are we putting pressure on Deadshot?

[Quebbster]

YOU though, Quebbster, I am still pretty sure you're not on the level. It is possible my information is flawed (it always is in these games) and if someone can give me a MUCH better lynch target, I'll switch my vote... but it stays for now.
Can't say I blame you - you are your own best friend after all. It's just frustrating to come clean and still be accused on unclear grounds. Particularly when you have a really fun role...
And why target me? Because I wanted to vote off a neutral that was also a "comedian" that I disliked?
Because you placed a seventh vote, out of nine required, within hours of the game opening. To me, that looked like trying to rush the vote.

I'm a little wary of the deadshot vote since Wade started it, but at this point it would probably be hypocritical of me not to vote.

Vote deadshot

[DarqFeonix]

I'm confused because Rokk seemed pretty confident Wade silenced me N1... Right? Or am I mixing up games.

[Mr Stranger]

I'm confused because Rokk seemed pretty confident Wade silenced me N1... Right? Or am I mixing up games.

Wade is most likely the silencer.

I just thought I could deal with that myself tonight.

[Quebbster]

Hey Darq, any chance you could confirm being misdirected on night 1?

[DarqFeonix]

Hey Darq, any chance you could confirm being misdirected on night 1?

*shrug*

It's possible. No way to know.

[Quebbster]

*shrug*

It's possible. No way to know.
Figured as much, but it doesn't hurt to ask.

[Jerry_Damage01]

I can guarantee that Quebbster is town.

So stop voting for him.

Quick question, if you targeted Quebbs, what night did you do it on? Last night or Night 1?

[Cornucopia]

Change vote: deadshot

I'll add to the pressure.

[Cornucopia]

I seem to have posted this in the wrong game. My bad. Anyway, I was going to vote Wade, since we were wondering on the silencing, but I can get behind voting for deadshot.

Vote: deadshot

Happy Belated Birthday Truffs! Sorry for not posting this yesterday.

[Immortal_Raven]

Vote Count:

Quebbs(5): Joh, Mags, normal, SLVRSR4, Silver
Deadshot(5): Wade, Truffle, Stranger, Quebbs, Corn

9 is majority. You have roughly 12 hours.

[normalview]

Vote Count:

Quebbs(6): Joh, Mags, normal, Corn, SLVRSR4, Silver
Deadshot(5): Wade, Truffle, Stranger, Quebbs, Corn

9 is majority. You have roughly 12 hours.

You have Corn on both votes.

[Immortal_Raven]

You have Corn on both votes.

Surely you jest. I love not fearing a modkill for editing.

[SLVRSR4]

Have we gotten a RC from Deadshot yet?

Change Vote:

Lynch: Deadshot

[batfink]

Wait, i'm trying to catch up here.
We're voting for Deadshot because the guy the Cop fingered as mafia has a "bad feeling" about him? Really?
Lynch Quebbs.

[batfink]

Masoned, or is that you all decided on the Proboards?

No, not masoned.

And that's all I'm going to say as I'm sure this has already put a target on my head.

So trust what I know, because I am not wrong on this one.

[Quebbster]

Wait, i'm trying to catch up here.
We're voting for Deadshot because the guy the Cop fingered as mafia has a "bad feeling" about him? Really?
Lynch Quebbs.
No one has said I am mafia. You are inferring a lot.

Remove vote as it's getting too close for comfort.

[Wade Wilson]

I thought Stranger was the cop :-s

[normalview]

I thought Stranger was the cop :-s

That seems to be what he's hinting at, but he's never come out and said it. Also, it seems a little off to out yourself like that without being able to offer an alternative (scummy) target.

Yeah, you might save an townie that is being wrongfully accused, but now everyone knows who you are and there is really not a whole lot to show for it. Seems a big risk to take... which is why I am not really buying that Stranger is the cop.

[Quebbster]

I thought Stranger was the cop :-s
He's the only one who has said anything about my alignment, at least.

[Jerry_Damage01]

If anyone targeted Quebbs, what night did you do it? Night 1 or last night?

[Wade Wilson]

That seems to be what he's hinting at, but he's never come out and said it. Also, it seems a little off to out yourself like that without being able to offer an alternative (scummy) target.

Yeah, you might save an townie that is being wrongfully accused, but now everyone knows who you are and there is really not a whole lot to show for it. Seems a big risk to take... which is why I am not really buying that Stranger is the cop.

The way he was posting was making him seem like he wasn't too sure on his results. He could be masoned with the cop but he isn't sure if they are the cop or not :-/

[normalview]

If anyone targeted Quebbs, what night did you do it? Night 1 or last night?

I targeted him night 1.

[Quebbster]

That seems to be what he's hinting at, but he's never come out and said it. Also, it seems a little off to out yourself like that without being able to offer an alternative (scummy) target.

Yeah, you might save an townie that is being wrongfully accused, but now everyone knows who you are and there is really not a whole lot to show for it. Seems a big risk to take... which is why I am not really buying that Stranger is the cop.
See, the way I see things, Townie lynches is a bad thing.
Also, if you let a townie be lynched, it might look bad later when you claim.
In theory, at least. :)

[Wade Wilson]

See, the way I see things, Townie lynches is a bad thing.
Also, if you let a townie be lynched, it might look bad later when you claim.
In theory, at least. :)

Not really, got to lynch Townies from time to time to weed out the mafia. Sometimes information is bad as there are a lot of things that can happen. Framing, misdirection, cloaks, millers, insane cops, etc...

[Quebbster]

Not really, got to lynch Townies from time to time to weed out the mafia. Sometimes information is bad as there are a lot of things that can happen. Framing, misdirection, cloaks, millers, insane cops, etc...
Yeah, but the more information is on the table, the better the lynches tend to be. If you lynch me and I turn up Town (which I will), then you'll know to trust Stranger more than Magnito or normalview.

[DarqFeonix]

Jerry's question was mainly towards Stramger, I think. Witchweed was likely JK last night, so tree should be no info on him

[Quebbster]

Jerry's question was mainly towards Stramger, I think. Witchweed was likely JK last night, so tree should be no info on him

Autocorrect?

[Wade Wilson]

Yeah, but the more information is on the table, the better the lynches tend to be. If you lynch me and I turn up Town (which I will), then you'll know to trust Stranger more than Magnito or normalview.

So you are saying that lynching you would give the town information.

Jerry's question was mainly towards Stramger, I think. Witchweed was likely JK last night, so tree should be no info on him

Witchweed, tree? You at some plant expo?

[Jerry_Damage01]

Jerry's question was mainly towards Stramger, I think. Witchweed was likely JK last night, so tree should be no info on him

Autocorrect?

I bet he's posting from an Ipad. Which makes me want to vote for him. :p

[DarqFeonix]

Wow, Witchweed = Quebbster. That one was bad

[Jerry_Damage01]

Wow, Witchweed = Quebbster. That one was bad

AHA! So Quebbster is NOT Eddie Izzard and is instead the dread comic Witchweed!

[Quebbster]

So you are saying that lynching you would give the town information.
Of course it would. The real question is if it is worth following the lead of two people who won't share their info, against the advice of someone who actually shares their info.
Wow, Witchweed = Quebbster. That one was bad
If by "bad" you mean "hilarious" then I agree.

[deadshot042]

I am John Heffron, the winner of Last Comic Standing 2.