What should my next game be?

[Peers]

Since things are moving fairly quickly towards the end of You Make The Game 1, it's time to decide on a theme for my next game.

1) Friendship Is Magic -- Apparently the previous My Little Pony game didn't get to the finish line, so maybe a change of jockey is in order... I'm not the world's biggest brony, but I think I know enough to handle the reins here.

2) Boardgame Mafia -- Everyone knows that it's easier to pick a boardgame to buy when there's only a few left on the shelves -- Will Bang! knock Settlers of Catan off the shelf? Will Pandemic convince people to team up? Will old classics like Fireball Island revel in the nostalgia factor? Will anyone look at the role list at the end of the game and say, "Yeah, I know all those games"?

3) Cops: Mafia -- Bad boys, bad boys, whatcha gonna do? Robbery in progress? Domestic dispute? Bar fight? The boys in blue are here to shut you down. Will there be law and order, or will criminals overwhelm the law?

4) Mathmafia -- Every player has a score from 1 to 5, and each night the player with the highest score is killed. But where the town can make minor plusses and minuses to scores, the Mafia can multiply, and the 'doctor' can divide

[FurbyFrank]

Board game, and can I be Arkham Horror?
:D

[gfishfunk]

Bam. Boardgames.

[sstralkowski]

Mathman, Mathman, Mathman! omnomnomnom

[Peers]

Hrm. Remind me to add an option for "Dude, your last game sucked, why would I play in another one?"

[sstralkowski]

So is it that I posted that reminded you of this option?
:laugh:

[Peers]

No, just a hunch. :)

[spworldtour]

Peers, to be honest, I love boardgames, I'd love to break out some boardgame madness, but I doubt most people will have the same love for them as me.

Then again, all 3 of your chose your own doom ones are pretty silly. And math would be super dang difficult to figure out. But clever. The what could go wrong one actually seemed to have a lot of promise. I stopped following once I died, but I like the idea of having more info

[gfishfunk]

I was playing with the idea of beer pong mafia.

[sstralkowski]

I think it was IR who ran a "make a request" boardgame mafia. I chose BattleMage maybe? The one with the huge floor map where you have a series of units to move. The bad guys have a giant ogre and the good guys have a cannon. That was fun.

[Peers]

I think it was IR who ran a "make a request" boardgame mafia. I chose BattleMage maybe? The one with the huge floor map where you have a series of units to move. The bad guys have a giant ogre and the good guys have a cannon. That was fun.

I have that one. Or, had. I think I co-opted most of the figures to use with Warhammer Fantasy, since they were the same sculpts... just far less expensive.