If you've ever been on the Marvel comics forum (I have...1,000+ posts say so) you will have noticed this type of game present there:

name1 [10]
name2 [10]
name3 [10]
name4 [10]
etc.

Now, on the Mravel forums, names1234 were generally replaced with X-Men, Avengers, writers, etc. Each time you voted you subtracted 1 (one) from that characters total, indicated by brackets, [ ], and added one to a different character.

A round may look like this:

name1 [9] -1
name2 [10]
name3 [11] +1
name4 [10]

Everytime you vote, you subtract one, then add one to a different character. The game ends when all but one character has been eliminated. A character is eliminated by having no more value, or when its total reaches zero. A eliminated character cannot be voted for.

Hopefully that made sense, and hopefully this will catch on. If you choose to vote, please do so in 1-2 hour intervals to be fair. So, without further ado...

JL Super Rares: (I will start the voting)


Shining Knight [10]
Power Ring [09] -1
Lobo [10]
Amazo [10]
Bib Barda & Mister Miracle [10]
Doomsday [11] +1
Green Lantern [10]
Time Trapper [10]
Flash [10]
Batman [10]
Wonder Woman [10]
Superman [10]

Shining Knight [9] -1
Power Ring [09] -1
Lobo [10]
Amazo [10]
Bib Barda & Mister Miracle [10]
Doomsday [12] +1
Green Lantern [10]
Time Trapper [10]
Flash [10]
Batman [10]
Wonder Woman [10]
Superman [10]

Just an aesthetic note, you only have to show the plus/minus from your own vote, to avoid clutter. Thanks for voting, Funk!

Shining Knight [10] +1
Wonder Woman [09] -1

Shining Knight [10]
Power Ring [09]
Lobo [10]=1
Amazo [10]
Bib Barda & Mister Miracle [10]
Doomsday [12]
Green Lantern [10]
Time Trapper [10]
Flash [10]
Batman [10]
Wonder Woman [8]-1
Superman [10]

My bet is Guy or Lobo will win.

Lobo +1
Flash -1

Shining Knight [10]
Power Ring [09]
Lobo [09] -1
Amazo [10]
Bib Barda & Mister Miracle [10]
Doomsday [12]
Green Lantern [10]
Time Trapper [11] +1
Flash [10]
Batman [10]
Wonder Woman [8]
Superman [10]

Actually, you would logically want to include the previous one and show the total, otherwise a person would have to calculate every post in order to make their selection.

My vote:

Shining Knight [9] -1
Power Ring [09]
Lobo [10]
Amazo [10]
Bib Barda & Mister Miracle [10]
Doomsday [13] +1
Green Lantern [10]
Time Trapper [10]
Flash [10]
Batman [10]
Wonder Woman [9]
Superman [10]

Shouldn't this be in the Arcade?

Zingo, you didn't copypasta mine. Time Trapper is at 11 and Lobo was at 9

Shining Knight [9] -1
Power Ring [09]
Lobo [10] +1
Amazo [10]
Bib Barda & Mister Miracle [10] +1
Doomsday [14] +1
Green Lantern [10]
Time Trapper [10]
Flash [10]
Batman [10]
Wonder Woman [9] -1
Superman [10] -1

The scoring's already messed up. (I had a post that fixed it but I accidently deleted it, grr)

Doomsday +1
Lobo -1

Technically, bit it is also heroclix related, so it's allowed in general discussion!

lobo +1
batman +1