I would recommend a relic/object that can be picked up on a 5 or 6, as opposed one that can only be picked up on a 6.
Obviously, the Hulk with the Power Gem would be a wrecking machine. The Soul Gem is a good fit for him as well, granting him Steal Energy, as he'll be in the thickest of the fighting for most of your battles.
Having the Red Lantern near the Hulk would give him a nice damage boost, but don't have him carry it, because he will use it as a light object in his first attack.
The Scorpio Key is a good fit for either Samuel L. Fury or Hawkeye, and you've got two different chances at picking it up. They would both benefit from the Crimson Gem as well.
... does anyone else have this nagging feeling that there should be a section in the next Rulebook, right before the Glossary, titled "Perspective"? My mods page!
Check my H/W button for trades!